2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[CENTURION]

Jason Sutherland has accepted a one match ban for rough contact.

It appears as though Mitchell Grigg's report has been thrown out. There is no mention of it on the SANFL site

1 match for pushing someone? Is that what happened?

[whufc]

Would it have been rough conduct if the brick wall wasnt there.

Stupid yes, dangerous yes, reckless definatly, rough conduct debatable.

[smac]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

[whufc]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

Yeah i just wonder if the club thought about appealing on basis of the charge being 'rough conduct'. Is pushing in the back really 'rough conduct' i thought it would have been more of a 'reckless charge'

I dont have a big issue with him getting a game, would be interesting though in the same situation if the player had been pushed into the standard fence whether he still would have been reported.

[JK]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

Yeah i just wonder if the club thought about appealing on basis of the charge being 'rough conduct'. Is pushing in the back really 'rough conduct' i thought it would have been more of a 'reckless charge'

I dont have a big issue with him getting a game, would be interesting though in the same situation if the player had been pushed into the standard fence whether he still would have been reported.

Or a goal post for example

[The Sleeping Giant]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

At least spectators can't break their legs on the wall.

[CENTURION]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

At least spectators can't break their legs on the wall.

or have globes fall on them.

[whufc]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

Yeah i just wonder if the club thought about appealing on basis of the charge being 'rough conduct'. Is pushing in the back really 'rough conduct' i thought it would have been more of a 'reckless charge'

I dont have a big issue with him getting a game, would be interesting though in the same situation if the player had been pushed into the standard fence whether he still would have been reported.

Or a goal post for example

Exactly if he had pushed him and he had hit the padded goal post what chance is there he would have been reported.

[CENTURION]

or pushed him into the fence & then he broke his leg. Would the game have stopped for 1/2 an hour?

[Go Legs]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

At least spectators can't break their legs on the wall.

or have globes fall on them.

At least we can afford to put globes in, unlike the real reason night games didn't happen at Lizbeth

Cheers,

[smac]

Yeah, much better to be half-arsed.

[CENTURION]

Can still be reported for shoving someone into the fence.

I don't think the wall should be there in the safe and careful world we live in, but it is. So players need to ensure they don't injure an opponent with it.

At least spectators can't break their legs on the wall.

or have globes fall on them.

At least we can afford to put globes in, unlike the real reason night games didn't happen at Lizbeth

Cheers,

That's because We are perfectionists. Some call Us arrogant but We don't give a rats!!

[topsywaldron]

For someone who doesn't care you sure bring it up often enough.

[Jim05]

Take it the reports from the ressies last week between Norwood and Central were thrown out

[Big Phil]

Take it the reports from the ressies last week between Norwood and Central were thrown out

No. Both Central players, Matt White and Damian Hynes, copped 1 week bans.

[Jim05]

Take it the reports from the ressies last week between Norwood and Central were thrown out

No. Both Central players, Matt White and Damian Hynes, copped 1 week bans.

Thanks, dont know much about White but Hynes appears to be handy. Why isnt he playing league?

[Big Phil]

Take it the reports from the ressies last week between Norwood and Central were thrown out

No. Both Central players, Matt White and Damian Hynes, copped 1 week bans.

Thanks, dont know much about White but Hynes appears to be handy. Why isnt he playing league?

He is quite injury prone and has been injured at times when there would have been an opportunity to go up to the League side...

Had been in great form in the 2's and wouldn't have been far away from elevation but this suspension sets him back, yet again.

[Jim05]

Byron Sumner copped a 1 match ban for front on contact.
Ben Kane was given a 1 match ban for rough conduct but has decided to contest the decision

[Big Phil]

Anyone know whether Adam Cockshell was suspended from the North v Port game on Sunday?

I don't think the SANFL publish results from their Reserves tribunal hearings?

[Jim05]

Anyone know whether Adam Cockshell was suspended from the North v Port game on Sunday?

I don't think the SANFL publish results from their Reserves tribunal hearings?

They dont BP, thats why I asked about the 2 Centrals lads last week