Your Top 5 Most Over-Rated Players Going Around

[Spargo]

Rik E Boy, please keep your sensible, informed posts out of this thread - they are clearly out of place.
Cheers.

[David Brent]

A Carlile by far most over rated in player in the comp.
Drew Petrie
Scotty McMahon
Farren Ray
Lastly our boy Ty Vickery- for F^*K sake start doing something Tyrone

[JK]

I was going to suggest Tyrone, but I didn't think anyone rated him

[valleys07]

A Carlile by far most over rated in player in the comp.
Drew Petrie
Scotty McMahon
Farren Ray
Lastly our boy Ty Vickery- for F^*K sake start doing something Tyrone

Bobby Carlisle? Rated? Are you serious??



Nothing more than a role player. Now stop....my chest hurts.

[Dogwatcher]

I think this thread proves that some people over-rate the rating of certain players.

[bennymacca]

oh great, another whinge thread from the grumpy old C*nts at SAFooty

please lets make the underrated thread longer than this one.

[woodublieve12]

Probably cop some flack but IMO Travis cloke is overrated

[RustyCage]

Probably cop some flack but IMO Travis cloke is overrated

Yep. Junk time goals when the opposition has long since stopped trying

[LaughingKookaburra]

Adam Schneider....

[Q.]

Ben Reid.... Sasquatches have been sighted more frequently than this bloke.

[cokadonkeytoo]

Angus 'Matthew Mitcham' Monfries.

Overrated footballer, underrated platform diver

[woodublieve12]

Ryder...

[Spargo]

Ben Reid.... Sasquatches have been sighted more frequently than this bloke.

One might say he was "Born to break your heart", Q......

[holden78]

Ryder and Mackie

[Jim05]

Ben Reid.... Sasquatches have been sighted more frequently than this bloke.

His brother aint much better

[RoosterMan]

One does not win two Brownlow Medals and two premierships if they are overrated.

Considering only 13 players in the history of the VFL/AFL have achieved the feat, it puts him up there with the all time greats of the game.

[woodublieve12]

One does not win two Brownlow Medals and two premierships if they are overrated.

Considering only 13 players in the history of the VFL/AFL have achieved the feat, it puts him up there with the all time greats of the game.

i am assuming you are talking about goodes...

probably one of the most versatile players in the history of the game. even his recent form has been very good...

[RoosterMan]

One does not win two Brownlow Medals and two premierships if they are overrated.

Considering only 13 players in the history of the VFL/AFL have achieved the feat, it puts him up there with the all time greats of the game.

i am assuming you are talking about goodes...

probably one of the most versatile players in the history of the game. even his recent form has been very good...

I was yes WB.

I was responding to a post that suggested he is overrated.

A bloke like Gary Ablett Snr never won a Brownlow or a premiership yet he is considered one of the greatest ever to play the game yet someone who has two Brownlows and two premierships is considered "overrated". Go figure.

[Spargo]

Carey, Matthews, Ablett Snr never won Brownlows and they're clearly the best 3 our games ever seen.
Wynd, Liberatore & Woewodin however, all won one.

[woodublieve12]

Carey, Matthews, Ablett Snr never won Brownlows and they're clearly the best 3 our games ever seen.
Wynd, Liberatore & Woewodin however, all won one.

Lockett better than carey imo...