2010 Magarey Medal

[fester69]

Aside from Robran and possibly Phillips have North ever produced a deserving winner?

[bayman]

You bloody Idiot Bayman
You told me there was a leak and that Allen was the winner
Next time get your bloody facts and spelling wright

put this in the worst jokes thread

[eaglehaslanded]

Congratulations Jimmy Allan - very deserving winner.

Another evenly spread vote again this season to the Eagles boys with Scotty Lewis our leading vote getter with 14 votes, an outstanding effort in his first season at the club.

[Footy Chick]

Great speech I thought, very heartfelt, with a touch of humour - a good mix

Everyone can sit here an bitch and whinge about who they think should have won.

Years ago we wouldn't have questioned the winner. Let the poor bloke have his 15 mins of fame without shooting him down FFS

[Ecky]

FINAL COUNT

Allan has won !!

Allan 22
Lower 20
T Allen 17

If only the 3 votes in that R5 North-Glenelg game went to Allen and not Allan

Not sure Ty was our best that game but I can name half a dozen players who were better than James Allan

Yes, I agree Ty didn't deserve any votes in that game but you never know what the umpires are thinking.

[pipers]

Dolling got 10 for the Magpies.

And LOL - Nestor just said "fat lady"

[zipzap]

Did I just hear Kelly say 'The Fat Lady has sung?'
Who could she be referring to?

[bulldogproud2]

I think Allan showed what he thought of North's decision to sack Healy.
We had a worse start under Jonas than North have had under Heals and yet he led us to a premiership.
Silly move, North!

?

x2 ??

Maybe a slight exaggeration on saying our start was worse but I can remember that Jonas was under a lot of pressure from many Central supporters at first. It took a fair while before we started to have success. He had to change our game plan to the same way Heals has been trying to change North's.
Anyway, that is for another discussion. Tonight is James's night - well done!

[Morrie]

Fester69 = TOOL!

[mal]

If they counted the NW /GL final it woUld have been
LOWER 23
ALLAN 22

[Stevie_K]

Apparently the fat lady has sung on the SANFL season?

I take it Norwood won the flag??

[Dutchy]

Why wasnt Archard there as a previous winner?

[JAS]

Great speech I thought, very heartfelt, with a touch of humour - a good mix

Everyone can sit here an bitch and whinge about who they think should have won.

Years ago we wouldn't have questioned the winner. Let the poor bloke have his 15 mins of fame without shooting him down FFS

Well said FC and well done to James (even if we was robbed)

Regards
JAS

[Punk Rooster]

Aside from Robran and possibly Phillips have North ever produced a deserving winner?

J Francou, D Lindner, B Barbary, A Jarman etc...

[southee]

Why wasnt Archard there as a previous winner?

Probably back on the farm.

[Ecky]

Dolling got 10 for the Magpies.

And LOL - Nestor just said "fat lady"

I think she was having a dig at your previous post, Pipers.
Hi Kelly!

[Media Park]

Aside from Robran and possibly Phillips have North ever produced a deserving winner?

J Francou, D Lindner, B Barbary, A Jarman etc...

Fester got a big scalp to bite there...

[am Bays]

Aside from Robran and possibly Phillips have North ever produced a deserving winner?

J Francou, D Lindner, B Barbary, A Jarman etc...

Thank goodness you had the decency (and football nous) to not mention Antrobus....

[sjt]

Great speech I thought, very heartfelt, with a touch of humour - a good mix

Everyone can sit here an bitch and whinge about who they think should have won.

Years ago we wouldn't have questioned the winner. Let the poor bloke have his 15 mins of fame without shooting him down FFS

Wrong, I question it every year a Centrals player doesn't win.

[PhilH]

Final Leaderboard (according to Adelaide Now web cast)

J Allan (NA) 22
N Lower (Nw) 20
T Allen (Gl) 17
B Zorzi (Nw) 16

14
S Lewis (Ea)
J Sheedy (St)
I Callinan (CD)
P Thomas (CD)

12
S Phillips (Nw)

11
N Duigan (Nw)

10
S McGlone (St)
N Dolling (PA)
S McGlone (St)
J Clayton (PA)
J Cicolella (Ea)

9
T Gum (St)