SA Footy

amber_fluid wrote:Unless our batters can improve dramatically it won’t matter what bowlers we pick.
Play Head as an extra batter and bowl him instead of bringing in another spinner.
Renshaw to make way for Head.
IF Green is fully fit he comes in for Handscomb.
Starc in for Boland too.
Davey gets one more chance

I agree but won’t happen

Brodlach wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Brodlach wrote:If Green plays he opens the bowling allowing the 3 spinners

So you're saying Green and Kuhners for Renshaw and Boland?

Yep

Has merit.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Booney wrote:Peter Lalor
@plalor

STAND BY.

There is a big chance Kuhnemann will make his Test debut today.

Looked like he was ready to play this morning.

This is the dumb shit that keeps us where we are, f*** the shock selections off and concentrate on winning each match then series as they come.

Pick our best XI available and let them work their craft.

Maybe they really want that point of difference you mentioned above? When it was announced that Kuhnemann was traveling over there I thought he could be a very good chance to play because like Murphy the Indians haven't really seen and faced him before like they've seen both Agar and Swepson various times in various formats and perhaps that's why he might get a game ahead of Agar.

As for Starc, he didn't sound like he was 100% confident that he was fit to play when asked about his finger in a press conference on Wednesday.

The Dark Knight wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

Booney wrote:Peter Lalor
@plalor

STAND BY.

There is a big chance Kuhnemann will make his Test debut today.

Looked like he was ready to play this morning.

This is the dumb shit that keeps us where we are, f*** the shock selections off and concentrate on winning each match then series as they come.

Pick our best XI available and let them work their craft.

Maybe they really want that point of difference you mentioned above? When it was announced that Kuhnemann was traveling over there I thought he could be a very good chance to play because like Murphy the Indians haven't really seen and faced him before like they've seen both Agar and Swepson various times in various formats and perhaps that's why he might get a game ahead of Agar.

As for Starc, he didn't sound like he was 100% confident that he was fit to play when asked about his finger in a press conference on Wednesday.

Green is the key, he plays then we can debut Kuhnemann, personally I'd love to squeeze him in but we have to make sure we're scoring more than 177 & 91.

If Kunhemann is playing we must be playing three spinners or Green is playing.

whufc wrote:If Kunhemann is playing we must be playing three spinners or Green is playing.

I think Brodlach is George Bailey. It's the only way we can.

Head won't be playing.

amber_fluid wrote:Unless our batters can improve dramatically it won’t matter what bowlers we pick.

Correct, our inability to make runs is a huge issue.

Load up on all the bats, and get through the overs with part timers.
We'd still lose, but might at least make it to lunch on day 4.

Warner
Khawaja
Lab - 5
Smith - 6
Renshaw
Handscomb
Green - 2
Head - 4
Carey
Boland - 1
Murphy - 3

Won't happen though.

Cummins will play despite clearly being outbowled by Boland last test.
Lyon will survive despite refusing to bowl differently in India than he does on the bouncy Aussie decks.
Head will be mixing cordial again.
And yeah, I recon they'll try and slip in the new bloke cause the indians haven't seen much of him.

Interestingly our 4 bowlers from last test all took 5 fa (or more) on debut. Just shows how much batsmen rely on video analysis and becoming comfortable with the bowlers they are facing. Anyone new and it takes a few tests before they work out how to face them.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

whufc wrote:If Kunhemann is playing we must be playing three spinners or Green is playing.

I think Brodlach is George Bailey. It's the only way we can.

Head won't be playing.

Spinners aren’t going to help improve our scores of 177 and 91 but Head might.
If Green can’t bowl then he doesn’t play IMO

Gerard Whateley has just said Head & Handscombe definitely playing from what he can gather by looking at the ground right now (warm ups).

Lyon and Murphy have painted their run up marks, no sign of Kuhnemann....but is in his whites having a photo taken.

No sign of Green either.

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Gerard Whateley has just said Head & Handscombe definitely playing from what he can gather by looking at the ground right now (warm ups).

So either Renshaw or Warner out
You’d assume Renshaw

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Gerard Whateley has just said Head & Handscombe definitely playing from what he can gather by looking at the ground right now (warm ups).

Whateley and Lalor are probably laughing at our forum right about now, probably thinking "look at these dumb gullible pricks"

I am gathering Renshaw and Boland out, Head and Kuhnemann in (from what I am hearing).

PatowalongaPirate wrote:I am gathering Renshaw and Boland out, Head and Kuhnemann in (from what I am hearing).

Doubt they go in with just one quick

So Cummins, Lyon, Murphy, Kuhnemann, Head, Labuschagne as the attack?

Jim05 wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:I am gathering Renshaw and Boland out, Head and Kuhnemann in (from what I am hearing).

Doubt they go in with just one quick

Yeah would be unlike us.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Gerard Whateley has just said Head & Handscombe definitely playing from what he can gather by looking at the ground right now (warm ups).

Whateley and Lalor are probably laughing at our forum right about now, probably thinking "look at these dumb gullible pricks"

Most people reading this forum would probably think that!

PatowalongaPirate wrote:I am gathering Renshaw and Boland out, Head and Kuhnemann in (from what I am hearing).

From Robbo?

amber_fluid wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Gerard Whateley has just said Head & Handscombe definitely playing from what he can gather by looking at the ground right now (warm ups).

Whateley and Lalor are probably laughing at our forum right about now, probably thinking "look at these dumb gullible pricks"

Most people reading this forum would probably think that!

At least we actually know it!

PatowalongaPirate wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:I am gathering Renshaw and Boland out, Head and Kuhnemann in (from what I am hearing).

Doubt they go in with just one quick

Yeah would be unlike us.

Looks like we are going in with just Pat