schimma wrote:teaoby wrote:;)NO-MERCY wrote:If the umpires not sure as to what happened it should be thrown out.
Maybe Seaton should ask the League if Bruce Barnes from Seaton can be relieved of his suspension & play this weeks Grand Final.
I don't see why not as the League seem to have a variety of different rules for different clubs.
in a way i see your point NM, if the umpy saw somthing warranting a straight red then surely they can explain what happened to the panel. seems a bit convienent that "oh im not sure what happened" either way doesnt really effect portland they never win the first 3 of the year anyway.
think you might be taking the piss on the barnes thing though NM he obviously did enough to get 12 so probably deserves some time off.
12 games over 45 years off footy and 9000000 games. i say let the old bugga play. still good enough
didnt they do the 12 games over only the past 5years or something? dont thiink it was all time. could be wrong though