Kurt Tippett's playing future?

scoob · Post by **scoob** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 10:17 am

I'm really hoping this drags out a few more days and the advertiser can write a few more interesting articles about it... Great reading / great drama!!!

helicopterking · Post by **helicopterking** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 10:20 am

scoob wrote:I'm really hoping this drags out a few more days and the advertiser can write a few more interesting articles about it... Great reading / great drama!!!

Great for the bottom of the birdcage too.

Groover · Post by **Groover** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:17 pm

If Jesse White wants to come to SA why dont Port come to the party in the Tippett deal?
The Power could trade pick #7 to the crows
The Crows could trade Tippett to the Swans
and the Swans could trade White and pick #23 to the Power

doesn't this seem like a fair solution for all clubs?

scoob · Post by **scoob** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:19 pm

Groover wrote:If Jesse White wants to come to SA why dont Port come to the party in the Tippett deal?
The Power could trade pick #7 to the crows
The Crows could trade Tippett to the Swans
and the Swans could trade White and pick #23 to the Power

doesn't this seem like a fair solution for all clubs?

Pick #7 for White and #23 get fugged!!!

Hondo · Post by **Hondo** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:20 pm

Groover,

I think Port would value their 7th round pick much higher than pick 23 + White

Crows would be big winners in that deal.

I think it would end up being the same issue that is stalling the Tippett deal. Pick 23 (ends up pick 27 or so?) + White just doesn't seem enough for either Tippett or pick 7. Instead of the Crows being screwed it would be Port.

Groover · Post by **Groover** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:22 pm

Fair call guys, was just trying to find a somewhat valid solution to this never ending drama...

Booney · Post by **Booney** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:22 pm

Hondo wrote:Groover,

I think Port would value their 7th round pick much higher than pick 23 + White

Crows would be big winners in that deal.

I think it would end up being the same issue that is stalling the Tippett deal. Pick 23 (ends up pick 27 or so?) + White just doesn't seem enough for either Tippett or pick 7. Instead of the Crows being screwed it would be Port.

We've got Renouf, Redden and Lobbe on the list. We dont need another second ruckman, we have 3 of them.

overloaded · Post by **overloaded** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:25 pm

Groover wrote:If Jesse White wants to come to SA why dont Port come to the party in the Tippett deal?
The Power could trade pick #7 to the crows
The Crows could trade Tippett to the Swans
and the Swans could trade White and pick #23 to the Power

doesn't this seem like a fair solution for all clubs?

Funniest post ever

Psyber · Post by **Psyber** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:30 pm

Hondo wrote:Groover,

I think Port would value their 7th round pick much higher than pick 23 + White

Crows would be big winners in that deal.

I think it would end up being the same issue that is stalling the Tippett deal. Pick 23 (ends up pick 27 or so?) + White just doesn't seem enough for either Tippett or pick 7. Instead of the Crows being screwed it would be Port.

It looks like a brilliant idea and a good solution to me as a Crows supporter!

MW · Post by MW » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:44 pm

Latest I have heard is:

Jesse White and Bryce Gibbs to Crows
Pick 23 (Sydney) and McKernan to Carlton
Tippett to Sydney

scoob · Post by **scoob** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:46 pm

Latest I have heard is:

Gary Ablett Junior to Crows
Jesse White and Richard Tambling to Gold Coast
Tippett to Sydney

MW · Post by MW » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:48 pm

scoob wrote:Latest I have heard is:

Gary Ablett Junior to Crows
Jesse White and Richard Tambling to Gold Coast
Tippett to Sydney

At least mine is realistic!

scoob · Post by **scoob** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:55 pm

MW wrote:
scoob wrote:Latest I have heard is:

Gary Ablett Junior to Crows
Jesse White and Richard Tambling to Gold Coast
Tippett to Sydney

At least mine is realistic!

we are talking about 4 superstars of the game here

MW · Post by MW » Mon Oct 22, 2012 12:55 pm

Post by **GWW** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 1:34 pm

MW wrote:Latest I have heard is:

Jesse White and Bryce Gibbs to Crows
Pick 23 (Sydney) and McKernan to Carlton
Tippett to Sydney

Looks almost reasonable, but I doubt the Crows would want to give up McKernan in the year that they lose Tippett.

Rik E Boy · Post by **Rik E Boy** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 1:54 pm

GWW wrote:
MW wrote:Latest I have heard is:

Jesse White and Bryce Gibbs to Crows
Pick 23 (Sydney) and McKernan to Carlton
Tippett to Sydney

Looks almost reasonable, but I doubt the Crows would want to give up McKernan in the year that they lose Tippett.

Maybe they would if they didn't have to take Gibbs.

regards,

REB

Perfect Drug · Post by **Perfect Drug** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 2:09 pm

MW wrote:Latest I have heard is:

Jesse White and Bryce Gibbs to Crows
Pick 23 (Sydney) and McKernan to Carlton
Tippett to Sydney

Carlton give up Gibbs for pick 23 and McKernan? Surely not.

I do remember an interview with Malthouse where he said he would not give Gibbs for Tippett. Although Tippet is overrated, I doubt pick 23 and McKernan has him covered?

Groover · Post by **Groover** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 2:10 pm

Ok after some evaluation I have come up with the following 6 club trade:
Adelaide trade Tippett to Sydney, Tambling and pick 20 to GC
Sydney trade White and pick #23 to Port
Port trades Pick #7 to Crows
GC trade T.Hickey and pick #26 to St Kilda
St Kilda trade Pick #13 and #25 to Port, J.Cripps and pick #37 to WC
WC trade M.Brown and pick #41 to GC

End result:
Adelaide gets Pick #7
Sydney gets Tippett
Port gets White and picks #13,#23 and #25
GC gets Tambling and Picks #20 and #41
St.Kilda gets M.Brown, T.Hickey and pick #26
WC gets Cripps and pick #37

wont happen but thats the best I have come up with so far.

Edit, minor adjustment, pick #41 from WC to GC instead of Stk

scoob · Post by **scoob** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 2:14 pm

Groover wrote:Ok after some evaluation I have come up with the following 6 club trade:
Adelaide trade Tippett to Sydney, Tambling and pick 20 to GC
Sydney trade White and pick #23 to Port
Port trades Pick #7 to Crows
GC trade T.Hickey and pick #26 to St Kilda
St Kilda trade Pick #13 and #25 to Port, J.Cripps and pick #37 to WC
WC trade M.Brown and pick #41 to St.kilda

End result:
Adelaide gets Pick #7
Sydney gets Tippett
Port gets White and picks #13,#23 and #25
GC gets Tambling and Pick #20
St.Kilda gets M.Brown, T.Hickey and picks #26 and #41
WC gets Cripps and pick #37

wont happen but thats the best I have come up with so far.

Good Work... That will be a simple one to push through. :lol:

Crows will not get pick 7 for Yippett IMHO!

Pup · Post by **Pup** » Mon Oct 22, 2012 2:19 pm

Groover wrote:Ok after some evaluation I have come up with the following 6 club trade:
Adelaide trade Tippett to Sydney, Tambling and pick 20 to GC
Sydney trade White and pick #23 to Port
Port trades Pick #7 to Crows
GC trade T.Hickey and pick #26 to St Kilda
St Kilda trade Pick #13 and #25 to Port, J.Cripps and pick #37 to WC
WC trade M.Brown and pick #41 to GC

End result:
Adelaide gets Pick #7
Sydney gets Tippett
Port gets White and picks #13,#23 and #25
GC gets Tambling and Picks #20 and #41
St.Kilda gets M.Brown, T.Hickey and pick #26
WC gets Cripps and pick #37

wont happen but thats the best I have come up with so far.

So Port lose pick 7 yet gain 13,23,25 and White?

WCE won't be trading Brown for that either. Not interested in Cripps being involved in the Brown trade apparently

Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Re: Kurt Tippett's playing future?

Who is online