carey wrote:The Sleeping Giant wrote:I think you are even more defensive mal.
Warner watches it straight in to the gloves and walks says it all really Warner had the best view of everyone including the keeper. Yet gets called back
Tend to agree but in saying that Stokes who by the time had followed through wasn't much further away looked dissapointed as if he thought it hadn't carried.
If Warner believes the keeper caught it and that's why he walked then he probably shouldn't have come back.
Personally the umpires should have asked the keeper and his answer should have been taken as the truth, with all the technology around I doubt a player would claim a catch unless he was extremely confident he caught it