Tribunal discussion/views/debate

[Big Phil]

Surely the Dogs will appeal the Sutherlands verdict, that was weak as piss

Clint Alleway got done the week before for the same thing, I don't think they will.

It was just stupiud on Pumpa's part doing it in the first place, regardless of how 'soft' it was.

[CENTURION]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

[Jim05]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Was about to say the same, Alleway is a known thug, big differance IMO

[whufc]

imho the club will appeal because they have nothing to lose by doing so.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Do you think there will be a day when people stop whinging about tribunal verdicts? No matter how "soft" the game of football may seem to be getting, football supporters will always be softer.

[redandblack]

imho the club will appeal because they have nothing to lose by doing so.

I think they have several thousand dollars to potentially lose, whufc.

[whufc]

meh chicken feed

[Big Phil]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Might be a first offence with Central but he has been opn another SANFL list with Glenelg and your record carries over from the past 7 years.

I think Pumpa may have had a few indiscetions when with the Bays, but I could be wrong?

May just have a bad record, albeit from the past, that would have some say in things.

[The Sleeping Giant]

meh chicken feed

Don't want to go digging into the light globe money again though.

[Hazydog]

you draw the line at deliberate, dangerous & totally unnecessary contact. simple really. once again, once you have a player in a tackle, where he can't either dispose of the ball or break free, there is nothing further required to get an umpire's adjudication. It will either be a bounce, play on, or holding the ball. By slinging the player, you have now placed yourself in a position where the ball can break free anyway BUT will possibly injure the opponent &/or place the slinger on report.

Disagree Centurion. 1. From what I can gather you are suggesting that all tackles be conducted with both players standing? 2. Coaches have instructed players from day dot to bring the player to ground. 3. Depending on the situation, both the the tackler and player being tackled, (tackleree??), may want the ball either to be dislodged or want to keep the ball bottled up - and in some instances bringing the player to ground may be the best way of achieving that.

Anyway - probably getting off topic here...

[The Sleeping Giant]

I think everyone should lay off Allers. He hasn't done anything wrong for two weeks now.

[G]

Just as a matter of interest, can anyone tell me how many games that "thug" Alleway has missed through suspension ?
- Spelly maybe ?

[StrayDog]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Might be a first offence with Central but he has been opn another SANFL list with Glenelg and your record carries over from the past 7 years.

I think Pumpa may have had a few indiscetions when with the Bays, but I could be wrong?

May just have a bad record, albeit from the past, that would have some say in things.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AFL_Tribun ... deductions

Reckon the "good record" deduction may apply after five years, unless there's a local variation.

[Big Phil]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Might be a first offence with Central but he has been opn another SANFL list with Glenelg and your record carries over from the past 7 years.

I think Pumpa may have had a few indiscetions when with the Bays, but I could be wrong?

May just have a bad record, albeit from the past, that would have some say in things.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AFL_Tribun ... deductions

Reckon the "good record" deduction may apply after five years, unless there's a local variation

Yes, there is a local variation, with 7 years being the carry over period:

http://www.sanfl.com.au/league/reports/ ... e_reports/ (at the bottom of the list)

Tribunal System
100 points = 1 match ban, under 100 points = reprimand

Additions:
10% is added to your base points for every game you have been suspended for in the past 3 years.

Deductions:
Guilty plea: 20% Deduction
Good record: 25% Deduction (a player that has never been found guilty of an offence in the last 7 years)

[The Sleeping Giant]

7 years? Christ. Get less for armed robbery.

[robranisgod]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Pumpa's 3rd offence, Alleway's 2nd offence

[CENTURION]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Pumpa's 3rd offence, Alleway's 2nd offence

thugs, the pair of them

[dedja]

7 years? Christ. Get less for armed robbery.

the 7 years is for being good ...

[The Sleeping Giant]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Pumpa's 3rd offence, Alleway's 2nd offence

thugs, the pair of them

So who are the thugs in the SANFL? Eagleton of course, Allers, Pumpa, Parry, Grocke, Cicca, Chris Gowans (the evil twin), Clayton, Grima and half of the West team.

[CENTURION]

Pumpa's 1st offence, Alltheway's ? offence?

Pumpa's 3rd offence, Alleway's 2nd offence

thugs, the pair of them

So who are the thugs in the SANFL? Eagleton of course, Allers, Pumpa, Parry, Grocke, Cicca, Chris Gowans (the evil twin), Clayton, Grima and half of the West team.

yes.