by Booney » Fri Apr 27, 2007 11:47 am
by RustyCage » Fri Apr 27, 2007 4:26 pm
zipzap wrote:Dutchy wrote:pafc1870 wrote:
I know a few teachers who you cant hold a decent conversation with about the business world and its mechanics and dont understand the pressure of private enterprise...thats all Im saying...Dutchy wrote:Thats because we dont need to know about all that stuff. Just the same as if I was to have a converstation with you about constructivism, or the work of Jean Piaget, or the setting up of a community or inquiry, or the new report card process, the changing dynamics of a classroom.... You learn what you need to learn to do what you do. If you are in business, you learn about business, if you are a teacher, you learn about education. Nothing to do with one being better than the other.
And I present to you "Exhibit A"....
Hmm...As soon as I saw that quote pafc1870 I knew we would be in trouble![]()
I think what you're trying to say is this: If I was a high school economics teacher I would definitely be expected to know about the machinations of the business world. But surely you wouldn't expect that from all teachers (eg a high school art teacher, or a general primary school teacher like myself)? Just like I wouldn't expect Mr Economics to teach my kid about Renaissance art or how to spell big words.
Our job, everything being equal and especially at primary level, is to turn out well-rounded individuals who have learned how to learn, get along with others and have gained the skills to become successful at whatever they pursue later on. Not to produce robotic little grey-faced economists who toe the line, look after the shareholders, snag a trophy wife, exploit others in pursuit of profit and vote Liberal.
That's for private schools
by RustyCage » Fri Apr 27, 2007 4:33 pm
Psyber wrote:pafc1870 wrote:Psyber wrote:pafc1870 wrote:I've always wondered why so many people think that private education is so much better than public. Is it the flashy uniforms? Is it the shitload of 4WDs out the front every day? Is it that you have to pay a lot of money to go there, so therefore it must be good? It is the higher TER scores that come out of the private schools? (which is because more people who go there want to go to uni rather than straight into work or TAFE as with a public school).
I suspect that another factor is the feeling that as a paying customer you have a bit more weight if you are not happy with the way things are being done, whether it is in the way the curriculum is run or the way behaviour and drug issues are being handled. You can front the Principal, and policy is not determined by some unreachable bureacrat in head office, who allegedly knows better than you. More highly educated people are likely to favour this. I went to a state High School - Woodville - but my step-daughter went to a private girls' school in Adelaide.
It is much the same as health policy. My wife needed a CT Scan recently to exclude lung cancer [all clear] and the specialist she saw privately is a consultant at a local public hospital with part-time private practice rights, and he referred her to their Radiology department. But I found out from a technical contact that a local private Radiology company had a scanner that was 9x more sensitive, verified it with a doctor I knew, and had her diverted there! The cost as a privately referred patient was the same in both places.
Firstly, education is a lot different than the medical field. Secondly, the differences between public and private schools you mentioned are not quite right. Policy in a public school is not chosen by someone in an office miles away as you stated. Public schools aren't just puppets for the government or DECS or whoever.
Those differences were there when I acquired a teenage step-daughter, but that was I admit 15 years ago. My brother-in-law is a senior high school teacher in SA and he is very attached to the public system, but from what he has said in passing conversation recently about problems he has experienced it still seems to be true, and he is not a disgruntled teacher, he actually approves of the system and is mildly disapproving of private schooling. Then he is a nice guy but very conventional and knows very little outside his field and sport - he is another Port Adelaide supporter. [While visiting recently I cleaned over 200 spyware items off a family computer for them.]
I have known a lot of teachers socially, usually like the brother-in-law, nice people, but conventional and unimaginative, and inclined to live inside their careers. I suspect the "never left school" thing does apply to many.
On the other hand a Hells Angel of my acquaintance sends his kids to a private school and they are very well behaved - mind you Dad is also very composed, polite, and business-like - not feral at all - presumably unless you cross him or interfere with his business. He keeps his kids away from "business".
by Mr66 » Fri Apr 27, 2007 9:53 pm
pafc1870 wrote:Psyber wrote:pafc1870 wrote:Psyber wrote:pafc1870 wrote:I've always wondered why so many people think that private education is so much better than public. Is it the flashy uniforms? Is it the shitload of 4WDs out the front every day? Is it that you have to pay a lot of money to go there, so therefore it must be good? It is the higher TER scores that come out of the private schools? (which is because more people who go there want to go to uni rather than straight into work or TAFE as with a public school).
I suspect that another factor is the feeling that as a paying customer you have a bit more weight if you are not happy with the way things are being done, whether it is in the way the curriculum is run or the way behaviour and drug issues are being handled. You can front the Principal, and policy is not determined by some unreachable bureacrat in head office, who allegedly knows better than you. More highly educated people are likely to favour this. I went to a state High School - Woodville - but my step-daughter went to a private girls' school in Adelaide.
It is much the same as health policy. My wife needed a CT Scan recently to exclude lung cancer [all clear] and the specialist she saw privately is a consultant at a local public hospital with part-time private practice rights, and he referred her to their Radiology department. But I found out from a technical contact that a local private Radiology company had a scanner that was 9x more sensitive, verified it with a doctor I knew, and had her diverted there! The cost as a privately referred patient was the same in both places.
Firstly, education is a lot different than the medical field. Secondly, the differences between public and private schools you mentioned are not quite right. Policy in a public school is not chosen by someone in an office miles away as you stated. Public schools aren't just puppets for the government or DECS or whoever.
Those differences were there when I acquired a teenage step-daughter, but that was I admit 15 years ago. My brother-in-law is a senior high school teacher in SA and he is very attached to the public system, but from what he has said in passing conversation recently about problems he has experienced it still seems to be true, and he is not a disgruntled teacher, he actually approves of the system and is mildly disapproving of private schooling. Then he is a nice guy but very conventional and knows very little outside his field and sport - he is another Port Adelaide supporter. [While visiting recently I cleaned over 200 spyware items off a family computer for them.]
I have known a lot of teachers socially, usually like the brother-in-law, nice people, but conventional and unimaginative, and inclined to live inside their careers. I suspect the "never left school" thing does apply to many.
On the other hand a Hells Angel of my acquaintance sends his kids to a private school and they are very well behaved - mind you Dad is also very composed, polite, and business-like - not feral at all - presumably unless you cross him or interfere with his business. He keeps his kids away from "business".
I think family is a bigger influence on how people turn out than the school system they are educated in, i.e. if the school had one view and the family had another view, the student would be more influenced by the family than the school.
You might be right about the never left school thing, and when Im out on a prac I find many of the teachers in the staff room very boring to talk to. I think some people have a lot of trouble getting out of the professional "teacher" mode.
I also think one of the moderators or admins should take these posts out of this thread and into a new one, so it doesn't kill the "what gives you the shits" thread.
by Gilly » Sat Apr 28, 2007 1:01 am
by Wedgie » Sat Apr 28, 2007 1:03 am
Armchair expert wrote:Such a great club are Geelong
by johntheclaret » Sat Apr 28, 2007 6:46 am
Gilly wrote:1. Posts that are quoted in their entirety and then requoted ad nauseam with every subsequent reply.
2. Victorians who confuse their "a"s with their "e"s, e.g. Malbourne, Nick Del Santo, Stan Elves, etc.
3. People who pronounce "here" like it has 2 syllables, i.e. "hee yar".
by Rik E Boy » Sat Apr 28, 2007 6:02 pm
Booney wrote:I am wearing thin with people who use "o" (oh) in a phone number oh4oh3,it's a zero,not an "o"
by Thiele » Sun Apr 29, 2007 12:20 am
by johntheclaret » Sun Apr 29, 2007 2:12 am
Thiele wrote:When you tell people you are going to meet them at a certain time they don't rock up. You try to conntact them on their mobile no answer they arrive an hour late and they say it is your fault
by Thiele » Sun Apr 29, 2007 2:13 am
Well said matejohntheclaret wrote:Thiele wrote:When you tell people you are going to meet them at a certain time they don't rock up. You try to conntact them on their mobile no answer they arrive an hour late and they say it is your fault
Especially when you are paying by the hour
by Thiele » Sun Apr 29, 2007 10:01 pm
by JK » Mon Apr 30, 2007 12:14 pm
by Interceptor » Mon Apr 30, 2007 12:45 pm
by Gilly » Mon Apr 30, 2007 1:37 pm
Interceptor wrote:Sports commentators or players who use the cliche 'a tough day at the office' or variations of that one.
by Booney » Mon Apr 30, 2007 2:16 pm
by scoob » Mon Apr 30, 2007 3:42 pm
by zipzap » Mon Apr 30, 2007 4:42 pm
by JK » Mon Apr 30, 2007 4:48 pm
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |