Free agents/Trade discussion

[MatteeG]

MatteeG, as a Hawks supporter, who do you consider the better defender...Gilham or Schoenmakers (not trolling just a question)

Gilham at the moment. But he cant get on the park, and hasnt been able for a lot of the time since 08. The leg injuries have taken their toll. From a future perspective the Shoe has much more to offer, particularly if we can get him off the gorillas!

[Brodlach]

MatteeG, as a Hawks supporter, who do you consider the better defender...Gilham or Schoenmakers (not trolling just a question)

Gilham at the moment. But he cant get on the park, and hasnt been able for a lot of the time since 08. The leg injuries have taken their toll. From a future perspective the Shoe has much more to offer, particularly if we can get him off the gorillas!

Thanks mate, do you think he will be delisted?

[MatteeG]

Hope not. We need someone when Lake breaks down.....

[carey]

I heard a rumour that Port are looking at trading Jacobs to St Kilda for Dal Santo and a draft pick. I heard it from some guys at work, but dont know how true it is. I cant find anything about it anywhere.

Anyone else heard anything like this? Would be a good deal for Port if true.

Sounds B/S to me...

[HH3]

I heard a rumour that Port are looking at trading Jacobs to St Kilda for Dal Santo and a draft pick. I heard it from some guys at work, but dont know how true it is. I cant find anything about it anywhere.

Anyone else heard anything like this? Would be a good deal for Port if true.

Sounds B/S to me...

Apparently it came up as a possibility in the trade ticker thing on news.com.au. one of those chat thingos they have. whoever the "expert" on there said it.

[Rik E Boy]

MatteeG, as a Hawks supporter, who do you consider the better defender...Gilham or Schoenmakers (not trolling just a question)

Gilham at the moment. But he cant get on the park, and hasnt been able for a lot of the time since 08. The leg injuries have taken their toll. From a future perspective the Shoe has much more to offer, particularly if we can get him off the gorillas!

Gilham? What's he done again? Surely Shoey is in front. He's played some reasonable footy this year I thought.

regards,

REB

[Brodlach]

David Rodan now a Melbourne player after being traded for a late round draft pick. Good pickup for them, now they just have to get the ball to him.

[Johno6]

yeah i rate rodan

other possible movements
aaron edwards to tigers from north
stevenson to port from eagles
cripps and morton to eagles


any others being mentioned?>

[Brodlach]

yeah i rate rodan

other possible movements
aaron edwards to tigers from north
stevenson to port from eagles
cripps and morton to eagles


any others being mentioned?>

Edwards to Tigers would be interesting, would have thought he would get in Riewoldts way.

Who is Stephenson Johno?

[Johno6]

to be honest not entirely sure, played 10 games in 2010 i dont really remember him.

port also after cambell heath from swans

[MatteeG]

MatteeG, as a Hawks supporter, who do you consider the better defender...Gilham or Schoenmakers (not trolling just a question)

Gilham at the moment. But he cant get on the park, and hasnt been able for a lot of the time since 08. The leg injuries have taken their toll. From a future perspective the Shoe has much more to offer, particularly if we can get him off the gorillas!

Gilham? What's he done again? Surely Shoey is in front. He's played some reasonable footy this year I thought.

regards,

REB

He asked me who was the better defender REB. I agree the Shoe has been pretty handy on occasions this year, and much more valuable thaan Gilham during 2012. As a fully fit defender now I'd take Gilham.

But he aint never fully fit no more Guv.

[Brodlach]

Jordan Russell signs with Collingwood

[scoob]

Jordan Russell signs with Collingwood

A spud to cover a spud in Maxwell - their backline looking like a potato bake!

[Brodlach]

David Rodan now a Melbourne player after being traded for a late round draft pick. Good pickup for them, now they just have to get the ball to him.

Pick 88

[The Sleeping Giant]

Jordan Russell signs with Collingwood

A spud to cover a spud in Maxwell - their backline looking like a potato bake!

A few clubs are doing a good job at trading/free agent signing themselves out of finals footy.

[Johno6]

trying to strengthen teh vfl and sanfl?

[Brodlach]

Jordan Russell signs with Collingwood

For pick 71

[scoob]

Jordan Russell signs with Collingwood

A spud to cover a spud in Maxwell - their backline looking like a potato bake!

A few clubs are doing a good job at trading/free agent signing themselves out of finals footy.

Since when is Peter Rhode working at Collingwood?

[stan]

Rodan to Melbourne for pick 88.
Russell to Collingwood for pick 71.

I think Rodan will still go alright, Russell might be handy if he can get back to his best. He is a good player when up and going.

[hearts on fire]

Lewis Stevenson from West Coast to Port Adelaide for pick 88.