SA Footy

What are the thoughts about the eye gouge from Judd today. I so only a brief view on the news and not from a great angle, so wouldnt like to make too much comment. The whole incident over here is bigger than the loss. In the news tonight it was the first thing mentioned in the entire broadcast. If he goes it will do one thing - open the Brownlow Market.

Dead set filthy animal, rub him out for 6 weeks. How dare he gouge the great Campbell Brown...

Seriously, if he had hit the mark with the fingers Campbell would have gone ape sh!t..

7 weeks at the tribunal

goodbye all brownlow bets

I did notice Brownlow betting was suspended last night!

Bookies barracking for him to be suspended!!!!!...far out what a windfall for them if he does...they will all be driving mercedes if Judd gets suspended after KErr last week....

After seeing the incident a few times, Chris Judd is definitely in trouble. If he does get suspended, Chad Cornes should be the favorite for the Brownlow.

PortAdelaideProud wrote:After seeing the incident a few times, Chris Judd is definitely in trouble. If he does get suspended, Chad Cornes should be the favorite for the Brownlow.

Chad Cornes should be the favourite anyway. West Coast have a few players that can take votes away from Judd. Cornes is the absolute stand out player in the Port side. Not saying Port don't have other good players but Cornes this year is easily at another level.

give him a game...just realised who we are playing next week!!!

Couple of interesting comments coming out about the incident.
- Brown saying that he doesnt think that Judd should have a case to answer
- and Wayne Carey and his assesment that it was fairly soft, but if it was reversed Brown would get one or tweo weeks, but because its Judd he'll get off.

Judd offered 1 week for gouge

PortAdelaideProud wrote:After seeing the incident a few times, Chris Judd is definitely in trouble. If he does get suspended, Chad Cornes should be the favorite for the Brownlow.

Chad Cornes?

I didn't know umpires noticed players who stood out the back of packs and collected uncontested possession after uncontested possession?

So true NFC, So true

Nothing in it .. Half the time a player is on the bottom of a pack they'll push, shove, claw anything to get someone off them without even realising which part of the body it is.

I saw it for the first time last night.

Looks bad on the vision - but hey who knows what the tribunal will do

He got off.

Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

Goodwin is the handball recieve master..... WAP and I am glad the umpires see it that way as well........

At least Cornes plays with passion and can mark the football.....goodwin is a front runner..

another grub wrote:Goodwin is the handball recieve master..... WAP and I am glad the umpires see it that way as well........

At least Cornes plays with passion and can mark the football.....goodwin is a front runner..

Richmond would take him in a heartbeat

hondo71 wrote:

another grub wrote:Goodwin is the handball recieve master..... WAP and I am glad the umpires see it that way as well........

At least Cornes plays with passion and can mark the football.....goodwin is a front runner..

Richmond would take him in a heartbeat

Richmond will take anyone, the gave ty zantuk a gig

scoob wrote:Fair result for mine... dont think he deserved to get punished... has good record giv ehim the benefit of the doubt....

NFC... the umpires dont hence simon goodwin not winning last years medal...

Goodwin >> Cornes.