Tribunal outcomes

[MagareyLegend]

Not the last you will hear from this boy with this type of thing - leopards don't change their spots.
Roy, you are lots of things but you are not a personality transformer.
I think I have been around long enough to know that Central have got this one wrong.
In fact, with all their recruitment/development that is one thing they have failed on to date - a replacement for "buckets".

[Big Phil]

Not the last you will hear from this boy with this type of thing - leopards don't change their spots.
Roy, you are lots of things but you are not a personality transformer.
I think I have been around long enough to know that Central have got this one wrong.
In fact, with all their recruitment/development that is one thing they have failed on to date - a replacement for "buckets".

With all due respect and not doubting that you know what you know...

Let's not forget Cameron Milne suffered a season ending, shocking injury a few months ago and he was progressing very nicely. At just 19, he was certainly being looked at as the next long term ruckman for the club. Hopefully when the hip injury heals, Cameron can prove you wrong on that point.

Also, you don't know for a fact that Roy is incapable of getting the best of someone with a questionable background. If you saw the respect and way Sutherland looks Roy Laird in the eye when he is speaking to him, you would possibly think otherwise. At the end of the day as well, if Roy can see that Sutherland is not capable of fitting in to his mould of player at the club, he will have no issue in moving him on.

Yes, Sutherland was wreckless in the incident with Morris from West and yes, he may face the tribunal again, every player that takes the field will run the chance of facing the tribunal. Perhaps give the guy a chance to prove you wrong before passing judgement.

[Not Scared]

He was found not guilty! Doesn't that mean there wasn't much in this one and you should probably reserve judgement on whether he can keep his head or not? Haven't seen him do anything untoward for Berri this season either, apart from a bit of push and shove sticking up for team mates!

[bulldogproud2]

Yes, that is a bit of a harsh call, Magary Legend. Jason has not been guilty of any wrongdoing at this stage. I could have agreed with you if he was found guilty and given a reprimand but not guilty is not guilty.

Cheers

[whufc]

just another frustrated supporter from another club.

while every other club have sat on there bum we have been pro active and picked up a 200cm in his early 20's

without doing a pre season and only playing his third sanfl game he had 12 possesions 20 plus hitouts to be the best big man on the ground

these types dont grow on trees especially with the new import rule coming in him being a local is a huge benefit.

[CENTURION]

nup, he's a WITCH! BURN HIM!! A 200CM GOWANS!!

[maxyoz]

Pumpa is a big kid who occasionally does dumbass stuff. I reckon the discipline and professionalism of the Bulldogs will straighten him out to be a very good footballer.

Sadly we didn't get the chance to see it whilst he was at the Bay, but at least I was there to share in the joys of a Reserves Premiership with him back in 2007.

[Dogwatcher]

Pumpa is a big kid who occasionally does dumbass stuff. I reckon the discipline and professionalism of the Bulldogs will straighten him out to be a very good footballer.

Sadly we didn't get the chance to see it whilst he was at the Bay, but at least I was there to share in the joys of a Reserves Premiership with him back in 2007.

That is a great summation given what I've seen/heard of the fella.

[sjt]

Not the last you will hear from this boy with this type of thing - leopards don't change their spots.
Roy, you are lots of things but you are not a personality transformer.
I think I have been around long enough to know that Central have got this one wrong.
In fact, with all their recruitment/development that is one thing they have failed on to date - a replacement for "buckets".

So you've seen him play a bit? In the end you may be right, but I'll back Roy - he may be a "personality transformer". Some people have been known to grab a second chance when given one. Wasn't he found not guilty?

[G]

Whats a Ruckmen doing having 12 possesions ??????????

Ive been waiting about 5 years for O'Hara to get into double figures

[doggies4eva]

Pumpa is a big kid who occasionally does dumbass stuff. I reckon the discipline and professionalism of the Bulldogs will straighten him out to be a very good footballer.

Sadly we didn't get the chance to see it whilst he was at the Bay, but at least I was there to share in the joys of a Reserves Premiership with him back in 2007.

A glenelg supporter who makes sense.

[CENTURION]

Pumpa is a big kid who occasionally does dumbass stuff. I reckon the discipline and professionalism of the Bulldogs will straighten him out to be a very good footballer.

Sadly we didn't get the chance to see it whilst he was at the Bay, but at least I was there to share in the joys of a Reserves Premiership with him back in 2007.

A glenelg supporter who makes sense.

an oxymoron!

[OnSong]

Found these on the Westies facebook page of the alleged incident, followed by the botched report!

[MagareyLegend]

Clearly innocent - it was Buckets.

[bulldog2004]

In the second picture you can see Colin Rowston watching the play. So how did he go to report the wrong player.

[doggies4eva]

In the second picture you can see Colin Rowston watching the play. So how did he go to report the wrong player.

Notice the way that he maintains eye contact to ensure that Buckets gets the messsage

[Big Phil]

Will be a busy night at the tribunal tonight, a few players facing various charges:

TRIBUNAL REPORTS:

All reports heard tonight (Tuesday, August 10).

6:00pm – Ben Fisher – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

6:20pm – Shannon Green – West Adelaide – Striking

6:40pm – Steven Morris – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

7:00pm – Adam Grocke – Eagles – Charging

7:20pm – Andrew McIntyre – North Adelaide - Striking

[bloods08]

Will be a busy night at the tribunal tonight, a few players facing various charges:

TRIBUNAL REPORTS:

All reports heard tonight (Tuesday, August 10).

6:00pm – Ben Fisher – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

6:20pm – Shannon Green – West Adelaide – Striking

6:40pm – Steven Morris – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

7:00pm – Adam Grocke – Eagles – Charging

7:20pm – Andrew McIntyre – North Adelaide - Striking

Can't believe the Morris one made the tribunal - will get thrown out

Fisher in a bit of trouble - reprimand - 1 week.

Didn't see the Green one.

[Thiele]

Will be a busy night at the tribunal tonight, a few players facing various charges:

TRIBUNAL REPORTS:

All reports heard tonight (Tuesday, August 10).

6:00pm – Ben Fisher – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

6:20pm – Shannon Green – West Adelaide – Striking

6:40pm – Steven Morris – West Adelaide – Forceful Front On Contact

7:00pm – Adam Grocke – Eagles – Charging

7:20pm – Andrew McIntyre – North Adelaide - Striking

Can't believe the Morris one made the tribunal - will get thrown out

Fisher in a bit of trouble - reprimand - 1 week.

Didn't see the Green one.

Was thinking the same.

[Adelaide Hawk]

7:20pm – Andrew McIntyre – North Adelaide - Striking

When was this supposed to happen? I can't recall any reportable incidents. Do you have details who he is supposed to have struck, and in what quarter?