SA Footy

The_Informer wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:Wait if a player moves between clubs in the same division, do they attract points?

FFS, if a player has played the majority of games in the A grade of a SAAFl club and moves to another SAAFL club he is worth 2 points.
Unless a Junior or the other reasons come into play.

Is that right, the SAAFL has implemented it's own rule for internal transfers, you can get a Div1 A-Grader for only 2 points and a Div1 B-grader for 0 points?

Look Good In Leather wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:Wait if a player moves between clubs in the same division, do they attract points?

FFS, if a player has played the majority of games in the A grade of a SAAFl club and moves to another SAAFL club he is worth 2 points.
Unless a Junior or the other reasons come into play.

Is that right, the SAAFL has implemented it's own rule for internal transfers, you can get a Div1 A-Grader for only 2 points and a Div1 B-grader for 0 points?

Yes that is correct

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:If I went and played for Kilburn would that make me a 2 pointer?

If you were getting a transfer from another SAAFL club to Kilburn and had not played for 2 seasons and last played majority A grade games, you would be a 0 pointer

Damn, I just wanted to be worth something.

LM my friend.. you are priceless

More like worthless

The_Informer wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:Wait if a player moves between clubs in the same division, do they attract points?

FFS, if a player has played the majority of games in the A grade of a SAAFl club and moves to another SAAFL club he is worth 2 points.
Unless a Junior or the other reasons come into play.

Is that right, the SAAFL has implemented it's own rule for internal transfers, you can get a Div1 A-Grader for only 2 points and a Div1 B-grader for 0 points?

Yes that is correct

What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

Look Good In Leather wrote:What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

What are your rules?

The_Informer wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:Wait if a player moves between clubs in the same division, do they attract points?

FFS, if a player has played the majority of games in the A grade of a SAAFl club and moves to another SAAFL club he is worth 2 points.
Unless a Junior or the other reasons come into play.

Is that right, the SAAFL has implemented it's own rule for internal transfers, you can get a Div1 A-Grader for only 2 points and a Div1 B-grader for 0 points?

Yes that is correct

So the league encourages clubs to poach off of each other rather than from clubs outside of your league Makes lots of sense

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

What are your rules?

As defined by the CFB

Players from SAAFL Div1-3 = 3 points
Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points
Players from SAAFL D4 down (A-Grade) = 2 points

Look Good In Leather wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

What are your rules?

As defined by the CFB

Players from SAAFL Div1-3 = 3 points
Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points
Players from SAAFL D4 down (A-Grade) = 2 points

Yeah.. doesn't say anything there about reserves players lower than D3R attracting points?

Look Good In Leather wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

What are your rules?

As defined by the CFB

Players from SAAFL Div1-3 = 3 points
Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points
Players from SAAFL D4 down (A-Grade) = 2 points

I have never read about Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points, can you please point that out to me as i havent been involved for a year or so

The_Informer wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:

Phantom Gossiper wrote:

Look Good In Leather wrote:What a joke, should be the same rules across the board, else it does not work

What are your rules?

As defined by the CFB

Players from SAAFL Div1-3 = 3 points
Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points
Players from SAAFL D4 down (A-Grade) = 2 points

I have never read about Players from SAAFL D1R-D3R = 2 points, can you please point that out to me as i havent been involved for a year or so

That is a rule for the SAAFL only. A couple of Div 1 & 2 clubs had their depth raided by country clubs. They got enough support to implement a rule change. Only applies to transfers out of SAAFL, within the league they are zero. Might not be around for much longer as some lower division clubs have cottoned on to this anomaly....

I would have thought it was beneficial to the league to have these D1R/D2R players stay in the SAAFL rather than go bush?

30mm rain at Houghton yesterday. This ain't gonna be pretty.

Smithfield have lost 8 points and are now sitting third I have heard. Due to their under 18s.

Sent from my HTC_PN071 using Tapatalk

Bigshow82 wrote:Smithfield have lost 8 points and are now sitting third I have heard. Due to their under 18s.

Just got told this. Looking at the ladder, this is what it shows.

Apparently, they are now on even thinner ice with the league.

Q. wrote:

Bigshow82 wrote:Smithfield have lost 8 points and are now sitting third I have heard. Due to their under 18s.

Just got told this. Looking at the ladder, this is what it shows.

Apparently, they are now on even thinner ice with the league.

Houghton Flag Favourites

What happened?
Is it because of playing over the points allowance???

tomo wrote:What happened?
Is it because of playing over the points allowance???

Think not tomo. How the hell can they let this happen. They could come from 7th and still win the flag. Staggered.

tomo wrote:What happened?
Is it because of playing over the points allowance???

Had a under 18's player reported for abusing umpires x 2, he received 4 games + (4) suspended, so they must have a been on a system by the league if any one at the club is reported they will loose the same amount points in the the top team. Maybe thats why they forfeited the 18's on the weekend because they can't afford any more suspensions??

Yank Man wrote:

tomo wrote:What happened?
Is it because of playing over the points allowance???

Think not tomo. How the hell can they let this happen. They could come from 7th and still win the flag. Staggered.

If they get any more suspensions they might not make the finals.

Correct DJ. Was part of their conditions on playing this season.