LIVE SCORES + DISCUSSION RD 19

[overloaded]

And some people on SAFOOTY say that umpires dont make any difference in football games
One of the worst decisions ever seen in an AFL game

I cant wait for the famous reply
"' But they had all game to get another 7 + points to win.""

In all honesty I reckon Daisy had the bloke over the back covered anyway. It was no cert.

[Interceptor]

It was a mark anyway.

Milne didnt look at the ball, always going to be a free. As frustraing as it is they generaly pay those.

S Milne clearly BOG for the Pies.....WADH

Milne kicked 3.
It was paid a free for chopping the arms.
Milne switched between looking at both O'Brien and the ball.

[overloaded]

It was a mark anyway.

Milne didnt look at the ball, always going to be a free. As frustraing as it is they generaly pay those.

S Milne clearly BOG for the Pies.....WADH

The umpire signalled an arm chop.
Didnt touch him

And what about the Birchall free last night. Was that a free?

I know it hurts that the pies won. I hate it. But I am not going to blame 1 umpire decision that was 50/50 ruin my night. How mamy 50/50 decisions were there on the night?

Cloke take the Freo deal before they come to their senses and halve the deal

[overloaded]

It was a mark anyway.

Milne didnt look at the ball, always going to be a free. As frustraing as it is they generaly pay those.

S Milne clearly BOG for the Pies.....WADH

Milne kicked 3.
It was paid a free for chopping the arms.
Milne switched between looking at both O'Brien and the ball.

Kicked 3 .... so what?????!!!!!!!!!

What about the stoooopid frees he gave away and cost his side. Undisciplined acts. He should be dropped next week. If St Kilda want to blame anyone he would be the first prick they should point the finger at.

[Strawb]

It was a mark anyway.

Milne didnt look at the ball, always going to be a free. As frustraing as it is they generaly pay those.

S Milne clearly BOG for the Pies.....WADH

The umpire signalled an arm chop.
Didnt touch him

And what about the Birchall free last night. Was that a free?

I know it hurts that the pies won. I hate it. But I am not going to blame 1 umpire decision that was 50/50 ruin my night. How mamy 50/50 decisions were there on the night?

Cloke take the Freo deal before they come to their senses and halve the deal

Seriously since his so called contract discussions have stopped so has he. Cloke is over rated and now proving it.

[overloaded]

How could any club seriously contemplate offering him $1m per year?

[Turbo]

Should have been a draw. Worst decision of the year

Thought it was a mark anyway. I know the umpire didn't pay it for that though

[Strawb]

How could any club seriously contemplate offering him $1m per year?

At the moment clubs are wanting to win a flag because they = cash. I wouldn't offer him any more than five hundred grand.

[overloaded]

Who do you all think would get the brownlow votes tonight?

[overloaded]

Should have been a draw. Worst decision of the year

Thought it was a mark anyway. I know the umpire didn't pay it for that though

It was clearly a mark, and Milne opted to look at the man. Either way it was Harrys ball
First thing you have ever said that makes any sense Turb

[Sojourner]

Port Power what a disgrace, lowest moment in the club's history?

Equal with when they lost to the Gold Coast in their first year in the AFL?

[The Sleeping Giant]

What about the gf loss?

[Turbo]

Should have been a draw. Worst decision of the year

Thought it was a mark anyway. I know the umpire didn't pay it for that though

It was clearly a mark, and Milne opted to look at the man. Either way it was Harrys ball
First thing you have ever said that makes any sense Turb

Could say the same about you

[gutterboy]

Should have been a draw. Worst decision of the year

Thought it was a mark anyway. I know the umpire didn't pay it for that though

It was clearly a mark, and Milne opted to look at the man. Either way it was Harrys ball
First thing you have ever said that makes any sense Turb

2 grabs at it and not hold it long enough......wasnt a mark should of been play on

[brod]

And I thought it was bad to be a Hawthorn supporter this weekend

[stan]

Very dissapointing effort from my lads this weekend. Freo just wanted it more and now any chanve of a top 4 spot looks slim. Bit dissapointing but I could be worse, I just look at port and boon and I can at least start to smile. Seriously boon hang in there mate that bullshit club owes you more than that.

[stan]

Port Power what a disgrace, lowest moment in the club's history?

Equal with when they lost to the Gold Coast in their first year in the AFL?

The gold coast was worse as it was there first win ever!

[overloaded]

worst result v GCFC

worst performance = yesterday

[mighty_tiger_79]

How could any club seriously contemplate offering him $1m per year?

the best thing is for all the other clubs to take any offers off the table and just watch his form and value keep declining

[Media Park]

Melbourne draw first blood against GCS through Sellar