Magarey Medal 2011

[Grahaml]

17 of his votes came from losing games

8 votes in 7 wins, 17 votes in 13 losses. He polls better in losses than wins. Interesting.

[MagareyLegend]

Thommo won't make the top 6.

Good call that one

[robranisgod]

17 of his votes came from losing games

8 votes in 7 wins, 17 votes in 13 losses. He polls better in losses than wins. Interesting.

Last year I think only three votes came from losing games and was criticised for only playing well in winning games. A few of the posters here are churlish in the extreme.

[robranisgod]

I personally attended the West v WWT game in Rd17 where Grocke absolutely dominated the game and did not register a vote. Granted he was reported, but surely when the umps are allocating the votes post game they cannot judge the player guilty of the offence and not award votes to him.

If an umpire was to award a player votes after he was reported in the same game it would be hypocritical, if the umpire believes his report was warrented there is no way he can also believe the same player was the fairest on the field.

It used to be a rule of the medal that a player who was reported couldn't poll votes. I don't know whether that rule still applies.

[smac]

17 of his votes came from losing games

8 votes in 7 wins, 17 votes in 13 losses. He polls better in losses than wins. Interesting.

Last year I think only three votes came from losing games and was criticised for only playing well in winning games. A few of the posters here are churlish in the extreme.

He said it was interesting! Hop off the high horse.

[The Sleeping Giant]

17 of his votes came from losing games

8 votes in 7 wins, 17 votes in 13 losses. He polls better in losses than wins. Interesting.

Agreed. He should have won by more.

[CENTURION]

Thommo won't make the top 6.

Good call that one

yeah, go figure! And Sansbury came nowhere!!

[Reddeer]

I personally attended the West v WWT game in Rd17 where Grocke absolutely dominated the game and did not register a vote. Granted he was reported, but surely when the umps are allocating the votes post game they cannot judge the player guilty of the offence and not award votes to him.

Yeah but look who the umpires were that day Avon, Dey and DEBOY
I rest my case!!!

[Dutchy]

Thommo won't make the top 6.

Good call that one

yeah, go figure! And Sansbury came nowhere!!

but apparently he is a gun!

[Grahaml]

17 of his votes came from losing games

8 votes in 7 wins, 17 votes in 13 losses. He polls better in losses than wins. Interesting.

Last year I think only three votes came from losing games and was criticised for only playing well in winning games. A few of the posters here are churlish in the extreme.

He said it was interesting! Hop off the high horse.

Exactly. It's very, very rare for someone to be more prolific in losses than wins. If you don't think that's interesting then there's something wrong with you. Perhaps you're the one who is churlish. Lol.

You could easily spin that mere fact either way. You could say he got more votes than he deserved, or played selfish footy and cost North games, or more accurately (IMHO) you can point the finger at his teammates and ask why so many went missing and left so much to very few. Clearly in my mind, Allan can't be so important to North and have team success. Rather than bring Allan down to the level of the team, the team should rise to help him. An ideal situation is he gets 20-25 touches and makes them more valuable and becomes one of several you need to quell rather than being the only one you need to limit. When one player is worth so much, it isn't so difficult to limit their damage as it is to limit the damage of an even team effort.

[Dirko]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

[CENTURION]

Thommo won't make the top 6.

Good call that one

yeah, go figure! And Sansbury came nowhere!!

but apparently he is a gun!

bloody racist umpires! Did you see Him this year, Dutchy? I think He will win Our B&F easily.

[Booney]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

Any wonder why we question the sexuality of Bay supporters? You blokes are sick.

[Media Park]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

Any wonder why we question the sexuality of Bay supporters? You blokes are sick.

???

[sjt]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

Any wonder why we question the sexuality of Bay supporters? You blokes are sick.

???

C'mon Media Park, think.

[jim5112]

Now that Nick Liddle has finsihed second, does that mean he is good enough to join James Boyd at Centrals?

[Media Park]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

Any wonder why we question the sexuality of Bay supporters? You blokes are sick.

???

C'mon Media Park, think.

Honestly, I have no idea....

[redwhiteandblueblooded]

Seriously MP??

Check your location for a clue

[Punk Rooster]

How come Jimmy Allan didn't have a picture of him & his date on the red carpet ?

Any wonder why we question the sexuality of Bay supporters? You blokes are sick.

[CENTURION]

Now that Nick Liddle has finsihed second, does that mean he is good enough to join James Boyd at Centrals?

where would We put him? Can he ruck?