by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 2:24 pm
by Footy Smart » Tue Sep 18, 2012 2:59 pm
scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:02 pm
Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
by Pag » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:04 pm
Those stats say Maric was better than both.scoob wrote:Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
Just proved my point thats Footy Smart... and as for a troll post which part of that was trolling - just mentioning my opinions and the facts back them up. Thanks Mate
by Footy Smart » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:08 pm
scoob wrote:Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
Just proved my point thats Footy Smart... and as for a troll post which part of that was trolling - just mentioning my opinions and the facts back them up. Thanks Mate
by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:21 pm
Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
Just proved my point thats Footy Smart... and as for a troll post which part of that was trolling - just mentioning my opinions and the facts back them up. Thanks Mate
Incorrect troll. Your trolling was clear regarding who Ivan/Sam plays for.
The stats support Ivan no doubt, while they also suggest you opinion re Sauce's work around the ground is incorrect2 possessions less that Ivan and more than the AA ruckman
cheers
by Footy Smart » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:28 pm
I would propose that Nic Nat's disposals would be a bit more damaging than Jacobs and Maric for that matter, considering he plays around the ground more like a ruck rover than a ruckman dishing of handballs.
But hey, thats my opinion and my points about who they play for is valid considering everyone is outraged over Jacobs yet Maric stats are better. So go and troll on that.
by helicopterking » Tue Sep 18, 2012 3:40 pm
by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:00 pm
Footy Smart wrote:I would propose that Nic Nat's disposals would be a bit more damaging than Jacobs and Maric for that matter, considering he plays around the ground more like a ruck rover than a ruckman dishing of handballs.
But hey, thats my opinion and my points about who they play for is valid considering everyone is outraged over Jacobs yet Maric stats are better. So go and troll on that.
Naturally AFC fans want Sauce in, Maric missed a few games late in the year didnt he? Id be happy with Maric or Jacobs in the team.
As for NicNats possessions being more damaging, id question that. Nic often makes the basics look hard and the impossible easy. Sauce is far mor steady, provides a marking outlet of half back and skills are pretty good for a big man. Maric alround game has improved massively as well
by Footy Smart » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:18 pm
scoob wrote:Footy Smart wrote:I would propose that Nic Nat's disposals would be a bit more damaging than Jacobs and Maric for that matter, considering he plays around the ground more like a ruck rover than a ruckman dishing of handballs.
But hey, thats my opinion and my points about who they play for is valid considering everyone is outraged over Jacobs yet Maric stats are better. So go and troll on that.
Naturally AFC fans want Sauce in, Maric missed a few games late in the year didnt he? Id be happy with Maric or Jacobs in the team.
As for NicNats possessions being more damaging, id question that. Nic often makes the basics look hard and the impossible easy. Sauce is far mor steady, provides a marking outlet of half back and skills are pretty good for a big man. Maric alround game has improved massively as well
If you were rose coloured glasses that doesn't make me a troll!
by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:23 pm
Footy Smart wrote:Hondo wrote:I think NicNat had a better year than Jacobs personally
Not by much but still better
I reckon NicNat will be a mainstay of future AA teams
IMO NIcNat is over rated, he does flashes of brilliance, then stuffs up the basics and goes missing for large chunks of games. A future star no doubt but to say he has had a better year than sauce OR IVAN MARIC?
by scoob » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:35 pm
Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
by Squids » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:36 pm
by woodublieve12 » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:39 pm
by Squids » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:43 pm
woodublieve12 wrote:Surely Leroy Jetta over Rioli????
by OnSong » Tue Sep 18, 2012 4:49 pm
Squids wrote:woodublieve12 wrote:Surely Leroy Jetta over Rioli????
Did you just ring triple m?
by NO-MERCY » Tue Sep 18, 2012 5:17 pm
Pag wrote:Josh Gibson unbelievably unlucky to at least claim a spot on the bench that's full of midfielders.
Jack Riewoldt won the Coleman but didn't deserve a spot IMO, and I watch him every week.
Naitanui and Rioli shouldn't be there, their best 10 games are amazing but their bad 10 are not AA worthy.
by The Dark Knight » Tue Sep 18, 2012 5:32 pm
Pag wrote:Josh Gibson unbelievably unlucky to at least claim a spot on the bench that's full of midfielders.
by helicopterking » Tue Sep 18, 2012 6:12 pm
Footy Smart wrote:scoob wrote:Jacobs is a good tap ruckman but doesn't do near enough to be All Australian... Big Ivan woul dbe in front of him IMO, but then again he doesn't play for the crows anymore.
Nothing to do with who they play for. Your stupid troll efforts once again shizenhousen
Nic Nat......... Ave Disposals 13.0 - 24.7 HO 24-14
Sam Jacobs......... Ave Disposals 13.6 - 30.6 HO 7-8
Ivan Maric ......... Ave Disposals 15.9 - 31 HO 7-6
from this id say Sam doesnt do to bad around the ground
by helicopterking » Tue Sep 18, 2012 6:20 pm
Squids wrote:Listening to the justification of certain players being selected. I have concluded the judges have searched for random stats to justify their selections. It almost as if certain players have to be selected no matter what.
Darren Glass captain? He never plays on the best forward, he plays in the backline. Jobe Watson dragged his team over the line in a few games. A terrible choice by these hack judges.
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |