Supercoach

[Hondo]

Upgrading Petrenko. Andrew Mackie or Graham Johncock thoughts?

Going to go Mackie i think.

I went Mackie with my Petrenko upgrade. BUT a tip I got from another site to consider is MacDonald from Brisbane. Started at $505K now $390K due to 3 average scores in a row.

I don't know enough about him and didn't like his recent scores so didn't go there. But I noticed he scored 135 round 1 and seems to be capable of higher scores than Mackie, whereas Mackie seems to score lower but be more consistent. Geelong = win most of time = lots of SC points for their players was my theory in the end!

The other one in the price range I looked at was McPhee of Essendon.

[Bum Crack]

Upgrading Petrenko. Andrew Mackie or Graham Johncock thoughts?

Going to go Mackie i think.

I went Mackie with my Petrenko upgrade. BUT a tip I got from another site to consider is MacDonald from Brisbane. Started at $505K now $390K due to 3 average scores in a row.

I don't know enough about him and didn't like his recent scores so didn't go there. But I noticed he scored 135 round 1 and seems to be capable of higher scores than Mackie, whereas Mackie seems to score lower but be more consistent. Geelong = win most of time = lots of SC points for their players was my theory in the end!

The other one in the price range I looked at was McPhee of Essendon.

I had McDonald last year and he was one of my guns. He has been quite ordinary this year (except for round 1). Josh Drummond has been playing the role McDonald played last year, so he isn't getting the free reign he had last year, which is restricting him from getting those easy possessions. One to look at in a couple of weeks when he gets back, is Des Headland. He's not worth much at all and will get possessions for sure.

[Rik E Boy]

Need to have one of Hill or Rance on the ground this week? Which one, both have been up and down as you would expect from Rookies. Richmond play Sydney while Freo play WCE in the Derby.

Bit of a roll of the dice. I think Hill is getting better, had a good game last week and could be buoyed by the Derby, which is why I selected him on the field ahead of Petrenko (who probably won't have as much game time as Hill).

I say go Rance. The Derbies are full on and Hill is built like a stick insect.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

In: L. Davis, S. Mumford Out: B. Harvey, D. Hille

B: J Drummond, N Bock, J. McMahon
HB: T. Lockyer, A. McPhee, N. Lovett-Murray
C: N. Jones, J. Adcock, B. Reilly
HF: L. Davis, R. Murphy, N. Krakouer
F: A. Davey, L. Franklin, S. Dew
1R: J. Meesen, L. Montagna (C), L. Hodge

Int: R. Petterd, M. Coughlan, S. Mumford, T. Walker

EMG: L. Greenwood, D. Zaharakis, J. White

Problems:
NO ABLETT, IN FACT NO CATS EXCEPT FOR OUR NUMBER THREE RUCKMAN.

Shame on you Clifford.

regards,

REB

[Rik E Boy]

Upgrading Petrenko. Andrew Mackie or Graham Johncock thoughts?

Going to go Mackie i think.

I went Mackie with my Petrenko upgrade. BUT a tip I got from another site to consider is MacDonald from Brisbane. Started at $505K now $390K due to 3 average scores in a row.

I don't know enough about him and didn't like his recent scores so didn't go there. But I noticed he scored 135 round 1 and seems to be capable of higher scores than Mackie, whereas Mackie seems to score lower but be more consistent. Geelong = win most of time = lots of SC points for their players was my theory in the end!

The other one in the price range I looked at was McPhee of Essendon.

I had McDonald last year and he was one of my guns. He has been quite ordinary this year (except for round 1). Josh Drummond has been playing the role McDonald played last year, so he isn't getting the free reign he had last year, which is restricting him from getting those easy possessions. One to look at in a couple of weeks when he gets back, is Des Headland. He's not worth much at all and will get possessions for sure.

I'd be staying away from McDonald that's for sure. Like you said Drummond has taken that role and that's why his price is dropping. You'd be better off with Ryder IMO.

regards,

REB

[silicone skyline]

In: L. Davis, S. Mumford Out: B. Harvey, D. Hille

B: J Drummond, N Bock, J. McMahon
HB: T. Lockyer, A. McPhee, N. Lovett-Murray
C: N. Jones, J. Adcock, B. Reilly
HF: L. Davis, R. Murphy, N. Krakouer
F: A. Davey, L. Franklin, S. Dew
1R: J. Meesen, L. Montagna (C), L. Hodge

Int: R. Petterd, M. Coughlan, S. Mumford, T. Walker

EMG: L. Greenwood, D. Zaharakis, J. White

Problems:
NO ABLETT, IN FACT NO CATS EXCEPT FOR OUR NUMBER THREE RUCKMAN.

Shame on you Clifford.

regards,

REB

Poor Mumford. He is shit though.

[Q.]

SS, that is the worst ruck combo I've seen from anyone's teams, you poor bastard

[silicone skyline]

Hille out injured and I was going to make some money on Paul Johnson with a low break even at the start of the year.

But he couldn't do it. I've lost money on Johnson, Hille out for the season, picked up Meesen as an EMG, as well as Jesse White.

My four rucks are Meesen, Mumford, White and Johnson. It sucks balls.

Meesen and Mumford, according to average, are my best two ruckmen.

[Rik E Boy]

Poor Mumford. He is s***t though.

Maybe as a SC player but not as a footballer though. He's ahead of West and developing all the time.

regards,

REB

[Brock Landers]

Is anyone else having trouble opening the supercoach site?

[silicone skyline]

You and the 50,000 others trying to get on it.

[silicone skyline]

I got on straight away

[Brock Landers]

I can get on but I can't edit my team due to errors on the page. It's p!$$ing me off

[Pup]

Need to have one of Hill or Rance on the ground this week? Which one, both have been up and down as you would expect from Rookies. Richmond play Sydney while Freo play WCE in the Derby.

Bit of a roll of the dice. I think Hill is getting better, had a good game last week and could be buoyed by the Derby, which is why I selected him on the field ahead of Petrenko (who probably won't have as much game time as Hill).

I say go Rance. The Derbies are full on and Hill is built like a stick insect.

regards,

REB

138 for Hill.

Thank you REB.!!!

[Rik E Boy]

LMAO. Anytime Pup, anytime. Rance will come out and get 40 today.

regards,

REB

[Pup]

Why would i listen to a bloke who i beat in the Grand Final last year

Dont worry i have learnt my lesson!

[Rik E Boy]

Fair go, Nostradamus couldn't have predicted that weedy Hill would rack up 138 points. Although I am reading that book again just in case he did......

regards,

REB

[Pup]

Haha i know mate.

I was just stirring.

[Bum Crack]

1547 pts with 9 players to go and still have Ablett as captain to come. Big score coming my way this week.

[Rik E Boy]

Glad I'm not playing you cracker. However some of my advice would soon bring that score down.

regards,

REB