SA Footy

I see the for and againsts.

Agreed, waste of time that they're not eligible - BUT

makes for an interesting count and in most cases might make ineligible player think twice about offending again if he has a medal taken off of him.

Footy Chick wrote:I see the for and againsts.

Agreed, waste of time that they're not eligible - BUT

makes for an interesting count and in most cases might make ineligible player think twice about offending again if he has a medal taken off of him.

Ask Steven Wellington from last year.

Its just a list of the clubs top vote getters.

Has anyone got the Reserves invitees?

Nicholas Symons in the top 4 for the hawks. Quality ruckman that should get a gig in the team of the year, although wobble guts needs to work on his goal kicking a little.

FFS, go and look in the medal night thread!

Footy Chick wrote:FFS, go and look in the medal night thread!

Well don't half do a job

Yank Man wrote:Ok PG you've had your fun. This is what I see based on the season thus far.
The fact remains they have lost Cross, Giuffreda, Reardon, Pawson, Madigan and Johnson-Shroeder from their early season domination and that brings them right back to the pack and very level with Ingle Farm.

Other than Johnson-schroeder, I heard the rest were all training last night

Mr Beefy wrote:Woodward - why invite him?

.

They invite Rosewater to compete in the finals - what's the difference?

Old Dog New Tricks wrote:

Mr Beefy wrote:Woodward - why invite him?

.

They invite Rosewater to compete in the finals - what's the difference?

Eligibility

Mr Beefy wrote:

Old Dog New Tricks wrote:

Mr Beefy wrote:Woodward - why invite him?

.

They invite Rosewater to compete in the finals - what's the difference?

Eligibility

.

Result is the same

Old Dog New Tricks wrote:

Mr Beefy wrote:

Old Dog New Tricks wrote:

Mr Beefy wrote:Woodward - why invite him?

.

They invite Rosewater to compete in the finals - what's the difference?

Eligibility

.

Result is the same

Got to be in it to win, you boys might make finals one year if you can go through a year
Without incident and lose your points.

Alan wrote:

Yank Man wrote:Ok PG you've had your fun. This is what I see based on the season thus far.
The fact remains they have lost Cross, Giuffreda, Reardon, Pawson, Madigan and Johnson-Shroeder from their early season domination and that brings them right back to the pack and very level with Ingle Farm.

Other than Johnson-schroeder, I heard the rest were all training last night

Great news for the dogs, but WOW some of those guys have almost missed the whole second half of the season. Broken bits, fractured bits, mental bits, would be a massive gamble to play any of them unless they come back through the ressies, which I have been guilty of doing, sorry to those concerned. the fact is it's do or die for the dogs and if those guys are available then selection will be a nightmare. Cross, gun, Pawson, gun, Reardon, gun, Gieffreda and Madigan are top players. We are talking about top echelon boys here and were the reason they were on top early. Interesting.

Arch44 wrote:My tips this week are the 2 West Croydon sides and the 2 Rosewater sides.

3 to come back in the ones this week.
IF will win the magoos.

Wouldn't COMMON SENSE prevail and Ingle Farm host a triple header?? just seems logical, but then again COMMON SENSE and Amateur Leauge in one sentence just doesn't seem right, Amatuer in true sense of the meaning.....

old fullback wrote:Wouldn't COMMON SENSE prevail and Ingle Farm host a triple header?? just seems logical, but then again COMMON SENSE and Amateur Leauge in one sentence just doesn't seem right, Amatuer in true sense of the meaning.....

Regardless of what we would like old fullback, West Croydon earned the right for their B's to be with their A's (and hence our B's playing away). If either our A's or B's were good enough recently, we would be together and playing a triple header. It's our own doing, NOT a lack of common sense by the League at all.

old fullback wrote:Wouldn't COMMON SENSE prevail and Ingle Farm host a triple header?? just seems logical, but then again COMMON SENSE and Amateur Leauge in one sentence just doesn't seem right, Amatuer in true sense of the meaning.....

In the minds of some the Earth revolves around the Sun, and the Sun revolves around Ingle Farm

Yank Man wrote:

Alan wrote:

Yank Man wrote:Ok PG you've had your fun. This is what I see based on the season thus far.
The fact remains they have lost Cross, Giuffreda, Reardon, Pawson, Madigan and Johnson-Shroeder from their early season domination and that brings them right back to the pack and very level with Ingle Farm.

Other than Johnson-schroeder, I heard the rest were all training last night

Great news for the dogs, but WOW some of those guys have almost missed the whole second half of the season. Broken bits, fractured bits, mental bits, would be a massive gamble to play any of them unless they come back through the ressies, which I have been guilty of doing, sorry to those concerned. the fact is it's do or die for the dogs and if those guys are available then selection will be a nightmare. Cross, gun, Pawson, gun, Reardon, gun, Gieffreda and Madigan are top players. We are talking about top echelon boys here and were the reason they were on top early. Interesting.

I would think only 2 would go straight into the As if their ready to go, the others missed too many weeks.

Removed

Sums up CU mind set doesnt it Piglet, taking pot shots at a club whos active in the second week of the finals while they sit on SAAFL sanctions and another year of irrelevance in div 6.. You cant teach an Old Dog New Tricks which is why they will always be a battling club

Mr Beefy wrote:

Yank Man wrote:

Alan wrote:

Yank Man wrote:Ok PG you've had your fun. This is what I see based on the season thus far.
The fact remains they have lost Cross, Giuffreda, Reardon, Pawson, Madigan and Johnson-Shroeder from their early season domination and that brings them right back to the pack and very level with Ingle Farm.

Other than Johnson-schroeder, I heard the rest were all training last night

Great news for the dogs, but WOW some of those guys have almost missed the whole second half of the season. Broken bits, fractured bits, mental bits, would be a massive gamble to play any of them unless they come back through the ressies, which I have been guilty of doing, sorry to those concerned. the fact is it's do or die for the dogs and if those guys are available then selection will be a nightmare. Cross, gun, Pawson, gun, Reardon, gun, Gieffreda and Madigan are top players. We are talking about top echelon boys here and were the reason they were on top early. Interesting.

I would think only 2 would go straight into the As if their ready to go, the others missed too many weeks.

Clearly that would be Cross and Pawson, that would really suit up your midfield Mr Beefy with Chad Williams and Frank, gives you massive rotation. Can't wait to see the selected team.