NO! Not ironic at all. CM Punk was a tireless worker on the indy circuit before breaking into the WWE through their ECW brand/show. He got over with little or no mike time in his first year based on his original in ring stlye and move set, character and look. When given the stick he has shown he has some of the best mic skills in the business and it has obviously enhanced his standing in the business. Yes he cut a killer promo that elevated him for a push but to say that he got his big break from that or got "made" is adsurd. He had all ready been a World Champ
As for your moments that "made" the stars

this didnt support your rant as they were fairly uninformed IMO
Stone Cold ; before WM 13 at KOR " Austin 3:16 says i just wipped your ass" is widely regarded as the moment of the beginning of the Austin era and has been posted on here in an earlier page.
Hogans slam of Andre : hahahahahahahahahahahaha

in his 4th year as World champion after having slammed him at Shea stadium and slamming him in 1980, after working with him all over Japan regularly slamming him and hitting him with the deadly "Axey Boomba". I think in 1983 as Thunderlips Huilk Hogan caught the entire worlds attention.
Edge ; TLC with Christian v The Hardys is considered the night all 4 took the step and secured their futures in the business.
Kane ; all Kane did that night was rip off a door and deliver a tombstone to take home one of wrestling s great matches.
Im guessing you dont like Punk but CHICAGO MADE PUNK is as much "Made" in the ring as anyone has been and he has done it without the use of steroids and ass kissing. He is a brilliant worker and can work equally as well as a heel or face
Yes clearly i am a big fan to the substance and style that he brings and his match v Cena in Chicago was one of the best WRESTLING matches i have seen in a long time and maintained the interest of all 7 people i watched it with that day (3 of them not wrestling fans) for the entire 40 minutes....CHARLES MONTGOMERY PUNK

The PNU Falcs 2005,06,13 x 2,14 and Div 1 Premiers in 2019......The SA 3peat - 2003,04,05