Page 1 of 3
Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 10:43 pmby hearts on fire
i think it's about time we see some common sense with Tredrea and send him back to the Magpies for a few games. Tredrea's performance tonight against the blues wasn't any better than previous weeks. He just can't do anything right at the moment, although the delivery has been poor he needs to be dropped back to the Magpies.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 10:52 pmby jackpot jim
And Replace Him With WHO ?????
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 10:55 pmby hearts on fire
someone that can make a contest!!!
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:00 pmby NFC
Magpie reserves IMO.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:01 pmby Hondo
Just checked the PP website and looked at their players in the SANFL ... there's not a lot there to replace Tredrea in position apart from maybe Willits?
Also would dropping the Captain have any impact on the morale of the younger guys?
But, I said in a different post he must be close to needing a break from AFL to either recuperate some more or get some touch back in the SANFL
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:06 pmby TroyGFC
Willis???
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:06 pmby smithy
hondo71 wrote:Just checked the PP website and looked at their players in the SANFL ... there's not a lot there to replace Tredrea in position apart from maybe Willits?
Also would dropping the Captain have any impact on the morale of the younger guys?
But, I said in a different post he must be close to needing a break from AFL to either recuperate some more or get some touch back in the SANFL
Westhoff was pretty good at FF tonight....
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:08 pmby hearts on fire
smithy wrote:hondo71 wrote:Just checked the PP website and looked at their players in the SANFL ... there's not a lot there to replace Tredrea in position apart from maybe Willits?
Also would dropping the Captain have any impact on the morale of the younger guys?
But, I said in a different post he must be close to needing a break from AFL to either recuperate some more or get some touch back in the SANFL
Westhoff was pretty good at FF tonight....
he was about the only forward that presented and kicked goals
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:09 pmby the wonder elephant
what about cockshell ? how many did he kick in the mighty legs thumping of the eags ?
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:30 pmby brent
TroyGFC wrote:Willis???
what you talkin bout willis?!
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sat Jun 09, 2007 11:48 pmby Aerie
the wonder elephant wrote:what about cockshell ? how many did he kick in the mighty legs thumping of the eags ?
I'm not sure how many Cockshell kicked today, but the two times I've seen him this year he's played well. Port might as well give him a run.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 12:03 amby smithy
brent wrote:TroyGFC wrote:Willis???
what you talkin bout willis?!
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 1:28 amby bayman
Aerie wrote:the wonder elephant wrote:what about cockshell ? how many did he kick in the mighty legs thumping of the eags ?
I'm not sure how many Cockshell kicked today, but the two times I've seen him this year he's played well. Port might as well give him a run.
cockshell kicked 1.2, willits or cockshell are the two that spring to mind if they did drop tredrea, i dont think that'll happen he may be injured for a week or two though
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 1:32 amby NFC
Cockshell is lucky to be playing for the league team ATM. No way is he AFL ready.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 10:24 amby the wonder elephant
NFC your only saying that to keep him at norwood as norwood have been winning since he has been back in the side . his preseason form was good as was his early afl form untill he got injured .i would think he would be in front of willits at this stage
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 10:35 amby Thiele
Willits didn't play after bruised ribs so i think Cockhsell might play if Tredrea gets drop
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 11:16 amby stan
smithy wrote:hondo71 wrote:Just checked the PP website and looked at their players in the SANFL ... there's not a lot there to replace Tredrea in position apart from maybe Willits?
Also would dropping the Captain have any impact on the morale of the younger guys?
But, I said in a different post he must be close to needing a break from AFL to either recuperate some more or get some touch back in the SANFL
Westhoff was pretty good at FF tonight....
Westhoff has been very good for a first year player. I like the way he has dip. Once he gets some body mass going he will be a great asset to the power forward line.
As who could replace Tredrea for a bit. Well you could look at willits. Maybe Damon White can have a bigger role. Or carlie in the side??? all possibilities, also consider the bloke from Norwood.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 11:41 amby silent hour
No leave him there he'll get some form back sooner or later.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 12:12 pmby TroyGFC
As long as Tredders isn't promoted to PAM's in a few weeks i will be happy. Can't imagine Tredder's, Waterhouse and Harg's all playing in same team though.
Re: Tredrea back to the Magpies??
Posted:
Sun Jun 10, 2007 12:14 pmby Hondo
TroyGFC wrote:As long as Tredders isn't promoted to PAM's in a few weeks i will be happy. Can't imagine Tredder's, Waterhouse and Harg's all playing in same team though.
You'd have to pre-record them, then play them back in FF on the day just so they can keep up