


Fully agree with your sentiments as well. You're either in or out. No in between. End of story.

by Goat Herder » Tue Dec 06, 2011 4:20 pm
by Cougar » Tue Dec 06, 2011 4:51 pm
by carey » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:15 pm
Smasha wrote:carey wrote:grave digger wrote:On the State comp i agree coogs shocking time of year to try and recruit players to play away from home i did bring this up at the meeting last carnival hope it has not fallen on deaf ears .One week later could make all the differance to some and a lot easier for those trying to put the side together .It is a great time away with great blokes to win the thing would be even Greater agree with Smasha recruiting from Div 1 is a must also no its not that simple if the timeing was re jigged this may help
I to agree with the timing issue but this whole div1 thing is crap.
So the Enfield coach agrees to terms with Greg Blewett to play at Enfield but come ass. time we cant pick him cause his div 2??? FFS give me a break look at the big picture div 2 players can still play.......
I am sure some of you people are slightly retarded.
I am saying you pick from div 1 first then pick from other divs after .....IS IT THAT HARD TO UNDERSTAND.
glad I am not on the committee to pick this assoc side , reackon I might punch a couple of people. CAREY you play div 2 so your saying if someone in div 1 is better than you you should still get picked first because you already played in the carnival ?
thats what is crap mate, if there are better players in div 1 one then they are first choice regardless who they are, if I put my hand up this year and someone is better than me then you pick them ....not hard is it. or do you want me to type slower.
by carey » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:16 pm
by Noel Craig » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:27 pm
One Ball Bandit wrote:OBB Association Side
1.B.Reidy
2.J.Borgas
3.J.Smith
4.A.McDonald
5.L.Mills
6.S.Holland
7.A.Harris
8.J.Clarke
9.A.Balding
10.M.Nitshke
11.C.Balneaves
12.R.Marshall
13.T.Hodson
by Noel Craig » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:38 pm
carey wrote:Smasha wrote:carey wrote:grave digger wrote:On the State comp i agree coogs shocking time of year to try and recruit players to play away from home i did bring this up at the meeting last carnival hope it has not fallen on deaf ears .One week later could make all the differance to some and a lot easier for those trying to put the side together .It is a great time away with great blokes to win the thing would be even Greater agree with Smasha recruiting from Div 1 is a must also no its not that simple if the timeing was re jigged this may help
I to agree with the timing issue but this whole div1 thing is crap.
So the Enfield coach agrees to terms with Greg Blewett to play at Enfield but come ass. time we cant pick him cause his div 2??? FFS give me a break look at the big picture div 2 players can still play.......
I am sure some of you people are slightly retarded.
I am saying you pick from div 1 first then pick from other divs after .....IS IT THAT HARD TO UNDERSTAND.
glad I am not on the committee to pick this assoc side , reackon I might punch a couple of people. CAREY you play div 2 so your saying if someone in div 1 is better than you you should still get picked first because you already played in the carnival ?
thats what is crap mate, if there are better players in div 1 one then they are first choice regardless who they are, if I put my hand up this year and someone is better than me then you pick them ....not hard is it. or do you want me to type slower.
I think you've taken me out of context mate the point i was making was the best 11 should be picked regardless of what grade they play.
And yes the best 11 logically should come from div1 but if there are players in div2 or what ever grade that are in the best 11 they should be picked regardless.
by Phantom Gossiper » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:45 pm
carey wrote:The Mrs offically hates me
by grave digger » Tue Dec 06, 2011 6:11 pm
by One Ball Bandit » Tue Dec 06, 2011 6:21 pm
by Noel Craig » Tue Dec 06, 2011 6:30 pm
well i dont rate Harris as one of the best bats in the comp so that should give you the answer ;-) as for Traianos i heard from a good source that he attented the first training session,dont know about the second one? so i dont see why he wouldnt be playing on Sunday[/quote]One Ball Bandit wrote:And your keeping would be Mills?? Or Harris? What about Matt Traianos from Seaton aswell? Does anyone know where his head is at regarding rep cricket?
by Noel Craig » Tue Dec 06, 2011 6:33 pm
grave digger wrote:I can tell you this THE ONE WHO PREFERS GOATS works his butt off to pull the best side together.PS Dutchy whats new its only the level that changes young fella.
by carey » Tue Dec 06, 2011 7:07 pm
grave digger wrote:I can tell you this THE ONE WHO PREFERS GOATS works his butt off to pull the best side together.PS Dutchy whats new its only the level that changes young fella.
by dark & stormy » Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:04 am
carey wrote:grave digger wrote:I can tell you this THE ONE WHO PREFERS GOATS works his butt off to pull the best side together.PS Dutchy whats new its only the level that changes young fella.
Oh i'm hearing ya but this time she is really pi$$ed at me she's been telling me all the things i got up to! woops
Told me to grow up i told her i'm already 6ft that did'nt go down well either
by Goat Herder » Wed Dec 07, 2011 9:24 am
Noel Craig wrote: Whilst it is ultimately up to the players to commit to this, I think it woud also pay hansomely for the senior coaches/managers of these sides to contact desired players personally. I'm not suggesting kissing there tooshs, all's I'm saying is good communication between the parties could be the key to getting together the strongest side this association can get and for me, I think that very side would be formiddable and very hard to beat![]()
by Noel Craig » Wed Dec 07, 2011 4:44 pm
Goat Herder wrote:Noel Craig wrote: Whilst it is ultimately up to the players to commit to this, I think it woud also pay hansomely for the senior coaches/managers of these sides to contact desired players personally. I'm not suggesting kissing there tooshs, all's I'm saying is good communication between the parties could be the key to getting together the strongest side this association can get and for me, I think that very side would be formiddable and very hard to beat![]()
Rest assured Lairdy, all attempts to take the best side into each Carnival are explored.In fact, the 'education process' of informing players about what is required of them has been occurring since 2005, including ensuring work and 'marital' leave passes are obtained WELL in advance - 12mths in advance wherever possible.
I can also enlighten you that a 'wishlist' squad of 20 players is drawn up by the coach & manager and contact with those players is made personally to sound out their interest and availability, WELL in advance! Ask any of the last 3 Carnival sides I've coached, they can confirm that.Then of course, training is organised (on turf wickets) for 6-8wks prior to jumping aboard the plane, where EVERYONE is invited to come out and show us what they've got. Afterall, new guys come in each year & some leave our comp, so everyone gets a crack at throwing their hat into the ring. I must also add that NEVER has the ‘wishlisted’ team eventuated, for whatever reason.
In addition to the above, EVERY spot is up for grabs, from the skipper right down to the 13th man. The best 13 will be picked from those available, regardless of what grade they play. We have some basic rules around the sort of qualities we look for in a player, and first and foremost is attitude. We will simply not put up with tools or anyone who we deem will not gel in a team environment. Obviously, skills/talent then come into play, along with passion and a willingness to listen & learn and work hard.
Fully agree though – if we fielded our BEST side, we would be coming back to Adelaide with the chockies – except for Harry, who came home with a ‘chicky’ last time..We’ll see where we’re at in 12mths time…..
by infinity+1 » Wed Dec 07, 2011 7:22 pm
by mickey » Wed Dec 07, 2011 7:25 pm
by bored » Wed Dec 07, 2011 7:40 pm
by infinity+1 » Wed Dec 07, 2011 9:27 pm
by auto » Thu Dec 08, 2011 9:44 am
Noel Craig wrote:grave digger wrote:I can tell you this THE ONE WHO PREFERS GOATS works his butt off to pull the best side together.PS Dutchy whats new its only the level that changes young fella.
The one who prefers GOATS?? Don't know what your trying to prove with that comment but I don't doubt GH works his butt off but I wasnt sure of the sort of communication our association may have been helping him out with ie. Letters, flyers etc..
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |