Rnd 24 - Central v North POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

[CENTURION]

James found not guilty because He didn't do anything. The facts are...Clinch belted James full-on in the face, behind play. Luckily James was wearing a mouth guard...if he wasn't, He would have lost a couple of teeth. He still sustained some injuries around the mouth & nose & the upper gum. No wonder the twins were angry.

[sjt]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

[Mic]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

[CENTURION]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

maybe you should become an optometrist then & hand out glasses to the umpires! Obviously they haven't seen what you have!! What will you & all the other sooks have to whinge about next year & beyond??

[sjt]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

Simple, you think missing potentially two finals games for hitting a person behind play is "worth it". Strange thought process. I wonder if he thinks it's worth it. He may never get the opportunity to play finals football again (hopefully).

[Mic]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

maybe you should become an optometrist then & hand out glasses to the umpires! Obviously they haven't seen what you have!! What will you & all the other sooks have to whinge about next year & beyond??

I've often offered umpires glasses. They didn't see the Clinch incident either Saturday night, but with Elizabeth's lights that's understandable.

[sjt]

Maybe they were watching where the ball was, rather than behind play, shame them.

[Mic]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

Simple, you think missing potentially two finals games for hitting a person behind play is "worth it". Strange thought process. I wonder if he thinks it's worth it. He may never get the opportunity to play finals football again (hopefully).

Nah, I rather him be playing Sunday. I reckon we're going to need a full strength side to beat the Eagles, so it will hurt us. Just trying to find a positive out of a negative.

[The Sleeping Giant]

James found not guilty because He didn't do anything. The facts are...Clinch belted James full-on in the face, behind play. Luckily James was wearing a mouth guard...if he wasn't, He would have lost a couple of teeth. He still sustained some injuries around the mouth & nose & the upper gum. No wonder the twins were angry.

Big Phil was reporting He had two teeth knocked out? Which one is it?

[Big Phil]

James found not guilty because He didn't do anything. The facts are...Clinch belted James full-on in the face, behind play. Luckily James was wearing a mouth guard...if he wasn't, He would have lost a couple of teeth. He still sustained some injuries around the mouth & nose & the upper gum. No wonder the twins were angry.

Big Phil was reporting He had two teeth knocked out? Which one is it?

Irrelevant now, the guilty verdict has been given so obviously what Clinch did was deemed to be worthy of weeks...

[Ian]

James found not guilty because He didn't do anything. The facts are...Clinch belted James full-on in the face, behind play. Luckily James was wearing a mouth guard...if he wasn't, He would have lost a couple of teeth. He still sustained some injuries around the mouth & nose & the upper gum. No wonder the twins were angry.

Big Phil was reporting He had two teeth knocked out? Which one is it?

Irrelevant now, the guilty verdict has been given so obviously what Clinch did was deemed to be worthy of weeks...

Either he had teeth knocked out or he didn't, why does a guilty verdict make it irrelevant

Did he have teeth knocked out or not?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Irrelevant now is it?

Probably one of those times when unless you know for certain, you probably shouldn't say anything. I mean, I've heard a story about what happened, but as I didn't see or hear what actually transpired, I won't repeat it.

What sort of record does Clinch have? To get 2 for striking is fairly stiff. With no umpires or video evidence, it would have come down to one players word against another's.

[udogs01]

[quote="The Sleeping Giant"]Irrelevant now is it?

Probably one of those times when unless you know for certain, you probably shouldn't say anything. I mean, I've heard a story about what happened, but as I didn't see or hear what actually transpired, I won't repeat it.

What sort of record does Clinch have? To get 2 for striking is fairly stiff. With no umpires or video evidence, it would have come down to one players word against another's.


Or just the physical scars on James face might be a dead giveaway

[The Sleeping Giant]

Are there any scars? 24hours ago Gowans had no teeth left?

[udogs01]

Are there any scars? 24hours ago Gowans had no teeth left?

I know ...poor Jimmy

He'll get over it...will you?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Of course. Everyone with a clear conscience will sleep well tonight.

[CENTURION]

James found not guilty because He didn't do anything. The facts are...Clinch belted James full-on in the face, behind play. Luckily James was wearing a mouth guard...if he wasn't, He would have lost a couple of teeth. He still sustained some injuries around the mouth & nose & the upper gum. No wonder the twins were angry.

Big Phil was reporting He had two teeth knocked out? Which one is it?

Irrelevant now, the guilty verdict has been given so obviously what Clinch did was deemed to be worthy of weeks...

Either he had teeth knocked out or he didn't, why does a guilty verdict make it irrelevant

Did he have teeth knocked out or not?

no He didn't.

[sjt]

Whose norths runner? He was getting pretty "excited", trying to "rev" up the crowd.

[on the rails]

Two sides to this story and Clinch was the retailiator based on a "less than savoury" lead up.

Clinch and the NAFC happy to leave it at that and he has to wear the 2 game ban. Apparently even though no one saw the alleged incident and both players had injuries consistent with physical contact only one player gets suspended?

[Trent Plucktrum]

2 games? A shame, but worth it.

Why? Now he's got a "claim" to fame amongst mental midgets. You mustn't rate him much as player.

I don't know what you're on about re: claim to fame with mental midgets.

He's played very well in recent weeks, we will miss him but look forward to having him him back in the Prelim Final.....

I've watched Gowans (the number 28 one) frequently give opposition players a punches/elbows/etc behind the play in the past decade (and annoyingly watch North players do nothing about it).

maybe you should become an optometrist then & hand out glasses to the umpires! Obviously they haven't seen what you have!! What will you & all the other sooks have to whinge about next year & beyond??

I'll still whinge about you and if you are saying that you have never seen james or chris be involved in anything behind the play or off the ball you are dead set dreaming !!