Tribunal discussion/views/debate

[CoverKing]

Logan Hill had a suspected broken nose after one of the incidents

Suspected? Bloody hell, just look at it and you'll be able to tell. Has it taken 3 days to work that out at CitySpectrumStadium?

working with him on the sunday, he not only had a broken nose, he was concussed as well. didnt sleep at all friday night! His nose got rather wide, which was hard because it was pretty wide and big before hand

[Big Phil]

The Taylor Walker situation:

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6060970979

[DOC]

BP. A centrals reserve player was booked in the second quarter for a pick up and dump tackle. Any news?

[blueandwhite]

The Taylor Walker situation:

http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 6060970979

looking at the video.. I think he may be having a couple of beers this week.....

[Big Phil]

BP. A centrals reserve player was booked in the second quarter for a pick up and dump tackle. Any news?

Yes, it was Tanunda lad Matthew Prior.

I didn't see the incident myself, had my head down jotting down some stats, when it happened so can't really comment on it.

I'd suspect he will have his hearing tomorrow evening when the league tribunal sits as well.

[Big Phil]

Channel 10 News just said Taylor Walker's hearing is still underway, although they confirmed he did plead 'guilty'.

I'd suggest he'll get over the 100 points but with the early guilty plea and clean sheet, he'll get the discounts and reduction to a reprimand.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Channel 10 News just said Taylor Walker's hearing is still underway, although they confirmed he did plead 'guilty'.

I'd suggest he'll get over the 100 points but with the early guilty plea and clean sheet, he'll get the discounts and reduction to a reprimand.

The Sleeping Giant
League - Best 21


Posts: 2090
Teams:
Broadview

Re: Round 8 LIVE scores
Early plea. Good record. No suspension.

_________________
Ssshhh.....you'll wake the sleeping giant.

Fri May 20, 2011 10:55 pm

[Big Phil]

Walker found NOT GUILTY despite pleading GUILTY

Good news for both Crows and Legs fans, and Taylor of course.


http://www.sanfl.com.au/league/reports/ ... e_reports/

[tigerland09]

Taylor Walker Ffound not guilty of charging.

[The Sleeping Giant]

LMAO. That is gold. Can the SANFL become any more of a joke.

[CENTURION]

LMAO. That is gold. Can the SANFL become any more of a joke.

yes.

[The Sleeping Giant]

According to reports, pleaded guilty then changed his plea later. I wonder who had a quiet word in his ear.

[mickey]

SANFL doing the crows a favour by letting an AFL listed player of the hook scott free. Has set up a dangerous precedent now... look out any player who has the guts to go back with the flight

[CENTURION]

did you do it? yeah but no but yeah but no but.....

[cripple]

not a good precedent to be set but the same thing happened with a worse effort in the WAFL with daniel kerr earlier in the year.

[Blacky]

what a joke hope he cops his one day then see what the cows say

[85 WAS A GOOD YEAR]

Alex Grima got a reprimand.

About time they stopped picking on the Grima brothers

[Mark_Beswick]

Cool - now anyone else who goes up can use that footage to get their blokes off - Men of the SANFL v softies of the AFL when taking repective tribunals into account > gotta love our comp!

[Adelaide Hawk]

what a joke hope he cops his one day then see what the cows say

Cops what? A push in the back?

BTW ... Who are Norwood playing this week? Oh, that's right .. West.

[southee]

Not much difference in Walkers hit than Adam Cockshell from South's...and Cocky got 2 weeks!!!

Utter joke!!!!