Robert Harvey is he finished

[the joker]

only one game from becoming the first saint to play 350 games but tore his hamstring early in the game against fremantle and with him being 35 and his history of bad hammys will he play again and get to 350???

[/img]

[NFC]

He'll play 350, but not too many more. 355 at the max IMO.

[mal]

Was one of the fittest players in the AFL then SK moved to that
famous concrete oval and ping ping ping ping ping HARVEY is as bad as WATTO

Yes I know it went ping in Perth tonight BUT....

[Dutchy]

Harvey is an absolute champion....wouldnt suprise to see him come back and still win their B & F

[smac]

What kind of setback is a hammy at that age? You would expect closer to 6 week recovery than the usual 3... Still plenty of time to chalk up the 350, the estimate above of 355 was probably on the money.

[rod_rooster]

Was one of the fittest players in the AFL then SK moved to that
famous concrete oval and ping ping ping ping ping HARVEY is as bad as WATTO

Yes I know it went ping in Perth tonight BUT....

No-one could be as bad as Watto mal

As for Harvey absolute champion in every sense of the word and he will get to 350.

[Rik E Boy]

I put 'No' just because of the determination of the man. I can't see him playing on for too much longer but Robert Harvey will return to AFL football and be a contributor in the latter stages of this season. It might be a case of St Kilda being finished however.

regards,

REB

Oops! I thought this poll was for 'is he finished'! No wonder the tally is 8 to 1!

[MightyEagles]

He might go on next year, but alot might not see it that way.

[scoob]

Oops! I thought this poll was for 'is he finished'! No wonder the tally is 8 to 1!

I fell for the same thing REB... topic heading ask 1 question then the poll asks another... mind you not too hard to confused the scoob...

[Hondo]

Why do we like to herald the end of our champion players so often?

Rubbish them for playing on, say they're too old, etc.

How often will we get to see a dual-Brownlow medalist running around?

[Blue Boy]

I have had the pleasure of meeting him a few times and he is a champion off the field as well.

Hoping he gets back and the Saints lift for him !!!

[the joker]

Why do we like to herald the end of our champion players so often?

Rubbish them for playing on, say they're too old, etc.

How often will we get to see a dual-Brownlow medalist running around?

well next year there will be adam goodes and chris judd playing

[spell_check]

Simple thing is, is that they are good enough to play, they should play regardless of age. He will come back for 350, but I get the feeling this would be his last year. But if Craig Bradley is anything to go by, who knows?

[Iron Fist]

this will be his last year
give him 5 to recover and he will finish off the year
hopefully his team mates can get him a finals berth
and for the ultimate reward
the saints win the premiership cant see it happening though