magarey medal betting (courtesy of sportsbet)

[Squawk]

Bays fans - who'd be polling better between Kane Tenace and Ty Allen?

[bayman]

Bays fans - who'd be polling better between Kane Tenace and Ty Allen?

i'd think it'd be pretty even but who knows what the umpires think & we do know that ty has polled well in the past

[bulldog2004]

Simon Phillips $34???????

[SDK]

Lewis from the Eagles is a class act and for mine would be a worthy winner.

However we have to remember one thing, umpires no NOTHING about football except rules written in black and white. They dont know a good player until they read about it in the paper. This is why established well know player poll well because the umpire is influenced by opinion and when he has no idea he will vote with the consensus.
They never appreciate good defensive players unless they are flashy and have no idea at all of the influence on a game a ruckman can have.

Brett Zorzi is one of the better players going around but umpires dont vote for good, hard, tough honest players . They like the flashy pretty boy types.

[bayman]

Lewis from the Eagles is a class act and for mine would be a worthy winner.

However we have to remember one thing, umpires no NOTHING about football except rules written in black and white. They dont know a good player until they read about it in the paper. This is why established well know player poll well because the umpire is influenced by opinion and when he has no idea he will vote with the consensus.
They never appreciate good defensive players unless they are flashy and have no idea at all of the influence on a game a ruckman can have.

Brett Zorzi is one of the better players going around but umpires dont vote for good, hard, tough honest players . They like the flashy pretty boy types.

having said that their aren't many (if any) players that have won it, be regarded as ordinary players & undeserving of their medal victories

[Squawk]

Has anyone heard any announcement yet as to whether the medal count will be telecast or broadcast this year?

[Big Phil]

Has anyone heard any announcement yet as to whether the medal count will be telecast or broadcast this year?

I think LifeFM are hoping to do something with it this year but it depends on the SANFL?

I would suggest Ian Callinan would have another 3 votes from the weekend?

[JK]

I would suggest Ian Callinan would have another 3 votes from the weekend?

Would have to surely, he was outstanding again on Saturday

[o five]

I've got no probelm with those prices. Certainly the Norwood players in there seem about right. Based on what I've seen, certainly Cullinan and Allan have been the stand outs so far in 2010.

FFS Who`s Cullinan?

Is that all you have to say? Hardly worth the effort. Ever tried actually contributing to a conversation for a change?

No

[catchisthecry]

Got $$ on S. Lewis at $26.
Prob could have got $501 at the start of the year!
Go Scotty!!

[LBJ8]

Bays fans - who'd be polling better between Kane Tenace and Ty Allen?

Smart man, was just going to post if someone from Glenelg is going to win it, it would be either Tenace or Allen, might have to go put some money on both at those odds.