SA FOOTY MEDIA GUIDE - CORRECTIONS FOR 2009 EDITION

[spell_check]

I have 234 meetings between Port and South, but Port has 186 wins and South 46 with two draws. Looking at the 1994 year book I have, my win loss records match those figures.

[spell_check]

Error in the CD v Glenelg head to head tally

should be;

P CD G D
107 55 52 -

I've got the same, too.

[JamesH]

Now that its clear that there are a lot diferences in head to head totals..... Eagles v Sturt thread shows a difference in win-loss totals

I think we need a re-count... just not as easy as it sounds

[spell_check]

Now that its clear that there are a lot diferences in head to head totals..... Eagles v Sturt thread shows a difference in win-loss totals

I think we need a re-count... just not as easy as it sounds

I'll go through my Excel file at some stage in the next few days and do the re-count.

[JamesH]

It may be a good a idea to compare what is on the spreadsheet to each club v club total in the media guide. I suspect a few differences.

What makes any differences in the media guide tough to pick up is the fact all the venue head to head info adds up;

below is my head to head total prior to the season starts. My count is based on the 2006 media guide. I would be shockked If I have a few errors[size=150][size=150][size=150][size=150][size=150][/size][/size][/size][/size][/size]

CENTRAL DISTRICT V GLENELG

P CD G D
107 55 52 -

Finals
3 - 3 -

Venues
AO 2 6 -
Elz 24 13 -
FP 8 12 -
Glg 21 21 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V NORTH ADELAIDE

P CD NA D
117 66 49 2
Finals
4 4 - -

Venues
AO 6 5 -
Elz 31 13 -
FP 7 9 -
Nur 1 - -
Psp 20 21 2
PtP 1 1 -



CENTRAL DISTRICT V NORWOOD

P CD N D
112 52 60 -
Finals
8 3 5 -

Venues
AO 4 1 -
Elz 25 16 -
FP 7 19 -
Nor 16 24 -



CENTRAL DISTRICT V PORT ADELAIDE
P CD PAM D
123 41 81 1
Finals
14 3 11 -

Venues
Alb 11 29 -
AO 4 7 -
Elz 20 23 1
FP 6 21 -
Why - 1 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P CD SA D
104 58 45 1
Finals
1 - 1 -

Venues
AO 17 20 -
Elz 28 12 -
FP 6 7 1
Noa 8 5 -
Ric - 1 -


CENTRAL DISTRICT V STURT
P CD St D
102 53 49 -
Finals
19 10 9 -

Venues
AO 8 6 -
Cla 1 - -
Elz 25 16 -
FL 10 9 -
Unl 9 18 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V WEST ADELAIDE
P CD WA D
108 61 46 1
Finals
2 2 - -

Venues
AO 2 4 -
Ber 1 - -
Elz 25 16 -
FP 11 6 -
Ric 22 20 1




CENTRAL DISTRICT V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P CD WWT D
53 29 24 -
Finals
9 8 1 -

Venues
AO 3 4 -
Elz 8 9 -
FP 9 5 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 9 5 -




GELENLG V NORTH ADELAIDE
P G NA D
209 89 118 2
Finals
10 7 3 -

Venues
AO 6 14 -
FP 15 7 -
Glg 35 43 -
Ken 3 4 -
Psp 30 60 2


GLENELG V NORWOOD
P G N D
229 90 138 1
Finals
18 7 11 -

Venues
AO 9 7 -
FP 24 15 -
Glg 36 50 -
Ken - 4 -
Mta 1 - -
Nor 20 61 1
Way - 1 -




GLENELG V PORT ADELAIDE
P G PAM D
229 57 169 3
Finals
23 8 15

Venues
Alb 16 65 1
AO 5 18 -
Elz - 1 -
FP 12 29 1
Glg 24 56 1
Ken - 1 -


GLENELG V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P G SA D
200 110 89 1
Finals
1 1 - -

Venues
AO 33 42 -
FP 10 5 -
Glg 54 33 1
Ken 5 - -
Noa 7 8 -
Pen - 1 -



GLENELG V STURT
P G St D
230 96 133 1
Finals
15 8 7 -

Venues
AO 18 26 -
FP 18 11 -
Glg 39 43 1
Ken - 1 -
Unl 21 51 -
Way - 1 -


GELENLG V WEST ADELAIDE
P G WA D
205 95 108 2
Finals
3 3 - -

Venues
AO 11 27 -
FP 14 5 -
Glg 41 43 1
Ken 1 2 -
Lam 1 - -
Ric 22 23 1
Way 5 8 -



GLENELG V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P G WWT D
47 13 32 2
Finals
3 1 2 -

Venues
AO 1 2 -
FP 2 5 -
Glg 8 10 -
Thb - 1 -
Wdv 2 13 2
Why - 1 -



NORTH ADELAIDE V NORWOOD
P NA N D
245 106 133 6
Finals
16 11 4 -

Venues
AO 24 17 1
FP 7 11 1
Jub 1 - -
Ken 1 1 -
Nor 36 62 3
Psp 36 42 1
SCG 1 - -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
28 2 26 -
District (1897-1906)
26 11 14 1



NORTH ADELAIDE V PORT ADELAIDE
P NA PAM D
246 80 166 -
Finals
23 9 14 -

Venues
Alb 28 62 -
AO 20 32 -
FP 5 14 -
Ken 2 4 -
Psp 25 53 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
25 3 21 1
District (1897-1906)
25 8 17 0


NORTH ADELAIDE V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P NA SA D
238 163 72 3
Finals
6 6 - -

Venues
Psp 64 23 1
AO 73 34 -
Nor 1 - -
Noa 6 6 2
Ken 3 2 -
Jub 5 1 -
FP 11 6 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
28 2 26 -
District (1897-1906)
26 11 14 1





NORTH ADELAIDE V STURT
P NA St D
235 110 120 5
Finals
16 6 9 1

Venues
AO 26 27 -
FP 4 10 -
Ken 1 - -
Nar 1 - -
Psp 62 30 -
Unl 26 52 3

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
13 12 1 -


NORTH ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P NA WA D
240 136 103 1
Finals
13 8 5 -

Venues
AO 28 34 -
FP 12 4 -
Jub - 8 1
Ken 1 - -
Psp 59 24 -
Ric 23 28 -
Way 9 4 -
Ber 1 - -

Other Eras
District (1897-1906)
28 23 5 -



NORTH ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P NA WWT D
51 16 35 -
Finals
6 3 3 -

Venues
AO 3 3 -
Cla - 1 -
FP 3 7 -
Psp 8 10 -
Thb - 1 -
Wdv 2 13 -



NORWOOD V PORT ADELAIDE
P N PAM D
276 114 158 4
Finals
43 23 19 1

Venues
Alb 18 63 2
AO 24 23 1
FP 23 26 -
Ken - 7 -
Nor 49 38 1
PtP - 1 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1878-1896)
74 45 19 10
District (1897-1906)
32 15 15 2



NORWOOD V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P N SA D
233 163 69 1
Finals
11 5 6 -

Venues
AO 63 32 -
Bic - 1 -
FP 14 7 -
Ken 5 - -
Noa 8 7 -
Nor 76 22 1

Other Eras
SAFA (1878-1896)
74 36 27 11
District (1897-1906)
31 15 16 -



NORWOOD V STURT
P N St D
251 139 109 3
Finals
21 9 12 -

Venues
AO 20 20 -
FP 17 11 -
Ken 3 3 -
MB 1 - -
Nor 63 36 3
Unl 36 41 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
14 12 2 -






NORWOOD V WEST ADELAIDE
P N WA D
242 144 96 2
Finals
19 9 10 -

Venues
AO 35 23 -
FP 12 4 -
Jub - 2 -
Ken 6 3 -
Nor 60 38 -
Ric 21 23 2
Way 10 3 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
4 4 - -
District (1897-1906)
22 21 1 -




NORWOOD V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P N WWT D
46 18 28 -
Finals
4 3 1 -

Venues
AO 1 2 -
FP 5 5 -
MtP - 1 -
Nor 6 11 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 5 9 -





PORT ADELAIDE V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P PAM SA D
235 185 48 2
Finals
13 8 5 -

Venues
Alb 89 10 1
Noa 10 6 -
FP 13 2 -
AO 72 30 1
PtL 1 - -

Other Eras
SAFA (1877-1896)
72 26 35 11
District (1897-1906)
33 19 13 1




PORT ADELAIDE V STURT
P PAM St D
259 169 88 2
Finals
26 12 14 -

Venues
Alb 68 18 -
Unl 39 36 -
FP 20 8 2
AO 31 26 -
Ken 6 - -
PtL 1 - -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
12 11 1 -





PORT ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P PAM WA D
246 157 87 2
Finals
24 12 12 -

Venues
Alb 75 19 1
AO 33 39 -
FP 13 4 -
Jub - 1 -
Ken 3 1 -
Ric 29 16 -
Thb 1 - -
Way 4 7 1

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
2 2 - -
District (1897-1906)
23 22 1 -




PORT ADAELIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P PAM WWT D
52 30 22 -
Finals
9 4 5 -

Venues
Alb 12 8 -
AO 1 2 -
FP 9 5 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 7 7 -





SOUTH ADELAIDE V STURT
P SA St D
233 88 144 1
Finals
6 3 3 -

Venues
AO 47 60 1
Bic 1 - -
EB - 1 -
FP 9 6 -
Jub 2 2 -
Ken 1 3 -
Noa 6 7 -
PtA 1 - -
Ric 1 - -
Str 1 - -
Unl 18 66 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
12 7 3 2




SOUTH ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P SA WA D
226 92 132 2
Finals
2 - 2 -
Venues
AO 56 62 1
EB 1 - -
FP 4 11 -
Jub 3 6 -
Ken - 4 -
MB - 1 -
Noa 3 8 1
Nor - 1 -
Ric 17 30 -
Unl 1 - -
Wai - 1 -
Way 7 8 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
1 1 - -
District (1897-1906)
24 20 3 1







SOUTH ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P SA WWT D
44 10 34 -
Finals
- - - -

Venues
AO 2 5 -
EB - 1 -
FP - 6 -
Noa 3 9 -
Nor 1 - -
Wdv 4 14 -





STURT V WEST ADELAIDE
P St WA D
230 121 108 1
Finals
9 2 7 -

Venues
Unl 51 36 -
Ric 25 23 -
FP 11 6 -
AO 23 34 1
Way 9 4 -
Ken 2 2 -
Jub - 1 -
Lox - 1 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
13 8 5 -






STURT V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P St WWT D
45 9 36 -
Finals
4 - 4 -

Venues
AO 4 9 -
FP - 7 -
Unl 4 6 -
Wdv 1 14 -






WEST ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P WA WWT D
47 18 29 -
Finals
4 2 2 -

Venues
AO 3 1 -
FP 3 5 -
Ric 8 11 -
Thb - 2 -
Wdv 4 10 -

[JamesH]

CENTRAL DISTRICT V GLENELG

P CD G D
107 55 52 -

Finals
3 - 3 -

Venues
AO 2 6 -
Elz 24 13 -
FP 8 12 -
Glg 21 21 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V NORTH ADELAIDE

P CD NA D
117 66 49 2
Finals
4 4 - -

Venues
AO 6 5 -
Elz 31 13 -
FP 7 9 -
Nur 1 - -
Psp 20 21 2
PtP 1 1 -



CENTRAL DISTRICT V NORWOOD

P CD N D
112 52 60 -
Finals
8 3 5 -

Venues
AO 4 1 -
Elz 25 16 -
FP 7 19 -
Nor 16 24 -



CENTRAL DISTRICT V PORT ADELAIDE
P CD PAM D
123 41 81 1
Finals
14 3 11 -

Venues
Alb 11 29 -
AO 4 7 -
Elz 20 23 1
FP 6 21 -
Why - 1 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P CD SA D
104 58 45 1
Finals
1 - 1 -

Venues
AO 17 20 -
Elz 28 12 -
FP 6 7 1
Noa 8 5 -
Ric - 1 -


CENTRAL DISTRICT V STURT
P CD St D
102 53 49 -
Finals
19 10 9 -

Venues
AO 8 6 -
Cla 1 - -
Elz 25 16 -
FL 10 9 -
Unl 9 18 -




CENTRAL DISTRICT V WEST ADELAIDE
P CD WA D
108 61 46 1
Finals
2 2 - -

Venues
AO 2 4 -
Ber 1 - -
Elz 25 16 -
FP 11 6 -
Ric 22 20 1




CENTRAL DISTRICT V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P CD WWT D
53 29 24 -
Finals
9 8 1 -

Venues
AO 3 4 -
Elz 8 9 -
FP 9 5 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 9 5 -




GELENLG V NORTH ADELAIDE
P G NA D
209 89 118 2
Finals
10 7 3 -

Venues
AO 6 14 -
FP 15 7 -
Glg 35 43 -
Ken 3 4 -
Psp 30 60 2


GLENELG V NORWOOD
P G N D
229 90 138 1
Finals
18 7 11 -

Venues
AO 9 7 -
FP 24 15 -
Glg 36 50 -
Ken - 4 -
Mta 1 - -
Nor 20 61 1
Way - 1 -




GLENELG V PORT ADELAIDE
P G PAM D
229 57 169 3
Finals
23 8 15

Venues
Alb 16 65 1
AO 5 18 -
Elz - 1 -
FP 12 29 1
Glg 24 56 1
Ken - 1 -


GLENELG V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P G SA D
200 110 89 1
Finals
1 1 - -

Venues
AO 33 42 -
FP 10 5 -
Glg 54 33 1
Ken 5 - -
Noa 7 8 -
Pen - 1 -



GLENELG V STURT
P G St D
230 96 133 1
Finals
15 8 7 -

Venues
AO 18 26 -
FP 18 11 -
Glg 39 43 1
Ken - 1 -
Unl 21 51 -
Way - 1 -


GELENLG V WEST ADELAIDE
P G WA D
205 95 108 2
Finals
3 3 - -

Venues
AO 11 27 -
FP 14 5 -
Glg 41 43 1
Ken 1 2 -
Lam 1 - -
Ric 22 23 1
Way 5 8 -



GLENELG V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P G WWT D
47 13 32 2
Finals
3 1 2 -

Venues
AO 1 2 -
FP 2 5 -
Glg 8 10 -
Thb - 1 -
Wdv 2 13 2
Why - 1 -



NORTH ADELAIDE V NORWOOD
P NA N D
245 106 133 6
Finals
16 11 4 -

Venues
AO 24 17 1
FP 7 11 1
Jub 1 - -
Ken 1 1 -
Nor 36 62 3
Psp 36 42 1
SCG 1 - -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
28 2 26 -
District (1897-1906)
26 11 14 1



NORTH ADELAIDE V PORT ADELAIDE
P NA PAM D
246 80 166 -
Finals
23 9 14 -

Venues
Alb 28 62 -
AO 20 32 -
FP 5 14 -
Ken 2 4 -
Psp 25 53 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
25 3 21 1
District (1897-1906)
25 8 17 0


NORTH ADELAIDE V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P NA SA D
238 163 72 3
Finals
6 6 - -

Venues
Psp 64 23 1
AO 73 34 -
Nor 1 - -
Noa 6 6 2
Ken 3 2 -
Jub 5 1 -
FP 11 6 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1883-1896)
28 2 26 -
District (1897-1906)
26 11 14 1





NORTH ADELAIDE V STURT
P NA St D
235 110 120 5
Finals
16 6 9 1

Venues
AO 26 27 -
FP 4 10 -
Ken 1 - -
Nar 1 - -
Psp 62 30 -
Unl 26 52 3

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
13 12 1 -


NORTH ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P NA WA D
240 136 103 1
Finals
13 8 5 -

Venues
AO 28 34 -
FP 12 4 -
Jub - 8 1
Ken 1 - -
Psp 59 24 -
Ric 23 28 -
Way 9 4 -
Ber 1 - -

Other Eras
District (1897-1906)
28 23 5 -



NORTH ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P NA WWT D
51 16 35 -
Finals
6 3 3 -

Venues
AO 3 3 -
Cla - 1 -
FP 3 7 -
Psp 8 10 -
Thb - 1 -
Wdv 2 13 -



NORWOOD V PORT ADELAIDE
P N PAM D
276 114 158 4
Finals
43 23 19 1

Venues
Alb 18 63 2
AO 24 23 1
FP 23 26 -
Ken - 7 -
Nor 49 38 1
PtP - 1 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1878-1896)
74 45 19 10
District (1897-1906)
32 15 15 2



NORWOOD V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P N SA D
233 163 69 1
Finals
11 5 6 -

Venues
AO 63 32 -
Bic - 1 -
FP 14 7 -
Ken 5 - -
Noa 8 7 -
Nor 76 22 1

Other Eras
SAFA (1878-1896)
74 36 27 11
District (1897-1906)
31 15 16 -



NORWOOD V STURT
P N St D
251 139 109 3
Finals
21 9 12 -

Venues
AO 20 20 -
FP 17 11 -
Ken 3 3 -
MB 1 - -
Nor 63 36 3
Unl 36 41 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
14 12 2 -






NORWOOD V WEST ADELAIDE
P N WA D
242 144 96 2
Finals
19 9 10 -

Venues
AO 35 23 -
FP 12 4 -
Jub - 2 -
Ken 6 3 -
Nor 60 38 -
Ric 21 23 2
Way 10 3 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
4 4 - -
District (1897-1906)
22 21 1 -




NORWOOD V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P N WWT D
46 18 28 -
Finals
4 3 1 -

Venues
AO 1 2 -
FP 5 5 -
MtP - 1 -
Nor 6 11 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 5 9 -





PORT ADELAIDE V SOUTH ADELAIDE
P PAM SA D
235 185 48 2
Finals
13 8 5 -

Venues
Alb 89 10 1
Noa 10 6 -
FP 13 2 -
AO 72 30 1
PtL 1 - -

Other Eras
SAFA (1877-1896)
72 26 35 11
District (1897-1906)
33 19 13 1




PORT ADELAIDE V STURT
P PAM St D
259 169 88 2
Finals
26 12 14 -

Venues
Alb 68 18 -
Unl 39 36 -
FP 20 8 2
AO 31 26 -
Ken 6 - -
PtL 1 - -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
12 11 1 -





PORT ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P PAM WA D
246 157 87 2
Finals
24 12 12 -

Venues
Alb 75 19 1
AO 33 39 -
FP 13 4 -
Jub - 1 -
Ken 3 1 -
Ric 29 16 -
Thb 1 - -
Way 4 7 1

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
2 2 - -
District (1897-1906)
23 22 1 -




PORT ADAELIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P PAM WWT D
52 30 22 -
Finals
9 4 5 -

Venues
Alb 12 8 -
AO 1 2 -
FP 9 5 -
Thb 1 - -
Wdv 7 7 -





SOUTH ADELAIDE V STURT
P SA St D
233 88 144 1
Finals
6 3 3 -

Venues
AO 47 60 1
Bic 1 - -
EB - 1 -
FP 9 6 -
Jub 2 2 -
Ken 1 3 -
Noa 6 7 -
PtA 1 - -
Ric 1 - -
Str 1 - -
Unl 18 66 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
12 7 3 2




SOUTH ADELAIDE V WEST ADELAIDE
P SA WA D
226 92 132 2
Finals
2 - 2 -
Venues
AO 56 62 1
EB 1 - -
FP 4 11 -
Jub 3 6 -
Ken - 4 -
MB - 1 -
Noa 3 8 1
Nor - 1 -
Ric 17 30 -
Unl 1 - -
Wai - 1 -
Way 7 8 -

Other Eras
SAFA (1887)
1 1 - -
District (1897-1906)
24 20 3 1







SOUTH ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P SA WWT D
44 10 34 -
Finals
- - - -

Venues
AO 2 5 -
EB - 1 -
FP - 6 -
Noa 3 9 -
Nor 1 - -
Wdv 4 14 -





STURT V WEST ADELAIDE
P St WA D
230 121 108 1
Finals
9 2 7 -

Venues
Unl 51 36 -
Ric 25 23 -
FP 11 6 -
AO 23 34 1
Way 9 4 -
Ken 2 2 -
Jub - 1 -
Lox - 1 -

Other Eras
District (1901-1906)
13 8 5 -






STURT V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
spellchack indicated head to head may be different
P St WWT D
45 9 36 -
Finals
4 - 4 -

Venues
AO 4 9 -
FP - 7 -
Unl 4 6 -
Wdv 1 14 -






WEST ADELAIDE V WOODVILLE-WEST TORRENS
P WA WWT D
47 18 29 -
Finals
4 2 2 -

Venues
AO 3 1 -
FP 3 5 -
Ric 8 11 -
Thb - 2 -
Wdv 4 10 -[/quote]

I have placed in bold the head to head records where there may be an eror in the media guide. As previously stated my counts are based on the 2006 media guide, withe the subsequent results added on

[Pseudo]

Scanning through last years' results in the "every result since forever" section, I thought I saw the final game in 2007 between North and Glenelg was listed as being at the Bay. In reality it was at Prospect.

[spell_check]

Scanning through last years' results in the "every result since forever" section, I thought I saw the final game in 2007 between North and Glenelg was listed as being at the Bay. In reality it was at Prospect.

Which means it's wrong in my Excel file, too. Thank you for spotting that.

[sapaul]

Does anyone else have The Complete Book of SANFL Records by Dion Hayman published in 1989? Pretty sure, not one mistake in that book, would have thought (if allowed) to gather everything from that book and then just add/update everything etc from 1990-2007.

EDIT: In that particular book, there is even something in the editorial about them getting their facts right as if they print a mistake, the record isn't a record or something or other. I know Dion did have help with that book from the late, great Ern.

[Adelaide Hawk]

Does anyone else have The Complete Book of SANFL Records by Dion Hayman published in 1989? Pretty sure, not one mistake in that book, would have thought (if allowed) to gather everything from that book and then just add/update everything etc from 1990-2007.

EDIT: In that particular book, there is even something in the editorial about them getting their facts right as if they print a mistake, the record isn't a record or something or other. I know Dion did have help with that book from the late, great Ern.

Gerry from "At The Toss Of A Coin" still has copies of it. And sorry to inform you but there were mistakes in there, but very few I'm happy to say.

[Squawk]

Norwood vs Cental at Elizabeth, 2007.
We lost by 2 goals, not 26.
Hopefully another Nwd supporter will confirm this typo.



Also, a South friend does not recall Don Scott coaching them and is unaware that Jack Cahill was appointed coach in 2007 for the 08 season.

[spell_check]

Most number of goals at Coopers Stadium/Norwood should be 19.

[spell_check]

On page 141 it says that the 19th man was introduced, when in fact this was the 20th man.