who will win c6 flag in 2010

[Footy_Rulz]

I reckon SMOSH would want PAOC to win, becuase half their players will need to go back and play C-Grade next week....

[Trader]

Where as if it is GG that progress then the entire GG-C4 side will play down??

[Footy_Rulz]

Nah because you would need permits in that situation. And there would be only 1 player that would get one.

[Trader]

Speaking of permits for C6 footy...

http://saafl.asn.au/files/uploads/leagu ... ept_10.pdf

[schimma]

Speaking of permits for C6 footy...

http://saafl.asn.au/files/uploads/leagu ... ept_10.pdf

just was looking at that. is that the waltham who has played A grade up forward last few years. what grade has he played all year.

[TEX07]

Where as if it is GG that progress then the entire GG-C4 side will play down??

Trust me, after this week we will be at this stage watching the B grade have a crack at the flag, hopefully add the A and D grade to that too!

[TEX07]

Speaking of permits for C6 footy...

http://saafl.asn.au/files/uploads/leagu ... ept_10.pdf

just was looking at that. is that the waltham who has played A grade up forward last few years. what grade has he played all year.

I think it is, was this list specifically for C6 footy or permits in general?

[Footy_Rulz]

HAHA so these guys played A-Grade in Round 11 in Div 3 and yet somehow became eligible to play D-Grade 2 months later?

[schimma]

HAHA so these guys played A-Grade in Round 11 in Div 3 and yet somehow became eligible to play D-Grade 2 months later?

they won by 20 goals that day as well. haha what a joke the SAAFL is for allowing them to play C6 football. that has to be looked into. we had guys in B grade that played the last 8 games of B grade but played 8 A grade in the first half and they got no permits.

[TEX07]

HAHA so these guys played A-Grade in Round 11 in Div 3 and yet somehow became eligible to play D-Grade 2 months later?

If that is true seems ridiculous that this can happen, I am not saying its PAOCs fault if they are playing within the rules then thats the rules, it is just dumb rules! Our B grade had a lad that was overseas until the last 3 games and played all these games and got knocked back on not enought games and three guys can play Div 3 footy and then when their clubs A, B and C grade have the week off in the finals play D grade. Goes against the spirit of the competition and poor form in my opinion.

[Footy_Rulz]

Clarke seems to have played under his preferred name of Michael maybe?. However just looking into a bit more Gazolla and Whalton did not play one game for the D-Grade from Round 12-18. And all three of them did not play for PAOC in the Qualifying final or Semi Final. What happened to the "not enough games in second half of season" rule?

[Choccies]

Waltham played B's in round 18....

[Footy_Rulz]

How could the SAAFL approve this? JOKE

[schimma]

Waltham played B's in round 18....

looks like one club is in bed with the SAAFL. its a shame for the blokes going to miss out. some one has some explaining to do???

[Footy_Rulz]

How much did PAOC pay for this to be approved ? I would like to hear the SAAFL Reasoning behind this.

[teaoby]

How much did PAOC pay for this to be approved ? I would like to hear the SAAFL Reasoning behind this.

mate i think you'll find we are very low on the list of clubs that saafl love. i.e the home finals debacle.

true gaz hasnt played loiwer then B's but also hasnt played since rd11 because of injury. same as max. not sure on jon though!

[Executive Member]

As one of the people who has to make the decision for permits I thought I would explain

The following rule as approved by CLUB Delegates at the start of the year

34.2 The following conditions shall apply for players when Member Clubs have more than one
team participating in the major round:
(a) There is free interchange of players between consecutively graded Divisions subject to
player’s eligibility.

PAOC currently have their top 3 sides still playing in the Major Round so players eligibility refers only to them playing 4 games during the year
Therefore any player who has not played in the finals in the A & B Grade is eligible to play - infact the rule allows for their entire C Grade side to play D Grade

Hope it at leasts explains the decision

[Footy_Rulz]

Well then the rule is a joke...and that is a massive loophole

[teaoby]

Well then the rule is a joke...and that is a massive loophole

well if your A's had done the right thing and won last week u'd be fine too

sorry couldn't help myself. but in all seriousness. we're not trying to mess with the system these blokes have legitimatly come back from injury and need a game. we're just lucky enough to have everyone else already in a GF

[newbloke]

So if there playing withing the rules, whats the problem? Clubs agreed to this at the start of the year. If you are more worried about 1 or 2 players playing, game is lost already. Heres a answer, go out and beat them!
Im sure 1 or 2 players doesnt make a team unbeatable.