SA Footy

jo172 wrote:What really loses me is that all Divisions have the same salary cap with the natural implication being that the gap between D1 and D7 should be as narrow as possible.

In what world is this a preferable reality?

the sad reality of equal capping div 1 to div 7 down, is that the cream of adelaide's metropolitian total footballers, the top 5% who are actually worthy of being paid, are unfortunately unable to be facilated here because they are classed as too good and too expensive. Or in another sense - not welcome here

consequently then they have to go to the barossa, great southern or whatever league

Then throughout the year channel 9 do their tv snippets, and we all pay $15 bucks to get into a div 1 grand final... "yeah C9AFL its all so great", but it truly isnt because the cream of the crop are being excluded off and we are all forced to watch a sub-standard division 1

marbles wrote:

jo172 wrote:What really loses me is that all Divisions have the same salary cap with the natural implication being that the gap between D1 and D7 should be as narrow as possible.

In what world is this a preferable reality?

the sad reality of equal capping div 1 to div 7 down, is that the cream of adelaide's metropolitian total footballers, the top 5% who are actually worthy of being paid, are unfortunately unable to be facilated here because they are classed as too good and too expensive. Or in another sense - not welcome here

consequently then they have to go to the barossa, great southern or whatever league

Then throughout the year channel 9 do their tv snippets, and we all pay $15 bucks to get into a div 1 grand final... "yeah C9AFL its all so great", but it truly isnt because the cream of the crop are being excluded off and we are all forced to watch a sub-standard division 1

I think you're being a bit extreme here Marbles. There would maybe be 1 or 2 saafl clubs that would realistically be able to match what some country clubs pay. So regardless of a cap or not, you'd still have these sorts of guys going to the country chasing a dollar.
I don't think div 1 would be considered sub-standard as a result. Plus, the cream of the local crop should all be playing SANFL anyway. I'd be pretty confident in saying div 1 would still be the best non-sanfl comp in SA.

bird of prey wrote:

marbles wrote:

jo172 wrote:What really loses me is that all Divisions have the same salary cap with the natural implication being that the gap between D1 and D7 should be as narrow as possible.

In what world is this a preferable reality?

the sad reality of equal capping div 1 to div 7 down, is that the cream of adelaide's metropolitian total footballers, the top 5% who are actually worthy of being paid, are unfortunately unable to be facilated here because they are classed as too good and too expensive. Or in another sense - not welcome here

consequently then they have to go to the barossa, great southern or whatever league

Then throughout the year channel 9 do their tv snippets, and we all pay $15 bucks to get into a div 1 grand final... "yeah C9AFL its all so great", but it truly isnt because the cream of the crop are being excluded off and we are all forced to watch a sub-standard division 1

I think you're being a bit extreme here Marbles. There would maybe be 1 or 2 saafl clubs that would realistically be able to match what some country clubs pay. So regardless of a cap or not, you'd still have these sorts of guys going to the country chasing a dollar.
I don't think div 1 would be considered sub-standard as a result. Plus, the cream of the local crop should all be playing SANFL anyway. I'd be pretty confident in saying div 1 would still be the best non-sanfl comp in SA.

im only pushing that we have "equal" salary caps to country clubs - Div1 to Div3, then if nuggets want drive out to poultry farms, then who gives a stuff

secondly who is the biggest name in c9afl div 1 2016?

edit: want*

marbles wrote:

bird of prey wrote:

marbles wrote:

jo172 wrote:What really loses me is that all Divisions have the same salary cap with the natural implication being that the gap between D1 and D7 should be as narrow as possible.

In what world is this a preferable reality?

the sad reality of equal capping div 1 to div 7 down, is that the cream of adelaide's metropolitian total footballers, the top 5% who are actually worthy of being paid, are unfortunately unable to be facilated here because they are classed as too good and too expensive. Or in another sense - not welcome here

consequently then they have to go to the barossa, great southern or whatever league

Then throughout the year channel 9 do their tv snippets, and we all pay $15 bucks to get into a div 1 grand final... "yeah C9AFL its all so great", but it truly isnt because the cream of the crop are being excluded off and we are all forced to watch a sub-standard division 1

I think you're being a bit extreme here Marbles. There would maybe be 1 or 2 saafl clubs that would realistically be able to match what some country clubs pay. So regardless of a cap or not, you'd still have these sorts of guys going to the country chasing a dollar.
I don't think div 1 would be considered sub-standard as a result. Plus, the cream of the local crop should all be playing SANFL anyway. I'd be pretty confident in saying div 1 would still be the best non-sanfl comp in SA.

im only pushing that we have "equal" salary caps to country clubs - Div1 to Div3, then if nuggets what drive out to poultry farms, then who gives a stuff

secondly who is the biggest name in c9afl div 1 2016?

Based on your criteria of has their own wikipedia articles Ben Nason, Hayden Jolly and Adam Cockshell come immediately to mind.

More when you count Michael Coad, Shane Tuck and Travis Tuck next year.

Lads.

I'm coming back next year.

They'll be 10 deep at the Den to witness the majesty

morell wrote:Lads.

I'm coming back next year.

They'll be 10 deep at the Den to witness the majesty

Only because Mitchell Park are on the D1 salary Cap right?

Well am glad there were at least 3 players u could name

Mitchell Park and Henley will have exactly the same number of players in D1 in 2017.

jo172 wrote:

morell wrote:Lads.

I'm coming back next year.

They'll be 10 deep at the Den to witness the majesty

Only because Mitchell Park are on the D1 salary Cap right?

if the league found out what I am really on they'd kick Mitchell Park out of the comp.

morell wrote:

jo172 wrote:

morell wrote:Lads.

I'm coming back next year.

They'll be 10 deep at the Den to witness the majesty

Only because Mitchell Park are on the D1 salary Cap right?

if the league found out what I am really on they'd kick Mitchell Park out of the comp.

Your on the good drugs then?

Many would say that I am twobob! Alas, I am not even a drinker let alone drug taker.

Jay schultz has turned down an offer of $400 a game at an unconfirmed c9afl club and will instead be heading to a victorian country club next season

marbles wrote:Jay schultz has turned down an offer of $400 a game at an unconfirmed c9afl club and will instead be heading to a victorian country club next season

Didn't realise St Kevin's Old Boys had relocated out of the Metro Melbourne area.....

Jay Schultz at $400 I can't understand why he hasn't
Stuck around , after being on close to 350k +.
You blokes are kidding yourselfs if you keep voting for this crap
Salary cap you will never keep any gun players here if Victoria is based on population
Salary cap , with clubs aloud to upto 150k a year.

running defender wrote:Jay Schultz at $400 I can't understand why he hasn't
Stuck around , after being on close to 350k +.
You blokes are kidding yourselfs if you keep voting for this crap
Salary cap you will never keep any gun players here if Victoria is based on population
Salary cap , with clubs aloud to upto 150k a year.

Thought i read Victorian clubs cap is 250k, good luck any SANFL club attracting anyone with their 350k cap split between 50 ish blokes. These amateur clubs probably get away with only paying a max of 22 blokes each week.

Monday night should be fun.

4 SA Clubs done over the Cap!

2 from the SAAFL

Who's the Div 1 club with a current mass exodus?????? No idea who could someone lend me a HAND?

carey wrote:Monday night should be fun.

4 SA Clubs done over the Cap!

2 from the SAAFL

Who's the Div 1 club with a current mass exodus?????? No idea who could someone lend me a HAND?

Not to point any fingers but if they've managed to finger anyone the penalties need to be severe. Only hope in hell of the system working

One club handed itself in so the penalties will be reduced.

jo172 wrote:

carey wrote:Monday night should be fun.

4 SA Clubs done over the Cap!

2 from the SAAFL

Who's the Div 1 club with a current mass exodus?????? No idea who could someone lend me a HAND?

Not to point any fingers but if they've managed to finger anyone the penalties need to be severe. Only hope in hell of the system working

Totally agree!
If this Salary Cap is going to work, there needs to be a NO TOLERANCE policy on any breach.
There should be NO COMPASSION for any clubs self confessing, if you're over the cap by as little as $100 one week, you're over the cap, its as simple as that.
Wouldn't see the AFL letting clubs off with a slap on the wrist!

Bag & Sledge wrote:

jo172 wrote:

carey wrote:Monday night should be fun.

4 SA Clubs done over the Cap!

2 from the SAAFL

Who's the Div 1 club with a current mass exodus?????? No idea who could someone lend me a HAND?

Not to point any fingers but if they've managed to finger anyone the penalties need to be severe. Only hope in hell of the system working

Totally agree!
If this Salary Cap is going to work, there needs to be a NO TOLERANCE policy on any breach.
There should be NO COMPASSION for any clubs self confessing, if you're over the cap by as little as $100 one week, you're over the cap, its as simple as that.
Wouldn't see the AFL letting clubs off with a slap on the wrist!

Particularly given at least ostensibly it seems difficult for the CFL to catch anyone. The only way to balance the apparent minimal risk of detection is to have incredibly harsh penalties.