Kilburn Stripped

[Pag]

This system this year has become ridiculous, was speaking to someone from Walkerville yesterday and they have guys good enough to play A grade playing B grade footy because of the points. Walkerville, like Kilburn I would assume would struggle to fill many junior sides due to the ageing area they reside in, how else are they to field senior sides without recruiting. At GG we are lucky, we have a big junior program and a good number of our A grade players come from that program straight into seniors.

Walkies have plenty of juniors mate, and of good quality too. There's no reason why they should have any problem with the concept I would have thought, much like you guys, TTG etc.

[beeroclock]

Clubs with poor or no juniors will targeted first.
Not saying thats the way it should be but thats what will happen.

[gutterboy]

Its official. Kilburn have had their Premiership points and their score taken away from them for their wins over Mitcham, Seaton and Pooraka for playing these 3 games over the 15 point APPS threshold. And fined $1000.

The other 3 teams get the 2 Premiership points. Kilburn now 0-5.

i heard $3000?

[Caramels]

I guess we should all start preparing for the world to cease to revolve on its axis, there's bound to be one hell of a noise over this result.

No not an earthquake, it will be Phil Martin driving a D9 bulldozer through the SAAFL office at Thebarton

Might even bring in the PAEC, the mayor and his councillors as support.

[locky801]

This system this year has become ridiculous, was speaking to someone from Walkerville yesterday and they have guys good enough to play A grade playing B grade footy because of the points. Walkerville, like Kilburn I would assume would struggle to fill many junior sides due to the ageing area they reside in, how else are they to field senior sides without recruiting. At GG we are lucky, we have a big junior program and a good number of our A grade players come from that program straight into seniors.

Walkies have plenty of juniors mate, and of good quality too. There's no reason why they should have any problem with the concept I would have thought, much like you guys, TTG etc.

Walkies like us do have alot of Juniors, still confuses me why they done field an Under 16 side

[FOURTH ESTATE]

Was talking to senior Walkerville official last night and they advised that they don't go past U/15 as they lose a good % of their players to the Private schools system in that age group.

[The Big Shrek]

Can let you know why this happened.

Mark McCallum played for NTFL ressies before Kilburn. League thought he was one point but he is actually zero. Therefore we were only one point over.

Nick Pearce came from Fitzroy but actually played mostly SANFL ressies. We thought he was two, but he was three.

Computer system that shows the points wasn't working the first few weeks.

We are now on zero wins, my reading of the rules is that no points are awarded to any team for the three games we won.

My understanding is that the SAAFL executive committee voted unanimously that kickinitand Fourth Estate are knob jockeys who cuddle each other at night.

[kickinit]

I also heard that kleenex shares have just gone through the roof as The Big Shrek can't stop crying.

[The Riddler]

Can let you know why this happened.

Mark McCallum played for NTFL ressies before Kilburn. League thought he was one point but he is actually zero. Therefore we were only one point over.

Nick Pearce came from Fitzroy but actually played mostly SANFL ressies. We thought he was two, but he was three.

Computer system that shows the points wasn't working the first few weeks.

We are now on zero wins, my reading of the rules is that no points are awarded to any team for the three games we won.

My understanding is that the SAAFL executive committee voted unanimously that kickinitand Fourth Estate are knob jockeys who cuddle each other at night.

[Blacks130]

Therefore we were only one point over.

but 1 point over nevertheless, yes????. Stiff penalty in anyone's language but the first one was always going to cop it I suppose.

[The Big Shrek]

Therefore we were only one point over.

but 1 point over nevertheless, yes????. Stiff penalty in anyone's language but the first one was always going to cop it I suppose.

Yep. Was just pointing out we were only one point over because the initial allegation was that we were ttwopoints over.

[FOURTH ESTATE]

Shrek Shrek Shrek, All I can say is that My heart pumps custard for you and cry me a river. You stuffed up and got caught now take your medicine like a grown man and stop complaining.

You got caught because you didn't do full diligence end of story and stop whining like a 2 yo baby!!!!!

[The Big Shrek]

Shrek Shrek Shrek, All I can say is that My heart pumps custard for you and cry me a river. You stuffed up and got caught now take your medicine like a grown man and stop complaining.

You got caught because you didn't do full diligence end of story and stop whining like a 2 yo baby!!!!!

Please quote a post where I complained.

Then stop dribbling altogether. By the way, I found out who you are. You're in no position to criticise anyone about football ability, or intellect.

[Jimmy_041]

The whisper I heard on the weekend was that PAOC in division 2 have been claiming some of their players as zero points who went to the school for year 12 only, meaning that they did not register the minimum 25 games required to be a zero point. I even heard one player played soccer not football when there at high school.

Now I maybe ignorant here, but to be zero or -1 points, you have had to play 25+ games for the club in previous years or juniors?
If this is the case, does this apply for the college sides? i.e. do they have to play 25 games of college football to be worth zero or -1?

You really shouldn't listen to the girls whispering to you at The Palace - they will tell you anything for another lap dance
None of the A Grade players went to PAC in Year 12 only.
James Admiraal played soccer at school and plays in the Bs, PLUS joined us straight from school so he'd be zero points anyway (Adders - we'd have to be pretty short mate )
Happy to confirm if you can give me a name, but I doubt you'll give one.

Hahaha nice one Jimmy, only reporting what I hear after all that is what this site is all about. I was a bit foggey on the rules for Old Scholars sides. However I still think after a few investigations into some sides, a few clubs may get found out. Not saying yours is one of them though. It is a funny system, currently as it stands I personally could change to 3 different clubs from the one I am at now and be zero points as I played junior footy at one, went to high school at the other, and also have played over 100 games for the third one.
But if I wanted to say try and play A grade at a top notch div 1 side (higher grade than the other 3 clubs) I would be worth 3 points!

Well, that's the difference between us FF, I only report fact on here.......
OK maybe not

BUT - considering you had a crack at my club, AND I know the girl (Yardy Lard) at the Palace that gave you the whisper the other night, and you know I love to dissect and respond, I retort with the following:

"Not saying yours is one of them though" - bull$hit - you were insinuating it and I called your bluff. Name and defend!
"I played junior footy at one" - if you played 25 junior games you would be zero points for them forever. That is where the system works well - rewards the clubs that promote juniors
"went to high school at the other" - did you play 25 games for them? Depends how old you are - very few high schools play footy now. Colleges, Marryatville and AHS as far as I know. I only wish the public school football system was still there so the colleges could regularly play Henley, Plympton, Unley, Norwood/Morialta High etc. I still drink with Norwood and Unley blokes that I played against.
"and also have played over 100 games for the third one" - granted - zero points
add in - which senior side did you first join?

[Jimmy_041]

Was talking to senior Walkerville official last night and they advised that they don't go past U/15 as they lose a good % of their players to the Private schools system in that age group.

One good thing about safooty is we can debate this stuff without knowing who is on the keyboard ( I know its you Pietro Gonzalez)
Whoever deemed these kids as "their players"
If they actually play 25 games for Walkerville juniors, then they are zero points for them if they ever WANT to play for them

[Killa]

What's more a joke there are players in to there 3rd year close to 50 games still carry a point

[Boosh]

What's more a joke there are players in to there 3rd year close to 50 games still carry a point

We have a player worth 2 points that is in his 6th season with the club as the first 5 he played he had 3 shoulder operations and only played 24 games before going out to Port Adelaide then the Adelaide Plains League. But that's the system so we have to live with it.

[Old Dog New Tricks]

What's more a joke there are players in to there 3rd year close to 50 games still carry a point

We have a player worth 2 points that is in his 6th season with the club as the first 5 he played he had 3 shoulder operations and only played 24 games before going out to Port Adelaide then the Adelaide Plains League. But that's the system so we have to live with it.

Any league can dissafiliate from the comm football league at it's leisure.

[Mythical Creature]

What's more a joke there are players in to there 3rd year close to 50 games still carry a point

We have a player worth 2 points that is in his 6th season with the club as the first 5 he played he had 3 shoulder operations and only played 24 games before going out to Port Adelaide then the Adelaide Plains League. But that's the system so we have to live with it.

Why don't you clear this player to another club, then clear him straight back and say that he has previously played 25 games for you? That should knock off a couple of points.

[FOURTH ESTATE]

Shrek Shrek Shrek, All I can say is that My heart pumps custard for you and cry me a river. You stuffed up and got caught now take your medicine like a grown man and stop complaining.

You got caught because you didn't do full diligence end of story and stop whining like a 2 yo baby!!!!!

Please quote a post where I complained.

Then stop dribbling altogether. By the way, I found out who you are. You're in no position to criticise anyone about football ability, or intellect.

I think you'll find my contribution to this league and my club far outweighs yours!!!!!!
At least I didn't take money for playing under false pretences (At least I could play)