Page 9 of 101
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 2:08 pmby twobob
Robb_Stark wrote:id say February 1st would be my deadline for both clubs if Kilburn cant produce a 55 playing list of actual players and salisbury west have not found anyone to take its place in div 3 then yeah the league need to makes some big decisions
Rob have the league told Salisbury West that they have to find a replacement club in Div 3? If thats the case i don't think it is a very good move by the SAAFL and does it leave the door open for a club outside of the SAAFL to get in and not have to start down at Div 6.
Will we be seeing the return of Edwardstown
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 2:26 pmby Robb_Stark
twobob wrote:Robb_Stark wrote:id say February 1st would be my deadline for both clubs if Kilburn cant produce a 55 playing list of actual players and salisbury west have not found anyone to take its place in div 3 then yeah the league need to makes some big decisions
Rob have the league told Salisbury West that they have to find a replacement club in Div 3? If thats the case i don't think it is a very good move by the SAAFL and does it leave the door open for a club outside of the SAAFL to get in and not have to start down at Div 6.
Will we be seeing the return of Edwardstown
i know a few clubs have expressed interest at this time but i think the kilburn problem is the bigger issue at the moment for the league
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 3:17 pmby twobob
Robb_Stark wrote:twobob wrote:Robb_Stark wrote:id say February 1st would be my deadline for both clubs if Kilburn cant produce a 55 playing list of actual players and salisbury west have not found anyone to take its place in div 3 then yeah the league need to makes some big decisions
Rob have the league told Salisbury West that they have to find a replacement club in Div 3? If thats the case i don't think it is a very good move by the SAAFL and does it leave the door open for a club outside of the SAAFL to get in and not have to start down at Div 6.
Will we be seeing the return of Edwardstown
i know a few clubs have expressed interest at this time but i think the kilburn problem is the bigger issue at the moment for the league
Are all these clubs Div 4 clubs
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 9:21 pmby wonder_kid
surely one of the div 4 clubs would take the opportunity to go up to div 3! EP would be the standout choice but not sure the footy club would want to!
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 9:29 pmby Footy Chick
they didn't want to stay up last year when Brahma opted out of D3, so there is absolutely no logic to them jumping at the chance to go back up to a place they didn't want to stay at in the first place.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 9:55 pmby wonder_kid
Footy Chick wrote:they didn't want to stay up last year when Brahma opted out of D3, so there is absolutely no logic to them jumping at the chance to go back up to a place they didn't want to stay at in the first place.
Nth haven ??? pooraka??
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 10:06 pmby twobob
wonder_kid wrote:Footy Chick wrote:they didn't want to stay up last year when Brahma opted out of D3, so there is absolutely no logic to them jumping at the chance to go back up to a place they didn't want to stay at in the first place.
Nth haven ??? pooraka??
i don't think it would be a very smart move for North Haven
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 10:14 pmby Jetters
The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Wed Nov 12, 2014 11:53 pmby Look Good In Leather
Jetters wrote:The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 9:43 amby Pag
Look Good In Leather wrote:Jetters wrote:The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 9:45 amby HH3
Pag wrote:Look Good In Leather wrote:Jetters wrote:The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
I like how SFL people try to tell SAAFL people how to run divisions
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 9:59 amby Lightning McQueen
Pag wrote:
]Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
You're not just a hat rack hey Pag
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 10:00 amby Q.
Look Good In Leather wrote:Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 11:19 amby Pag
Lightning McQueen wrote:Pag wrote:
]Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
You're not just a hat rack hey Pag
Much, much more mate.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 11:21 amby Boosh
twobob wrote:wonder_kid wrote:Footy Chick wrote:they didn't want to stay up last year when Brahma opted out of D3, so there is absolutely no logic to them jumping at the chance to go back up to a place they didn't want to stay at in the first place.
Nth haven ??? pooraka??
i don't think it would be a very smart move for North Haven
North Haven would like to get into Div 3 but we would be prime candidates for relegation so probably wouldn't go for it
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 1:06 pmby Look Good In Leather
Pag wrote:Look Good In Leather wrote:Jetters wrote:The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
Totally agree, but 4 or 5 clubs stuff themselves up and now everyone is now expected to fall over themselves to save them.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 1:08 pmby Look Good In Leather
HH3 wrote:Pag wrote:Look Good In Leather wrote:Jetters wrote:The SAAFL has set a very dangerous precedent.
Unless a club is hit with unforeseeable and extreme circumstances, it should not be allowed to (in the 'A' grades), more or less, choose its division.
It gives a club with poor management an opt out of the consequence of its poor management and encourages other clubs to run their clubs with a greater element of risk because they know, if they screw it up, the SAAFL will save them.
What a cock up.
Sounds like you need to adopt a grading system like in social basketball. Play a few games and then allocate into divisions. Would solve all your issues.
Don't need to. Make a GF, go up. Finish bottom two, go down. Simple. Or, it should be.
I like how SFL people try to tell SAAFL people how to run divisions
I like how the SAAFL's rep team represents the entire state
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 1:25 pmby Footy Chick
If your'e going to continue to come in here and fling shit like a chimpanzee, piss off.
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 1:43 pmby Robb_Stark
when the SAAFL is the next biggest league after the SANFL of course it would represent the state.....country league would be dead with out players going from saafl to fill up the gaps or the leagues would be piss poor with hicks playing in them
Re: Ch9 AFL Division 4 - 2015
Posted:
Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:22 pmby Footy Chick
and what does this have to do with D4 was more my point...