Glenelg v WWT Eagles Review

[tigerpie]

memo to all non glenelg supporters:

an overwhelming majority of our fans loved the singing of the club song on the ground after the game, and quite frankly we couldnt give a **** if you agree with it or not and that is the same for homfray smith and co WE DONT CARE WHAT YOU THINK!!!!!!!!!!!

wild applause stampy ya read my mind.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Good on ya's. Has been some OTT celebrations at Alberton in recent times when North have won there.

[gossipgirl]

memo to all non glenelg supporters:

an overwhelming majority of our fans loved the singing of the club song on the ground after the game, and quite frankly we couldnt give a **** if you agree with it or not and that is the same for homfray smith and co WE DONT CARE WHAT YOU THINK!!!!!!!!!!!

EXACTLY, GREAT COMMENT

[Booney]

memo to all non glenelg supporters:

an overwhelming majority of our fans loved the singing of the club song on the ground after the game, and quite frankly we couldnt give a **** if you agree with it or not and that is the same for homfray smith and co WE DONT CARE WHAT YOU THINK!!!!!!!!!!!

Thats funny. You think that we'd like to know if you care....

[JK]

Just watched some highlights on the the Adelaidenow site and looked to me as though the HTB call on Treeby was spot on .. I'm not sure who the Eagles player was that missed applying the shepherd, but that was the killer.

[on the rails]

Good on ya's. Has been some OTT celebrations at Alberton in recent times when North have won there.

Even so - still haven't seen our players sing the song in front of the supporters mind you but (1) There's not much to sing about in recent times and (2) With the amazing amount of supporters they let in the room after a game there's nearly as many in there as there are out on the terraces so probably wouldn't matter!

[The Sleeping Giant]

Just watched some highlights on the the Adelaidenow site and looked to me as though the HTB call on Treeby was spot on .. I'm not sure who the Eagles player was that missed applying the shepherd, but that was the killer.

I'm not too sure. Looked like he got a handball away fairly quickly.

[JK]

Just watched some highlights on the the Adelaidenow site and looked to me as though the HTB call on Treeby was spot on .. I'm not sure who the Eagles player was that missed applying the shepherd, but that was the killer.

I'm not too sure. Looked like he got a handball away fairly quickly.

Yeah possible I guess, it's a bit obscured by the non-shepherding teammate, but if he did get the handball off it was until after he'd taken the tackler on

[The Sleeping Giant]

Eagles got lucky against Sturt, so I guess it all evens out in the long run.

[bloods08]

Anyone know what the official attendance was?

[HOORAY PUNT]

Having a shot at Jai Bednall is a bit rough. His articles are accurate most times IMO , I reckon he writes well .

[whufc]

Having a shot at Jai Bednall is a bit rough. His articles are accurate most times IMO , I reckon he writes well .

True but he does make alot of school boy errors for a bloke who is writing as his paid profession.

[am Bays]

Well there are photos on SL.org that demonstrate that it was illegal disposal due to the tackle. Mulesy actually wraps up Treeby's R hand in tackling him which means that there was no way he could have handballed it legally.

[HOORAY PUNT]

Still happy to have him cover SANFL. Could be a hell of a lot worse .................
At least Jai understands the game and writes only about it with no other agenda.

[am Bays]

Having a shot at Jai Bednall is a bit rough. His articles are accurate most times IMO , I reckon he writes well .

True but he does make alot of school boy errors for a bloke who is writing as his paid profession.

Go easy on the bloke, his articles are his Grade 7 Naplan tests....

[whufc]

Still happy to have him cover SANFL. Could be a hell of a lot worse .................
At least Jai understands the game and writes only about it with no other agenda.

True whats the old saying any publicity is..........

[dedja]

Still happy to have him cover SANFL. Could be a hell of a lot worse .................
At least Jai understands the game and writes only about it with no other agenda.

QED

[FlyingHigh]

Just watched some highlights on the the Adelaidenow site and looked to me as though the HTB call on Treeby was spot on .. I'm not sure who the Eagles player was that missed applying the shepherd, but that was the killer.

I'm not too sure. Looked like he got a handball away fairly quickly.

Yeah possible I guess, it's a bit obscured by the non-shepherding teammate, but if he did get the handball off it was until after he'd taken the tackler on

Well there are photos on SL.org that demonstrate that it was illegal disposal due to the tackle. Mulesy actually wraps up Treeby's R hand in tackling him which means that there was no way he could have handballed it legally.

Agree with a bit of all of this. The shepherd was pretty average, especially that they didn't work out to rush a point between them when they were 2 points up. The call seemed a bit quick to me if he did handball it, the vision on AdelaideNow was a bit hard to see, but happy for it to be HTB if it, am Bays, if it wasn't a proper disposal seeing as he tried to get around the player.

[HOORAY PUNT]

I notice on the Adelaide Now video that a scuffle broke out early. Was this Glenelg driven as I think they tried to ruffle a few feathers against West early as well.Maybe that is part of Massies plan ?

[HOORAY PUNT]

Still happy to have him cover SANFL. Could be a hell of a lot worse .................
At least Jai understands the game and writes only about it with no other agenda.

True whats the old saying any publicity is..........

Reading the article , there is nothhing wrong with what he said and in fact makes some valid points.