Rd 23 tribunal

[best on hill]

Goddard made a comment in the paper about the Ziebell tackle being reckless... Before it got to the review panel...

ziebells bump on riewolt was always going to sighted. as he hit the most protected species playing AFL. but i thought player weren't ment to comment on the matc review panal?

[Media Park]

But a comment in the media before it goes to the MRP? naughty naughty...

[best on hill]

But a comment in the media before it goes to the MRP? naughty naughty...

agreed, now if we can just shut the presidents up

[Rik E Boy]

West Coast better watch out they are playing the Laggers in the last round.

regards,

REB

[Pag]

West Coast better watch out they are playing the Laggers in the last round.

regards,

REB

Yep. Cox, Natanui, Kerr and LeCras better not make any physical contact with any Crows player or their seasons could be over too.

[Booney]

Goddard made a comment in the paper about the Ziebell tackle being reckless... Before it got to the review panel...

ziebells bump on riewolt was always going to sighted. as he hit the most protected species playing AFL. but i thought player weren't ment to comment on the matc review panal?

WTF? You saw the Zeibell "bump", yes? Bloody hell, a more dangerous act you wont see and to say Reiwoldt is protected is remarkable. All key forwards get a better ride than they used to, but they still cop it.

[Media Park]

Riewoldt generally is protected- but the Ziebell hit (not calling it a bump) was the most ridiculous thing I've seen in 2011.

[best on hill]

Goddard made a comment in the paper about the Ziebell tackle being reckless... Before it got to the review panel...

ziebells bump on riewolt was always going to sighted. as he hit the most protected species playing AFL. but i thought player weren't ment to comment on the matc review panal?

WTF? You saw the Zeibell "bump", yes? Bloody hell, a more dangerous act you wont see and to say Reiwoldt is protected is remarkable. All key forwards get a better ride than they used to, but they still cop it.

ease up boony like i said ziebell bump was always going to be sighted that what the rule is trying to get out of the game. but it is my believe that riewolt is a protected species.

[Psyber]

They are known to squeal arn't they? Wasn't the Birdman a squealer?

Yes he was.
The Crows also squealed in the Trengove sling tackle incident.
Will come back to bite them one day

I'm all in favour of any team "dobbing" players who break or bend the rules.
Not doing so is condoning unreasonable violence and castigating those who "dob" is a form of bullying.
If you want violence go for boxing or that other Universal code rubbish on TV.
Skill should rule in sport, not thuggery..

[howzat]

They are known to squeal arn't they? Wasn't the Birdman a squealer?

Yes he was.
The Crows also squealed in the Trengove sling tackle incident.
Will come back to bite them one day

I'm all in favour of any team "dobbing" players who break or bend the rules.
Not doing so is condoning unreasonable violence and castigating those who "dob" is a form of bullying.
If you want violence go for boxing or that other Universal code rubbish on TV.
Skill should rule in sport, not thuggery..

your joking arent you a tackle and bullying related roflmao hitting players behind play and with no intension of going for the ball i agree with as thats what the cameras and review panel was designed for but a tackle and dobbing in is rediculous.......if the match review panel didnt sight it until the cows told them then it couldnt of been that bad i watched the replay and didnt think anything of it until i heard the cows squeled........whats the game coming to i see netball games played harder than afl games......

[best on hill]

They are known to squeal arn't they? Wasn't the Birdman a squealer?

Yes he was.
The Crows also squealed in the Trengove sling tackle incident.
Will come back to bite them one day

I'm all in favour of any team "dobbing" players who break or bend the rules.
Not doing so is condoning unreasonable violence and castigating those who "dob" is a form of bullying.
If you want violence go for boxing or that other Universal code rubbish on TV.
Skill should rule in sport, not thuggery..

your joking arent you a tackle and bullying related roflmao hitting players behind play and with no intension of going for the ball i agree with as thats what the cameras and review panel was designed for but a tackle and dobbing in is rediculous.......if the match review panel didnt sight it until the cows told them then it couldnt of been that bad i watched the replay and didnt think anything of it until i heard the cows squeled........whats the game coming to i see netball games played harder than afl games......

i just hope every other club takes a set against the crows and dob them in every chance they get

[howzat]

yeah best on hill and just watch the supporters complain they got dobbed in lol

[bloods08]

i just hope every other club takes a set against the crows and dob them in every chance they get

If a crows player did the same thing, I have no problems with the opposition dobbing us in. If you do the crime, you should do the time. It's like someone reporting an assault. Just because the judiciary didn't see him do it, doesn't mean he can't be prosecuted. Thats what witnesses are for.

[howzat]

i just hope every other club takes a set against the crows and dob them in every chance they get

If a crows player did the same thing, I have no problems with the opposition dobbing us in. If you do the crime, you should do the time. It's like someone reporting an assault. Just because the judiciary didn't see him do it, doesn't mean he can't be prosecuted. Thats what witnesses are for.

we are talking about a bloody tackle not an assault......as you say though thats what (squelers) i mean witnesses are for i suppose....