VERSION 2: 7 Pure A-Grade Divisions

[Cohiba]

Our two M & M,s ..... reminds you bit about the real pair of M & M's.....polar opposites....

You get in the bowl.

Rather have a bowl....

[Jetters]

This is the dumbest shit ever. What is been proposed is a minor change, how can so much dibble be written about it?

Marbles your arguments blow and you are the worst salesman of all time. Although in principle your idea is fine.

People from low grade clubs are so fricken sensitive.


It would be best for a number of reasons if it was A v A and C v C.

Marbles you have the issue that this causes an unworkable number of clubs. You either have to have byes, invite new clubs to jump divs or leave clubs stranded. NO ONE LIKES THESE SOLUTIONS. When you think of a different solution, go for it.

Morell, on one hand you say you guys are really C graders and so in reality it is appropriate to play against big club's C grades. But on the other, you say you are actually an A grade side and therefore your existence should be prioritised over the big club's C grades. You can't have your cake and eat it too. A player is a player is a player no matter what club/what standard, you all pay the same subs to the League, the league cares about rate of participation. You all get treated equally as a mere number.

[marbles]

This is the dumbest shit ever. What is been proposed is a minor change, how can so much dibble be written about it?

Marbles your arguments blow and you are the worst salesman of all time. Although in principle your idea is fine.

People from low grade clubs are so fricken sensitive.


It would be best for a number of reasons if it was A v A and C v C.

Marbles you have the issue that this causes an unworkable number of clubs. You either have to have byes, invite new clubs to jump divs or leave clubs stranded. NO ONE LIKES THESE SOLUTIONS. When you think of a different solution, go for it.

Morell, on one hand you say you guys are really C graders and so in reality it is appropriate to play against big club's C grades. But on the other, you say you are actually an A grade side and therefore your existence should be prioritised over the big club's C grades. You can't have your cake and eat it too. A player is a player is a player no matter what club/what standard, you all pay the same subs to the League, the league cares about rate of participation. You all get treated equally as a mere number.

thankyou jetters u big equilibrium

ok put it this way, div 7 next year is so far looking like...

Mitchell Park (1 team)
Angle Vale
North Pines
Flinders Uni (1 team)
Wingfield (1 team)
Adelaide Uni Cs to stay?

is there away these battlers can play each other 3 times or 4 times or sum shit?

and lets not write off kilburn from this pack either, which will push another side up to div 6

oh and Blackwood C's are somewhere too? cgrade super league??

i honestly doubt uni would wanna stay in this comp

[morell]

Marbles you have the issue that this causes an unworkable number of clubs. You either have to have byes, invite new clubs to jump divs or leave clubs stranded. NO ONE LIKES THESE SOLUTIONS.

Mind you I don't know why I am applauding. This point has been made countless times by countless people and it still escapes marbles.

Morell, on one hand you say you guys are really C graders and so in reality it is appropriate to play against big club's C grades. But on the other, you say you are actually an A grade side and therefore your existence should be prioritised over the big club's C grades. You can't have your cake and eat it too. A player is a player is a player no matter what club/what standard, you all pay the same subs to the League, the league cares about rate of participation. You all get treated equally as a mere number.

NO I DIDNT YOU NUMPTIES! Hahah this is hilarious. You have bought into marbles false strawman Jetters. For **** sake I even clarified this not a page ago:

I am not saying any club should be put in front of any other club.

I am saying any clubs survival should be put in front of a C Grade sides right to choose what division they play in and who they play against.

Stop. Dribbling. Shit.

See if you can spot the difference.

[jo172]

This is the dumbest shit ever. What is been proposed is a minor change, how can so much dibble be written about it?

Marbles your arguments blow and you are the worst salesman of all time. Although in principle your idea is fine.

People from low grade clubs are so fricken sensitive.


It would be best for a number of reasons if it was A v A and C v C.

Marbles you have the issue that this causes an unworkable number of clubs. You either have to have byes, invite new clubs to jump divs or leave clubs stranded. NO ONE LIKES THESE SOLUTIONS. When you think of a different solution, go for it.

Morell, on one hand you say you guys are really C graders and so in reality it is appropriate to play against big club's C grades. But on the other, you say you are actually an A grade side and therefore your existence should be prioritised over the big club's C grades. You can't have your cake and eat it too. A player is a player is a player no matter what club/what standard, you all pay the same subs to the League, the league cares about rate of participation. You all get treated equally as a mere number.

thankyou jetters u big equilibrium

ok put it this way, div 7 next year is so far looking like...

Mitchell Park (1 team)
Angle Vale
North Pines
Flinders Uni (1 team)
Wingfield (1 team)
Adelaide Uni Cs to stay?

is there away these battlers can play each other 3 times or 4 times or sum shit?

and lets not write off kilburn from this pack either, which will push another side up to div 6

oh and Blackwood C's are somewhere too? cgrade super league??

i honestly doubt uni would wanna stay in this comp

Are you saying that if Henley are put in Div 7 next year they will pull their C and D Grades?

[marbles]

Are you saying that if Henley are put in Div 7 next year they will pull their C and D Grades?

No mate. Henley C & D are next in line to the div 7 virus. if we are there next year we'll be forfeiting too just like the clubs the virus has already eaten into

Im saying if all C grades went to a super c-grade league, excluding Adelaide Uni, div 7 could possibly look like this...

Mitchell Park (1 team)
Angle Vale
North Pines
Flinders Uni (1 team)
Wingfield (1 team)
Adelaide Uni Cs to stay?

i kind of doubt that Adelaide Uni will want to stay here amongst these minions. wouldnt you agree??

[morell]

See you next year marbles.

[tomo]

Gee, Henley's D grade must really hate being undefeated for the last two years!!!!
Div 7 is way too hard for them!!!!!

[Look Good In Leather]

Are you saying that if Henley are put in Div 7 next year they will pull their C and D Grades?

No mate. Henley C & D are next in line to the div 7 virus. if we are there next year we'll be forfeiting too just like the clubs the virus has already eaten into

Im saying if all C grades went to a super c-grade league, excluding Adelaide Uni, div 7 could possibly look like this...

Mitchell Park (1 team)
Angle Vale
North Pines
Flinders Uni (1 team)
Wingfield (1 team)
Adelaide Uni Cs to stay?

i kind of doubt that Adelaide Uni will want to stay here amongst these minions. wouldnt you agree??

Maybe it is time for Uni to split up into two A-grade clubs?
I know it has been considered in the past - they have done it with Monash in VIC

[X Runna]

Gee, Henley's D grade must really hate being undefeated for the last two years!!!!
Div 7 is way too hard for them!!!!!

Not quite correct - they were smashed at the Farm last season. HOWEVER - in principle you are correct. If as has been quoted "they are only there for a kick and a catch" why don't they bring some credibility to themselves, their club AND the competition by playing C Grade, because they are clearly Henley's 3rd best side.

IF, and only IF, Henley showed some metal and enforced this, marbles' ridiculous super C Grade competition may have half a modicim of merit.

[finn]

Are you saying that if Henley are put in Div 7 next year they will pull their C and D Grades?

No mate. Henley C & D are next in line to the div 7 virus. if we are there next year we'll be forfeiting too just like the clubs the virus has already eaten into

Im saying if all C grades went to a super c-grade league, excluding Adelaide Uni, div 7 could possibly look like this...

Mitchell Park (1 team)
Angle Vale
North Pines
Flinders Uni (1 team)
Wingfield (1 team)
Adelaide Uni Cs to stay?

i kind of doubt that Adelaide Uni will want to stay here amongst these minions. wouldnt you agree??

Maybe it is time for Uni to split up into two A-grade clubs?
I know it has been considered in the past - they have done it with Monash in VIC

Nope - Monash has two sides as one came from an another institution's team that became part of Monash Uni (in similar manner to Magill CAE becoming part of UniSA) as well as one from Monash itself. These clubs are also based at different campuses.
Uni won't be splitting into two clubs - and it certainly hasn't been considered in the last 15-20 years. Without pre-empting anything i'd say that Uni would be much more likely to try to stick its c grade in a competition that's more consistent than the potential one above though.

[marbles]

Ladies & Gentleman announcing a solution for you all...

This solution is based on 1 club - Kilburn

In observing they are now forfeiting every game, the prospect of them having 2 sides come March 2015 may be very slim. The league wont allow them to stay in Div 4. Theyll have to be removed.

This benefits everyone, 3 sides will have to come up from every division below, and as a result Div 7 will actually list all the clubs who have hit hard times in 2014.

This along with the creation of the C-Grade Super League, every club in the league excluding Kilburn is to benefit from an up-shuffle.

The only dilemma now is that the new Div 7 boys will have to play each other 3 times, and its still not known whether any of them can field 2 teams. Maybe it will have to become a 1 team per club division???....

2015z.jpg (67.83 KiB) Viewed 1321 times

Now how do you's all feel about this one???

[marbles]

hmmm wait div 7 with 6 placements play each other 3 times (5*3=15 rounds) - f##k wont work

[cracka]

Gotta give you credit for persistence.

[X Runna]

**** off marbles - are you the dumbest prick I've ever heard of?

NOBODY here gives a shit about your "BLUE-CHIP" Henley, crawl back under your rock.

[Neverwasgood]

Give up

[heater31]

Also the shit you have been posting recently has got similar treatment.

Give it up sunshine nobody cares about your nonsense posting.....

[Q.]

Another thread?

You raise a good point though, we've got no idea what will happen to some clubs over the next six months. Maybe there will only be enough teams for six divisions?

[marbles]

Another thread?

You raise a good point though, we've got no idea what will happen to some clubs over the next six months. Maybe there will only be enough teams for six divisions?

yeah another thread a new design

hopefully this saves Mitchell Park, Angle Vale, Flinders Uni, Wingfield, Kilburn for at least another year

Plus the clubs with 4 sides gain a better environment to flourish and to restore the recent erosions

apparently nobody cares for this though, let them all die seems to be the norm

[Look Good In Leather]

Ladies & Gentleman announcing a solution for you all...

This solution is based on 1 club - Kilburn

In observing they are now forfeiting every game, the prospect of them having 2 sides come March 2015 may be very slim. The league wont allow them to stay in Div 4. Theyll have to be removed.

This benefits everyone, 3 sides will have to come up from every division below, and as a result Div 7 will actually list all the clubs who have hit hard times in 2014.

This along with the creation of the C-Grade Super League, every club in the league excluding Kilburn is to benefit from an up-shuffle.

The only dilemma now is that the new Div 7 boys will have to play each other 3 times, and its still not known whether any of them can field 2 teams. Maybe it will have to become a 1 team per club division???....

2015z.jpg

Now how do you's all feel about this one???

Put Uni, Modbury, Henley, Smosh + one other in Div 7, shuffle Div 9 into the C Grades and all is good.