who will win c6 flag in 2010

[Executive Member]

So do you think it's a fair rule then ???
To drop 3 grades lower than the grade you have played 2/3rds of the year in ??

What I think isnt relevant to the decision making process
I and others must make rulings based on the rules and in this case the rule is clear cut that the players can play - we cant over rule a rule just because we dont like it, imagine if we did I am sure PAOC would be quoting the rule at us saying we havent followed it

I know I keep going back to it but only the Clubs can change this type of rule through the rules & regulations process, which is done at the beginning of each year

This was one of the rules changed at the start of this year

[a2m]

I would like to congratulate paoc for playing by the rules, personally I think it is very honourable by the to take the right steps now early in the week, golden grove know who they are playing against why don't just put plans in at training tonight to try and stop their better players, use your energy that way boys, GAME ON...

[TEX07]

So do you think it's a fair rule then ???
To drop 3 grades lower than the grade you have played 2/3rds of the year in ??

What I think isnt relevant to the decision making process
I and others must make rulings based on the rules and in this case the rule is clear cut that the players can play - we cant over rule a rule just because we dont like it, imagine if we did I am sure PAOC would be quoting the rule at us saying we havent followed it

I know I keep going back to it but only the Clubs can change this type of rule through the rules & regulations process, which is done at the beginning of each year

This was one of the rules changed at the start of this year

Ok then so what was the reason the rule needed to be changed at the start of this season then? All I can see is this happening right from the start. If the rules are that clear cut, why did they need to apply for a clearance in the first place? Surely if it was as obvious as you say it is then PAOC should have just been able to play them? I would assume the SAAFL did not make this rule for this to happen?

[Choccies]

So do you think it's a fair rule then ???
To drop 3 grades lower than the grade you have played 2/3rds of the year in ??

What I think isnt relevant to the decision making process
I and others must make rulings based on the rules and in this case the rule is clear cut that the players can play - we cant over rule a rule just because we dont like it, imagine if we did I am sure PAOC would be quoting the rule at us saying we havent followed it

I know I keep going back to it but only the Clubs can change this type of rule through the rules & regulations process, which is done at the beginning of each year

This was one of the rules changed at the start of this year

I didn't ask if what you thought was relevant to the decision making process in regard to permits. I asked what was YOUR OPINION on the rule ??

[newbloke]

well if your A's had done the right thing and won last week u'd be fine too

sorry couldn't help myself. but in all seriousness. we're not trying to mess with the system these blokes have legitimatly come back from injury and need a game. we're just lucky enough to have everyone else already in a GF[/quote]

So do we but we aren't blatantly cheating like that !! Waltham has played 12 A grade games so to prepare for his A grade finals he 'needs' to play a D grade game ?? Get yer hand off it.... Thats a crap rule and I dont care what piss weak crap Executive Member comes out with but thats a joke and if he is on the committee that approves those permits he should hang his boots up. Disgrace. [/quote]

Thanks for the vote of confidence there Choccies it means a lot to me
Can I suggest that if you and your club are outraged by the rule then you speak to your Club Delegate who has the power to get it changed
It's not like we sat around and made the rule up all we can do is enforce it and like I said if you and your club feel that strongly about it then you have the power to change it[/quote]

Clearly the rule wont be changed by Saturday and will not change the feeling that our players will feel for the rest of our lives of being cheated by the SAAFL if we lose on saturday.[/quote]

Fair Dinkum you are carrying on a bit. How about yopu go out there and beat them? Teams do this every year. They are playing within the rules? This game is lost before you even go out there. Go on blame the SAAFL for it. How about you focus your energy on the game not what you cant control. Imagine the feeling if you win!

[Choccies]

Which club are you from newbloke ?

[catchisthecry]

Waltham's a freak!
Good luck to the C6 fullback who gets the job..
Seems to have been around forever too, playing for PAOC in early 2000's? How old is he?

[TEX07]

Waltham's a freak!
Good luck to the C6 fullback who gets the job..
Seems to have been around forever too, playing for PAOC in early 2000's? How old is he?

Especially since he has kicked 23 goals in the Div 3 comp for the top side.

[Old Dog 13]

What are you's worried about?? You've got Elsworthy!!!

[Choccies]

What are you's worried about?? You've got Elsworthy!!!

Finally some sanity to the discussion....

[a2m]

See your both a bunch of cheats haha, golden grove with that umpire still takes the cake though...

[turbo182]

Ha, bit of a laugh. But I am now filfthy I didn't get my permit Executive member!

If memory serves round 11 against PAC was my last game before i was injured as well...

[Footy_Rulz]

Prince Alfred Old Collegians =

[Footy_Rulz]

Ha, bit of a laugh. But I am now filfthy I didn't get my permit Executive member!

If memory serves round 11 against PAC was my last game before i was injured as well...

Turbo you idiot, you have to play FOR PAOC to get a "special permit", and you only qualify if you play As or Bs and want to play D-Grade this weekend

[Jimmy_041]

All that energy for nothing

Lloyd, Haydn
1* Allen, Anthony
13* Heitmann, Andrew
39 Balnaves, Adam
49 Sanders, David
52 Simmons, Bradley
54 Coop, John
65 Davis, Matthew
73 Murray, Alastair
81 Farminer, William
85 Thomas, James
86 Burford, Max
88 May, James
89 Boord, Thomas
95 Wood, Samuel
98 Weidenhofer, Bradley
102 Newbery, Benjamin
107 Winter, Ryan
110 Brabham, Antony
111 Olsson, Charles
113* Paine, Thomas
121 Lloyd, Randall
130 Gerner, David
136 Ellison, Thomas
140 Noblett, Will

and you're a tool FR if ever there was one

[Footy_Rulz]

Im more than happy to be called a tool if those guys are not playing !!

[Footy_Rulz]

P.S. Jimmy can you explain why your club applied for permits for the 3 blokes for the 4th of September when the D-Grade was the only team playing? or are the permits continuous for the 11th?

[Jimmy_041]

Probably to make you look stupid - mission accomplished

[Footy_Rulz]

Probably to make you look stupid - mission accomplished

Where did you get that team from anyway?

[Jimmy_041]

iscore and its on the SAAFL site