SA Footy

With all the debate about the reserves, how about this one?
What if their was a South West conference- Port, Adelaide, West coast and Fremantle
The 2 Neafl conferences- East and North - 18 teams
Total of 22 teams.
SW conference - plays each other twice( 6 games)
And the other 18 conference teams once- half away, half home.
Total of 24 matches- no NAB Cup.
SW games to be played as curtain raisers to AFL
Each AFL club is allocated 4 SANFL clubs to choose a total of 20 top up players at he beginning of the season.
No more than 4 from each club. Can include Under 18 players.
Only to be used when their Is not enough AFL listed players to choose from
Top 6- best performed sides over be 3 conferences.
1v6
2v5
3v4
2 lowest ranked losers drop out.
Preliminary finals
Grand final
Let us know your thoughts?

You lost me at "With all this debate"

drifter wrote:With all the debate about the reserves, how about this one?
What if their was a South West conference- Port, Adelaide, West coast and Fremantle
The 2 Neafl conferences- East and North - 18 teams
Total of 22 teams.
SW conference - plays each other twice( 6 games)
And the other 18 conference teams once- half away, half home.
Total of 24 matches- no NAB Cup.
SW games to be played as curtain raisers to AFL
Each AFL club is allocated 4 SANFL clubs to choose a total of 20 top up players at he beginning of the season.
No more than 4 from each club. Can include Under 18 players.Only to be used when their Is not enough AFL listed players to choose from
Top 6- best performed sides over be 3 conferences.
1v6
2v5
3v4
2 lowest ranked losers drop out.
Preliminary finals
Grand final
Let us know your thoughts?

You were doing ok until you suggested what is in bold. Again another AFL Supporter just thinking about what is best for the AFL and not really caring what you do to the SANFL!

This has SFA to do with reserves in the SANFL. The only reference to SANFL you make is the specification of SANFL teams as a host of warm bodies to top up AFL lists on demand. How about you take your idea and post it over on bigfooty where the braindead posters will no doubt laud you with kudos. You're unlikely to get it here.

If you read the title of the post, I never mentioned the SANFL, I reckon you must be on the wrong forum, not me. Surely this doesn't disrupt the SANFL as much as the current arrangement, would probably only involve 4-5 SANFL based players each week, and allows another pathway for promising youngsters to impress and get on an AFL list.
Seriously, you guys are obsessed with conspiracy theories .

on the rails wrote:

drifter wrote:With all the debate about the reserves, how about this one?
What if their was a South West conference- Port, Adelaide, West coast and Fremantle
The 2 Neafl conferences- East and North - 18 teams
Total of 22 teams.
SW conference - plays each other twice( 6 games)
And the other 18 conference teams once- half away, half home.
Total of 24 matches- no NAB Cup.
SW games to be played as curtain raisers to AFL
Each AFL club is allocated 4 SANFL clubs to choose a total of 20 top up players at he beginning of the season.
No more than 4 from each club. Can include Under 18 players.Only to be used when their Is not enough AFL listed players to choose from
Top 6- best performed sides over be 3 conferences.
1v6
2v5
3v4
2 lowest ranked losers drop out.
Preliminary finals
Grand final
Let us know your thoughts?

You were doing ok until you suggested what is in bold. Again another AFL Supporter just thinking about what is best for the AFL and not really caring what you do to the SANFL!

Exactly go and get your top up players from the ammos or country footy.
Either that or if you want a top up player from a SANFL side you cough up a decent sum of money

drifter wrote:If you read the title of the post, I never mentioned the SANFL, I reckon you must be on the wrong forum, not me. .

Really? What's the title of this subforum, manure-for-brains? The AFL forum is down the hall (or better, on bigfooty).

So where does it say SANFL?? Expecting a couple of witless insults in return to really let me know you are small minded and have nothing better to offer

Jim05 wrote:

on the rails wrote:

drifter wrote:With all the debate about the reserves, how about this one?
What if their was a South West conference- Port, Adelaide, West coast and Fremantle
The 2 Neafl conferences- East and North - 18 teams
Total of 22 teams.
SW conference - plays each other twice( 6 games)
And the other 18 conference teams once- half away, half home.
Total of 24 matches- no NAB Cup.
SW games to be played as curtain raisers to AFL
Each AFL club is allocated 4 SANFL clubs to choose a total of 20 top up players at he beginning of the season.
No more than 4 from each club. Can include Under 18 players.Only to be used when their Is not enough AFL listed players to choose from
Top 6- best performed sides over be 3 conferences.
1v6
2v5
3v4
2 lowest ranked losers drop out.
Preliminary finals
Grand final
Let us know your thoughts?

You were doing ok until you suggested what is in bold. Again another AFL Supporter just thinking about what is best for the AFL and not really caring what you do to the SANFL!

Exactly go and get your top up players from the ammos or country footy.
Either that or if you want a top up player from a SANFL side you cough up a decent sum of money

Would actually suggest just that. Make a payment to the club involved each time they are used.

No disrespect but....

Great another thread for kickinit to argue in

Oh spare us!!! No doubt kickinit will be rallying the other PAFC "Numpties" to get on this topic too!

Sorry Brodlach, lost me . Who is kickinit ?

drifter wrote:Sorry Brodlach, lost me . Who is kickinit ?

Another selfish one eyed Port supporter! Go and read the AFL Reserves topic and no doubt you will form some alliance with him!

Mate, chill, Sorry I posted something where you may have to look outside your red and white goldfish bowl . All I can say is Go the Cocks !!!!! The name says it all.

on the rails wrote:

drifter wrote:Sorry Brodlach, lost me . Who is kickinit ?

Another selfish one eyed Port supporter! Go and read the AFL Reserves topic and no doubt you will form some alliance with him!

no swearing this time muppet? i'm surprised i havent received any abusive pm lately.

drifter wrote:Mate, chill, Sorry I posted something where you may have to look outside your red and white goldfish bowl . All I can say is Go the Cocks !!!!! The name says it all.

now wait for the abuse to start

Jim05 wrote:

on the rails wrote:

drifter wrote:With all the debate about the reserves, how about this one?
What if their was a South West conference- Port, Adelaide, West coast and Fremantle
The 2 Neafl conferences- East and North - 18 teams
Total of 22 teams.
SW conference - plays each other twice( 6 games)
And the other 18 conference teams once- half away, half home.
Total of 24 matches- no NAB Cup.
SW games to be played as curtain raisers to AFL
Each AFL club is allocated 4 SANFL clubs to choose a total of 20 top up players at he beginning of the season.
No more than 4 from each club. Can include Under 18 players.Only to be used when their Is not enough AFL listed players to choose from
Top 6- best performed sides over be 3 conferences.
1v6
2v5
3v4
2 lowest ranked losers drop out.
Preliminary finals
Grand final
Let us know your thoughts?

You were doing ok until you suggested what is in bold. Again another AFL Supporter just thinking about what is best for the AFL and not really caring what you do to the SANFL!

Exactly go and get your top up players from the ammos or country footy.
Either that or if you want a top up player from a SANFL side you cough up a decent sum of money

or we could just get them to leave their sanfl club go back to ammos and take them that way.

drifter wrote:Sorry Brodlach, lost me . Who is kickinit ?

Any thread that mentions Port, he is like a dog with a bone and just argues just for the sake of it

drifter wrote:Mate, chill, Sorry I posted something where you may have to look outside your red and white goldfish bowl . All I can say is Go the Cocks !!!!! The name says it all.

As opposed to you looking outside your black, white and teal goldfish bowl???

Another FW like kickinit!

I think I'll move this topic to the AFL forum since Einstein didn't realise he'd posted it in the SANFL forum.