How many games will Judd get??

[Squids]

We have an easy run in the next four weeks with only Sydney likely to cause problems.

Dogs Carp
Tigers Carp
Swans V.Good
Lions Carp


He will be fresh for our assault on the flag.

[Dirko]

If it was a fringe player from Western Bulldogs or Fremantle in the dock they'd have taken 10 minutes to deliver a 6-week ban.

Crap. Wouldn't have even been sighted.

Some Richmond dude did a similar thing last year and got a fine!

[Rik E Boy]

Swanny wouldn't of been able to lift his arm up that high, the fat midget

Scott Pendlebury then. It's not an anti Carlton stance for mine, I think Wellingham should have got more than Judd every day of the week but you (not you personally LMA) can't seriously buy Turb's 'witchunt' scenario fair dinkum.

regards,

REB

[goraw]

We have an easy run in the next four weeks with only Sydney likely to cause problems.

Dogs Carp
Tigers Carp
Swans V.Good
Lions Carp


He will be fresh for our assault on the flag.

[Turbo]

[quote="SJABC"]Should've lined him up and broken his jaw....

What a crock of shit.

Yep correct. If it was a lesser known player the media wouldn't have even shown interest eg Jackson dislocating Harvey's arm in 09.
Cos he is such a champion he will have to alter this behaviour as he is in the immediate spotlight. Unfortunately we live in a nation that is well known for tall poppy syndrome.

Witch hunt over. All you village idiots can put away the torches and pitch forks

Biased bullshit. He eye gouges a dude, elbows pav in the face...wins a flaming Brownlow real witchhunt on this bloke. Then you lot expect him to get away with pulling a guys arm back behind his back when he is on the ground being tackled by other blokes. If we were talking about Dane Swan here you'd be carrying a pitchfork yourself.

regards,

REB

Speaking of tall poppy syndrome

No worries Cyclops. Tell me you wern't thinking 'oh shit' when you saw that last week. As a SC nerd, I want Juddy in this week!

regards,

REB[/quote]

It's all good mate I really couldn't give a crap except for some of the ridiculous posts of a harsher penalty. I can live with 4 given the past record. At least you demonstrate some football understanding unlike some of the other cretins

[Rik E Boy]

If it was a fringe player from Western Bulldogs or Fremantle in the dock they'd have taken 10 minutes to deliver a 6-week ban.

Crap. Wouldn't have even been sighted.

Some Richmond dude did a similar thing last year and got a fine!

Yeah but he wouldn't have gotten away with that pressure point bullshit and the elbow in the face to pav..that is what Juddy is paying for tonight it's an itemised bill. The system is bullshit.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

It's all good mate I really couldn't give a crap except for some of the ridiculous posts of a harsher penalty. I can live with 4 given the past record. At least you demonstrate some football understanding unlike some of the other cretins

If I was a Bluebagger I'd be spewing too. Wellingham getting less than Judd just doesn't seem right. This reminds me of when Diesel got nine weeks for pushing that umpire lightly in the chest. Judd has been made an example of and as such it's not a good decision.

regards,

REB

[CUTTERMAN]

Surely if Judd set out to injure someone he would target one of the roos better players.

They probably weren't already held down so he could get a cheap shot in

[Turbo]

It's over now time to move on. Cracking round of footy this weekend. Looking forward to it

[Turbo]

It's all good mate I really couldn't give a crap except for some of the ridiculous posts of a harsher penalty. I can live with 4 given the past record. At least you demonstrate some football understanding unlike some of the other cretins

If I was a Bluebagger I'd be spewing too. Wellingham getting less than Judd just doesn't seem right. This reminds me of when Diesel got nine weeks for pushing that umpire lightly in the chest. Judd has been made an example of and as such it's not a good decision.

regards,

REB

That Greg Williams one was a disgrace. Unfortunately i passionately support a team that people love to hate. Sometimes that clouds their judgement probably as much it does mine.

[Turbo]

Taylor Walker hasn't injured anyone with his reports and he's been sidelined for weeks and carry over points, suck it up Carlton, shoe's on the other foot now!

Walker is a douchebag though.

So is Judd. Tonight is the catch up for all the other shit has gotten away with in the past.

regards,

REB

Yep, has served 3 weeks total only.
Should have got 5 for the eye gouge, 4 for the elbow to Pavlich and 5 for the pressure point.
Protected species

Back just in time to play your mob, over all niggles and chaffing at the bit I'd suggest

[The Sleeping Giant]

It's all good mate I really couldn't give a crap except for some of the ridiculous posts of a harsher penalty. I can live with 4 given the past record. At least you demonstrate some football understanding unlike some of the other cretins

If I was a Bluebagger I'd be spewing too. Wellingham getting less than Judd just doesn't seem right. This reminds me of when Diesel got nine weeks for pushing that umpire lightly in the chest. Judd has been made an example of and as such it's not a good decision.

regards,

REB

Wellingham got 5, but because he hadn't previously eye gouged for example, good record reduced it to 3.

[Brad]

4 harsh, 2 was justified, bad luck to Turbo and Squids....

[The Sleeping Giant]

4 is better than 2, but would of loved to see Judd get 6.

[Turbo]

Judd should be grateful that Squids and Turbo weren't defending him at the tribunal. Gleeson would've put on a loading just for being binkered bumrattlers!

Turn it up peanut

[The Sleeping Giant]

Judd should be grateful that Squids and Turbo weren't defending him at the tribunal. Gleeson would've put on a loading just for being binkered bumrattlers!

Turn it up peanut

Your Honour

[daysofourlives]

Can the AFL appeal this descision?
I think its a disgrasce given his bad record, this is effectively a 2 week ban plus 2 for previous bad record.
If it was judged by the points system he gets 7, dont worry turbs and didley squids he is still very much a protected species.
How many would Steve Baker have got?

[White Line Fever]

Can the AFL appeal this descision?
I think its a disgrasce given his bad record, this is effectively a 2 week ban plus 2 for previous bad record.
If it was judged by the points system he gets 7, dont worry turbs and didley squids he is still very much a protected species.
How many would Steve Baker have got?

The hate is strong with this one.

End well, this will not.

[Turbo]

Can the AFL appeal this descision?
I think its a disgrasce given his bad record, this is effectively a 2 week ban plus 2 for previous bad record.
If it was judged by the points system he gets 7, dont worry turbs and didley squids he is still very much a protected species.
How many would Steve Baker have got?

It may not be over yet. Carlton considering an appeal

[Rik E Boy]

Can the AFL appeal this descision?
I think its a disgrasce given his bad record, this is effectively a 2 week ban plus 2 for previous bad record.
If it was judged by the points system he gets 7, dont worry turbs and didley squids he is still very much a protected species.
How many would Steve Baker have got?

The hate is strong with this one.

End well, this will not.

He's still waiting for the AFL to bring back zoning.

regards,

REB