SA Footy

mutton cove wrote:Any word on the Compass fiasco ,or do the other clubs have to just suck it up. Would be interesting to see the make up and positioning of the final five at the end of the home and away rounds if this has not been addressed.

I don’t think the final 5 change from here. Positions might change, but that’s about it.

Tiger83 wrote:

mutton cove wrote:Any word on the Compass fiasco ,or do the other clubs have to just suck it up. Would be interesting to see the make up and positioning of the final five at the end of the home and away rounds if this has not been addressed.

I don’t think the final 5 change from here. Positions might change, but that’s about it.

I fear it happens in many league's

Can anyone tell me who the galahs are that commentate on that gsfl YouTube

They are terrible. They don’t know many names of the player except for enc bay game
then they get the wrong players names
A guy kicks for goal the number clearly on his back and they call someone else

The ball goes up, there’s a hand ball, the ball goes up someone kicks it the ball goes up..... on and on and on

They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

The eclipse fan wrote:
They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

[emoji23][emoji23]
Usually Kevin Curran, Trevor Prior and Nifty Miller.
Yes they are but at least they are doing it. I’m sure they’d welcome some help Putting your hand up?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

field of dreams wrote:

The eclipse fan wrote:
They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

[emoji23][emoji23]
Usually Kevin Curran, Trevor Prior and Nifty Miller.
Yes they are but at least they are doing it. I’m sure they’d welcome some help Putting your hand up?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nifty Miller is by far the best of the 3 and is quite knowledgeable and entertaining with his call whilst the other 2 try but struggle to keep up with whats going on.

field of dreams wrote:

The eclipse fan wrote:
They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

[emoji23][emoji23]
Usually Kevin Curran, Trevor Prior and Nifty Miller.
Yes they are but at least they are doing it. I’m sure they’d welcome some help Putting your hand up?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Very ordinary commentary and they aren’t open to any help or giving it up for some new callers.

damian wrote:

field of dreams wrote:

The eclipse fan wrote:
They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

[emoji23][emoji23]
Usually Kevin Curran, Trevor Prior and Nifty Miller.
Yes they are but at least they are doing it. I’m sure they’d welcome some help Putting your hand up?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Very ordinary commentary and they aren’t open to any help or giving it up for some new callers.

Wow- surprised to hear that.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

damian wrote:

field of dreams wrote:

The eclipse fan wrote:
They are bloody terrible

Who are they????

[emoji23][emoji23]
Usually Kevin Curran, Trevor Prior and Nifty Miller.
Yes they are but at least they are doing it. I’m sure they’d welcome some help Putting your hand up?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Very ordinary commentary and they aren’t open to any help or giving it up for some new callers.

Bloody hell, those guys were nearly past it when I played a few games in the early 90s

I recall a few years ago in the program that when Strathalbyn had a Home Game then Langhorne Creek would have an Away game and Vice a Versa, this seems to have changed now,

old fullback wrote:I recall a few years ago in the program that when Strathalbyn had a Home Game then Langhorne Creek would have an Away game and Vice a Versa, this seems to have changed now,

I think you'll find that scheduling also applied to Yank and Myponga games and possibly Victor Encounter Bay games.

The Fiasco continues.

Compass and their 'member of parliament' flexed his muscles and appealed the fact that Tom Dix is a 0 pointer. An appeal was heard by an "independent commission" (Bob Bache, Gordon Tonkin and one other) and what i am hearing is that they have overturned the decision and Tom Dix is down deemed a Zero point player.

The GSFL is becoming a joke! Mount Compass Football Club are losing all credibility and are making themselves the most hated club in the league.

How hard is it to just accept the points system and rules put in place and abide by them.

On what grounds did they appeal he is zero points?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Tom Dix Cannot be a zero pointer, read the rules and accept the points system. Compass have breached the points on three occasions so far this season and claimed ignorance or being given permission. Three players have since had there points adjusted up ( with Dix now being appealed ) yet no penalty for any breach. This is on top of appealing for and receiving 2 extra points which they did not qualify for. F.F.S.

So any player who didn’t play in 2020 is now 0?

Pandora's can of worms has just been cracked open.

LuvsFooty wrote:So any player who didn’t play in 2020 is now 0?

Recruiting season just re-opened?

This has the potential to open up a serious can of worms across every league in SA if this is not properly dealt with and parties outside of the league stepping in. If there are leagues who don’t agree with the points system coming in, all you need to do is look at this example and start making up exemptions. It’s not good!

Dutchy wrote:

LuvsFooty wrote:So any player who didn’t play in 2020 is now 0?

Recruiting season just re-opened?

Mid season draft!!!

LaughingKookaburra wrote:This has the potential to open up a serious can of worms across every league in SA if this is not properly dealt with and parties outside of the league stepping in. If there are leagues who don’t agree with the points system coming in, all you need to do is look at this example and start making up exemptions. It’s not good!

I thought the Community Footy Board have an investigation team that address these issues and make ruling above the Leagues rules.

With player points, the only scope a league has is the allocation of points each season to the clubs in their league whilst working within the permitted parameters i.e. number of clubs x 15 points = the total number of points that the league can distribute as they see fit.

Most leagues including the GSFL have established guidelines for that allocation e.g. ladder position and/or games won in the previous X or Y years. BUT - none of this changes the SACFL rules for determining the points allocation to an individual player.

Driving the Victor Harbor Road is dangerous enough without soon having to avoid the heads that may be rolling down it!!!