Reserves Elim Final: Centrals v West @ Woodville (Sat)

[Big Phil]

And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

They've played too many League games, so they are ineligable

I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

When both or all sides are in the finals qualification games don't apply for interchange between league/ressies and U18s.

Thanks for clarifying that am Bays, sorry Pidge, but didn't think that was the case at all mate...

So it must be a case of Roy Laird holding back Habel and Hardy or they are injured...

[Grahaml]

I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

When both or all sides are in the finals qualification games don't apply for interchange between league/ressies and U18s.

Surely that doesn't count for when the league side has a week off in the finals. Otherwise we could choose to play half our top team in the reserves this week. Heck, we could give Jay Nash a run in the reserves since he's had his week off.

My bet is any player who is reserves qualified can play, while any player who played the previous game in the reserves can apply for permission to play.

[whufc]

I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

When both or all sides are in the finals qualification games don't apply for interchange between league/ressies and U18s.

Surely that doesn't count for when the league side has a week off in the finals. Otherwise we could choose to play half our top team in the reserves this week. Heck, we could give Jay Nash a run in the reserves since he's had his week off.

My bet is any player who is reserves qualified can play, while any player who played the previous game in the reserves can apply for permission to play.

i think your spot on graham. when the sanfl sent central the list of players available this week switala wasnt included. the club seeked permission to play hin and it was approved.

while if the ressies win today next week is open selection for every central player. even though it would never happen effectively gowans could be dropped in the ressies next week

[Big Phil]

FINAL SCORES @ WOODVILLE

Reserves Elimination Final:

Central - 16.15 = 111

West - 8.11 = 59



Goal Kickers:

Central: T.Dunne, D.Hynes, L.Westhoff 3, J.Vater, M.Westhoff 2, M.Frail, C.Musolino, A.Switala 1

West: Br.Fisher, T.Langford 2, S.Birss, D.Webb, R.Blesing, M.Jose 1



Better Players:

Central: L.Westhoff, D.Hynes, T.Dunne, J.Schiller, C.Musolino, A.Duncan, J.Hannath, D.Haydon

West: S.Birss, Br. Fisher, T.Langford, J.Rowe, M.Jose



This now means Justin Hardy and Luke Habel are eligable to play for the Dogs reserves next week because the lCentral league side will be playing.

[scott]

A rise from the ashes by the Dogs, who were 2-8 or something at one stage of the season.

[CENTURION]

Leigh Westhoff must have had at least 40 possessions, played like a man inspired!!

[bulldogproud2]

Great win, boys!
Now for the first semi.

[Thiele]

Good win by Centrals we weren't that good today

[redandblack]

One of those games where West were rarely more than 2 goals behind most of the day, but you couldn't work out why.

Centrals were far too good and although the margin blew out in the last quarter, West were very disappointing.

Shane Birss was once again a mile better than anyone else for West.

[sjt]

And not sure why with the Dogs reserves side there is no Habel or Hardy who both played reserves last week?

They've played too many League games, so they are ineligable

I would have thought anyone with League and Reserves still in finals could please themselves who played where until the League side was out of finals. SANFL clearly dosen't = common sense.

When both or all sides are in the finals qualification games don't apply for interchange between league/ressies and U18s.

Thanks for clarifying that am Bays, sorry Pidge, but didn't think that was the case at all mate...

So it must be a case of Roy Laird holding back Habel and Hardy or they are injured...

I think you may be right Pidge. Hardy said, he and Habel weren't eligible, something about too many league games. Not exactly sure.

[MagareyLegend]

What is going on at West?
Reserves coach livid that the senior coach came in and took over training during the week.
Not happy Jan, absolute control freak apparently.

[redandblack]

Total nonsense.

I would have thought you'd have enough problems wondering what's happening at your club without trolling about West.

[MagareyLegend]

Total nonsense.

Obviously you are not in the know in your own club.

I would have thought you'd have enough problems wondering what's happening at your club without trolling about West.

Too true but relevance factor zero.

Are you serious you didn't know about this?

[oldfella]

Similar to R&B I was at training this week as normal and training took place as normal?

[MagareyLegend]

Were you there for all sessions including late in the week.

[redandblack]

Yes, ML, oldfella and I were, but I'd say you weren't.

Training was exactly as normal and the Reserves coach took training as usual on Friday.

[The Apostle]

I managed to catch the match from halfway through the 2nd qtr onwards. Not much in it up until after the 3/4 time break when Centrals turned it on.

Highlight for me was in the last quarter when West Adelaide decided to replace the person who was doing their (dodgy) kick ins after a point with Jeremy Rowe. His first kick in got cut off and resulted in a Dogs goal. I remember his name as I was giving him heaps from behind the goals after that stuff up!!!

[bloods08]

What is going on at West?
Reserves coach livid that the senior coach came in and took over training during the week.
Not happy Jan, absolute control freak apparently.

If he was such a control freak, Why wasn't he coaching the team yesterday instead of sitting in the stand watching on.

[bulldog2004]

Leigh Westhoff must have had at least 40 possessions, played like a man inspired!!

apparently only had 28 possessions.

[nickname]

What is going on at West?
Reserves coach livid that the senior coach came in and took over training during the week.
Not happy Jan, absolute control freak apparently.

Must have a different definition of 'Senior Coach' at North Adelaide.