Southern Football League

[Bloods4Life]

I like you... Unfortunately Kenilworth wouldn't get within 10 goals of Walkerville. I'm very happy to be proven wrong but....

SFL top 8 is a solid comp imo. Still not as good as GSFL and Hills which as I mentioned back even back around 2000 the SFL along with Western Border were the best comps out side Ammos div 1[/quote]


I said bottom sides, which were modbury and kilburn who only won a few games each, walkerville won 7 games and were a very competitive outfit. And with the players that each kenilworth and woodville south boasted, I would've backed them to beat both those sides this year.

[LaughingKookaburra]

Enter The Big Shrek

[Numbers]

a soulless premiership they claim wtf

Delusions of grandeur marbles. I know the SAAFL model is perfect and we should all be queueiing up, but something keeps us going back to the SFL. Could be just that playing within a spirited comp beats soulless premierships in Division 324?

1174995_536293516444388_686073407_n.jpg

Looks like they celebrating the chance to play for a real premiership next year!

Good luck to them, if it doesn't work out they can go back & win another chance!

What a stupid, uneducated and naive post. That side would easily account for 10 of the 15 SFL sides and challenge if not beat the others.

Please explain how it is either stupid, uneducated or naive? Or in fact even incorrect in anyway?

By your own admission they would have finished 5-8 (maybe slightly higher) in the SFL & would not be celebrating like that. There are 7 sides in the SAAFL that would celebrate like that every year & 6 of them know they weren't the best in the league.

[Bloods4Life]

What a stupid, uneducated and naive post. That side would easily account for 10 of the 15 SFL sides and challenge if not beat the others.[/quote]

Please explain how it is either stupid, uneducated or naive? Or in fact even incorrect in anyway?

By your own admission they would have finished 5-8 (maybe slightly higher) in the SFL & would not be celebrating like that. There are 7 sides in the SAAFL that would celebrate like that every year & 6 of them know they weren't the best in the league.[/quote]

Because not every club is positioned player wise or financially to compete with clubs that are hence why they're put in divisions that are more suitable to them. That's where it's uneducated and naive. An incorrect because that premiership is as genuine and real as any other to the players, members, supporters, life members and sponsors. What's div is the SFL? Div 1?? No it's a country like league that has its good teams and also it's strugglers, which there is probably a heap of leagues similar Australia wide, and I've never knocked the SFL. But don't come on here pal and talk down other clubs premierships or the div they're in. Who the hell are you to knock em. What are they suppose to do, just roll over and fold just cause you say they should?? Very uneducated!

[Numbers]

What a stupid, uneducated and naive post. That side would easily account for 10 of the 15 SFL sides and challenge if not beat the others.

Please explain how it is either stupid, uneducated or naive? Or in fact even incorrect in anyway?

By your own admission they would have finished 5-8 (maybe slightly higher) in the SFL & would not be celebrating like that. There are 7 sides in the SAAFL that would celebrate like that every year & 6 of them know they weren't the best in the league.[/quote]

Because not every club is positioned player wise or financially to compete with clubs that are hence why they're put in divisions that are more suitable to them. That's where it's uneducated and naive. An incorrect because that premiership is as genuine and real as any other to the players, members, supporters, life members and sponsors. What's div is the SFL? Div 1?? No it's a country like league that has its good teams and also it's strugglers, which there is probably a heap of leagues similar Australia wide, and I've never knocked the SFL. But don't come on here pal and talk down other clubs premierships or the div they're in. Who the hell are you to knock em. What are they suppose to do, just roll over and fold just cause you say they should?? Very uneducated![/quote]

I have obviously touched a nerve, but what does finance have to do with being competitive? Not every side has to pay more to be competitive.

I am not having a crack at any individual side, just the concept of playing in a lower division premiership & thinking it is the same as the top division. This really has nothing to do with SFL as the concept of the league is different.

Marbles was suggesting that playing in a lower division just so the struggling clubs in SFL could be "successful" would be rewarding. I don't think it would be rewarding.

I don't think that if Goodwood finds itself in Div 2 at some stage that a premiership at that level would come close to matching their recent success!

[Look Good In Leather]

I don't think that if Goodwood finds itself in Div 2 at some stage that a premiership at that level would come close to matching their recent success!

We all understand this, you aim to be the best in your league.

I don't think you will convince our friend marbles:

I doubt anyone there is caring that it wasnt the Div 1 flag their club achieved the ultimate success

Ultimate success?? No, a step on the way to getting to the top division so that you can then achieve that ultimate success.

Or in our league's case, the improvement required to achieve that ultimate success.

[marbles]

in 10 years that sfl flag will be ours! ya doing well great work

in 2014 we'll concentrate on handballing, the next year marking, then 2016 we'll teach ya tackling!!! mm yeah love you sfl, my next 200 games with christies will certainly be very fulfilling

[tigerpie]

Yep folks some village has lost its idiot

[Zelezny Chucks]

Yep folks some village has lost its idiot

I think this one is doing the work of a few villages.

[am Bays]

Nah, you can keep him

Ever heard the saying that starts "Don't argue with an idiot..."

Phaarrkk

This thread is gold.

FC can you teach some of these muppets how to use the quote function???

[heater31]

Nah, you can keep him

Ever heard the saying that starts "Don't argue with an idiot..."

Phaarrkk

This thread is gold.

FC can you teach some of these muppets how to use the quote function???

It adds to the hilarity IMO

[Zelezny Chucks]

Nah, you can keep him

Ever heard the saying that starts "Don't argue with an idiot..."

Phaarrkk

This thread is gold.

FC can you teach some of these muppets how to use the quote function???

If the Bay's don't fold, maybe Div 7 is an option for them?

[tigerpie]

Oh oh its contagious!

[WHEELS&DEALS]

If the Bay's don't fold, maybe Div 7 is an option for them?[/quote]

Merging with Morphy Parks and becoming the tiger-Roos

[Look Good In Leather]

If the Bay's don't fold, maybe Div 7 is an option for them?

Merging with Morphy Parks and becoming the tiger-Roos

Or perhaps the "Twisted Tigers"

[afc9798]

in 10 years that sfl flag will be ours! ya doing well great work

in 2014 we'll concentrate on handballing, the next year marking, then 2016 we'll teach ya tackling!!! mm yeah love you sfl, my next 200 games with christies will certainly be very fulfilling

Probably doesn't warrant a response as you're clearly trolling for a response, however, you clearly haven't noticed the significant improvement of a number of clubs this year in the SFL. Edwardstown, Christies and Hackham all had significant improvement over the prior year. Christies were very competitive and matched it with a number of the top teams for sustained periods, EDwardstown were 3 kicks away from a prelim and hackham had a few wins, beating Flagstaff Hill along the way.

If you want to comment, you should actually get a clue about what is happening in the league instead of preaching a model that is according to many in the SAAFL, a broken model itself.
SFL is far from perfect, but most of us here support the league in its current form whilst hoping for some changes that will improve it, ratyher than radically change the whole concept.

[HH3]

in 10 years that sfl flag will be ours! ya doing well great work

in 2014 we'll concentrate on handballing, the next year marking, then 2016 we'll teach ya tackling!!! mm yeah love you sfl, my next 200 games with christies will certainly be very fulfilling

Probably doesn't warrant a response as you're clearly trolling for a response, however, you clearly haven't noticed the significant improvement of a number of clubs this year in the SFL. Edwardstown, Christies and Hackham all had significant improvement over the prior year. Christies were very competitive and matched it with a number of the top teams for sustained periods, EDwardstown were 3 kicks away from a prelim and hackham had a few wins, beating Flagstaff Hill along the way.

If you want to comment, you should actually get a clue about what is happening in the league instead of preaching a model that is according to many in the SAAFL, a broken model itself.
SFL is far from perfect, but most of us here support the league in its current form whilst hoping for some changes that will improve it, ratyher than radically change the whole concept.

Ive played in both, and believe me, playing for North Haven A Grade in Div 5 is much more rewarding than playing in the As at Hackham and getting pumped by almost 60 goals one long arvo at Brighton Oval.

This isn't a knock on Hackham, because they're awesome people there, doing a ridiculously hard job.

There's a reason most SAAFL divisions are so competitive, and that's the promotion/relegation system. In the 3 seasons Ive been back at the Haviery, the teams competing in finals havent been decided until the final regular season game.

Just because its Div 5, doesn't mean we don't or shouldn't appreciate our successes.

This whole arguments like saying Div 1 teams shouldnt consider their premierships successes because they didnt do it in the SANFL. And SANFL Premiers shouldnt consider it a success because they didnt do it in the AFL.

[Esteban Vihaio]

If the Bay's don't fold, maybe Div 7 is an option for them?

Merging with Morphy Parks and becoming the tiger-Roos

Or perhaps the "Twisted Tigers"

Instead of being the roo boys they could be the roo bays

[Look Good In Leather]

in 10 years that sfl flag will be ours! ya doing well great work

in 2014 we'll concentrate on handballing, the next year marking, then 2016 we'll teach ya tackling!!! mm yeah love you sfl, my next 200 games with christies will certainly be very fulfilling

Gen Y

Why work hard for something special when you can take the easy option.

[afc9798]

in 10 years that sfl flag will be ours! ya doing well great work

in 2014 we'll concentrate on handballing, the next year marking, then 2016 we'll teach ya tackling!!! mm yeah love you sfl, my next 200 games with christies will certainly be very fulfilling

Probably doesn't warrant a response as you're clearly trolling for a response, however, you clearly haven't noticed the significant improvement of a number of clubs this year in the SFL. Edwardstown, Christies and Hackham all had significant improvement over the prior year. Christies were very competitive and matched it with a number of the top teams for sustained periods, EDwardstown were 3 kicks away from a prelim and hackham had a few wins, beating Flagstaff Hill along the way.

If you want to comment, you should actually get a clue about what is happening in the league instead of preaching a model that is according to many in the SAAFL, a broken model itself.
SFL is far from perfect, but most of us here support the league in its current form whilst hoping for some changes that will improve it, ratyher than radically change the whole concept.

Ive played in both, and believe me, playing for North Haven A Grade in Div 5 is much more rewarding than playing in the As at Hackham and getting pumped by almost 60 goals one long arvo at Brighton Oval.

This isn't a knock on Hackham, because they're awesome people there, doing a ridiculously hard job.

There's a reason most SAAFL divisions are so competitive, and that's the promotion/relegation system. In the 3 seasons Ive been back at the Haviery, the teams competing in finals havent been decided until the final regular season game.

Just because its Div 5, doesn't mean we don't or shouldn't appreciate our successes.

This whole arguments like saying Div 1 teams shouldnt consider their premierships successes because they didnt do it in the SANFL. And SANFL Premiers shouldnt consider it a success because they didnt do it in the AFL.

I don't disagree with you and can certainly appreciate the situation with being belted week in week out. I do not support other posters comments about the relevance of flags in any division, but I do take exception to this being the great panacea for struggling SFL Clubs. if it was, they would be doing it now. As I said SFL is far from perfect, but there is a reason clubs aren't leaving it.

We love the fact that our teams play against traditional rivals, all teams mostly play at the same grounds and we get to build that culture within the club of having all our guys developing together. it's not a slight on the SAAFL as it obviously works for most of those clubs, it's just a different model.