SA Footy

rooman wrote:

jo172 wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:CBC B Grade rocking up to GGFC today with only 16 players despite their C Grade having a bye is baffling.

Always been a strange club like that CBC

CBC forfeited in C Grade on Saturday. Are they going to be able to field a team for Saturday as the first week of finals for C6?

Jeepers how on earth did CBC C grade make finals - must have been a horrific C grade comp this year

Sticks28 wrote:

rooman wrote:

jo172 wrote:

Fools Gold wrote:CBC B Grade rocking up to GGFC today with only 16 players despite their C Grade having a bye is baffling.

Always been a strange club like that CBC

CBC forfeited in C Grade on Saturday. Are they going to be able to field a team for Saturday as the first week of finals for C6?

Jeepers how on earth did CBC C grade make finals - must have been a horrific C grade comp this year

They are in C5 or somethign arent they? they arent in C3 thats for sure! Adelaide Uni took their spot in C3.

Fools Gold wrote:CBC B Grade rocking up to GGFC today with only 16 players despite their C Grade having a bye is baffling.

CBC actually played with 15. GGFC played 16v15 for the first 3 quarters.

Saturday 20th August

Flinders Park Oval
Qualifying Final
Div 3 - Flinders Park v Modbury - 2:00pm
Div 3R - Flinders Park v Edwardstown - 12:00pm

Edwardstown Oval
Elimination Final
Div 3 - Edwardstown v Scotch OC - 2:30pm
Div 3R - SMOSH West Lakes v Modbury - 10:30am

Noticed Josh Glenn playing for Golden Grove yesterday.

Bluedemon wrote:Saturday 20th August


Edwardstown Oval
Elimination Final
Div 3 - Edwardstown v Scotch OC - 2:30pm
Div 3R - SMOSH West Lakes v Scotch OC - 10:30am

Hang on, ressies is SMOSH and Modbury at 10.30am and then C3 is Scotch v SMOSH at 12.30pm

Footy Chick wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:Saturday 20th August


Edwardstown Oval
Elimination Final
Div 3 - Edwardstown v Scotch OC - 2:30pm
Div 3R - SMOSH West Lakes v Scotch OC - 10:30am

Yet C3 Is also Scotch and SMOSH but is being played at 12.30pm,

C Graders cant hold their consumption

Executive Member wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:Saturday 20th August


Edwardstown Oval
Elimination Final
Div 3 - Edwardstown v Scotch OC - 2:30pm
Div 3R - SMOSH West Lakes v Scotch OC - 10:30am

Yet C3 Is also Scotch and SMOSH but is being played at 12.30pm,

C Graders cant hold their consumption

Nah Bluedemon is confused, 3R is SMOSH and Modbury at 10.30am - makes sense now, it's probably so scotch can play one after another and not have to move bags

southernbulldog wrote:Noticed Josh Glenn playing for Golden Grove yesterday.

Yep, I watched him play, GG have a crook old side, must be huge brown paper bags up that way!
Josh is lean & mean, could easily step back into SANFL next season but he wants to play on with Shenton & Co.

Footy Chick wrote:

Executive Member wrote:

Footy Chick wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:Saturday 20th August


Edwardstown Oval
Elimination Final
Div 3 - Edwardstown v Scotch OC - 2:30pm
Div 3R - SMOSH West Lakes v Scotch OC - 10:30am

Yet C3 Is also Scotch and SMOSH but is being played at 12.30pm,

C Graders cant hold their consumption

Nah Bluedemon is confused, 3R is SMOSH and Modbury at 10.30am - makes sense now, it's probably so scotch can play one after another and not have to move bags

And players from Modbury B grade can go and watch their A grade play later in the day at another venue

S Demon wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:

oldman wrote:Any updates on the Westminster fiasco? Surely it needs to be sorted out with a final decision reached. Clearly it will have significant ramifications one way or another for teams battling to avoid relegation and also a possible finals spot.

are they appealing it?

Reading The Update this morning, I would suggest an appeal isn't on the cards...

"Facilitating a permit on PHQ is not the same as applying for a permit to be auto approved as against having it approved by The League as per eligibility described in the Rules and Regulation.
Be under no illusion, your club will lose premiership points and or score as well as wear the fine from any match if these regulations are breached."

Westminster is appealing the decision & they think they'll win.
Training as usual tomorrow night.

gazzamagoo wrote:

S Demon wrote:

Bluedemon wrote:

oldman wrote:Any updates on the Westminster fiasco? Surely it needs to be sorted out with a final decision reached. Clearly it will have significant ramifications one way or another for teams battling to avoid relegation and also a possible finals spot.

are they appealing it?

Reading The Update this morning, I would suggest an appeal isn't on the cards...

"Facilitating a permit on PHQ is not the same as applying for a permit to be auto approved as against having it approved by The League as per eligibility described in the Rules and Regulation.
Be under no illusion, your club will lose premiership points and or score as well as wear the fine from any match if these regulations are breached."

Westminster is appealing the decision & they think they'll win.
Training as usual tomorrow night.

Surely if they where going to appeal they would have done it by now??

Yeah i was going to say surely they won't win the appeal this close to finals? surely would have been sorted ages ago if there was an issue.

What's the point of appealing? They missed the finals by 3 points and didn't get relegated. They'll finish 6th with or without an appeal.

MoP wrote:What's the point of appealing? They missed the finals by 3 points and didn't get relegated. They'll finish 6th with or without an appeal.

They get 2 points, Scotch lose two points

WOS make the 5

Armchair expert wrote:

MoP wrote:What's the point of appealing? They missed the finals by 3 points and didn't get relegated. They'll finish 6th with or without an appeal.

They get 2 points, Scotch lose two points

WOS make the 5

take it to the supreme court easy fixed

Westminster is appealing the decision & they think they'll win.
Training as usual tomorrow night.[/quote]


Two incredibly dumb and ridiculous comments in a row. Maybe a few beers at mad Monday had a fair bit of salt in them???

the smokey wrote:Westminster is appealing the decision & they think they'll win.
Training as usual tomorrow night.

Two incredibly dumb and ridiculous comments in a row. Maybe a few beers at mad Monday had a fair bit of salt in them???[/quote]

Apparently the SANFL is stepping in.

Westmister appeal is happening.
Not sure why but the SANFL are involved, the permit in question was approved is my mail from very reliable source.

The Adelaide Footy League is no longer "Amateur" clubs are spending significant amounts of money to improve and becoming far more professional, it would appear after the last couple of weeks with decisions made by the league that clubs could be starting to question the leagues handling and professionalism.

oldman wrote:Westmister appeal is happening.
Not sure why but the SANFL are involved, the permit in question was approved is my mail from very reliable source.

The Adelaide Footy League is no longer "Amateur" clubs are spending significant amounts of money to improve and becoming far more professional, it would appear after the last couple of weeks with decisions made by the league that clubs could be starting to question the leagues handling and professionalism.

The SANFL aren’t stepping in at all.

WOSFC have appealed to a SANFL tribunal as is their right after the SACFL have also told WOSFC that there is no valid permit.