SA Footy

Backs - Scarlett Glass Enright
Half backs - R Murphy Ben Reid L Davis
Centres - Thomas Mitchell Pendlebury
Half forwards - Murphy Cloke Swan
Full forwards - Milne Franklin Goodes
Rucks - Cox Judd (vc) Ablett (c).
Interchange - Boyd Dal Santo Kelly Petrie

No Deledio off Half Back ahead of Rob Murphy? So James Kelly has had a better year than Scott Thompson? Plus the skipper was Captain of a team which finished bottom?

was very surprised captain was ablett ahead of judd..

Would have Gibson ahead of Reid

Johno6 wrote:was very surprised captain was ablett ahead of judd..

What utter crap.

Drew Petrie?

MatteeG wrote:Drew Petrie?

Hell Carlton had 3 blokes ahead of him on the goal kicking list and he still gets a gig.....

Marc Murphy on the HFF is a ******* joke.

Thought Scotland was a tad unlucky from a Carlton view.

Juddy V.C

Petrie looks to me like his is the back up ruckman as well as being able to play forward

That may have got him in there ahead of the other forwards in the squad

I don't mind his AA selection TBH

Hondo wrote:Petrie looks to me like his is the back up ruckman as well as being able to play forward

That may have got him in there ahead of the other forwards in the squad

I don't mind his AA selection TBH

I reckon even Dutchy will tell you he is a very average back up ruckman!

I know but he's done well as a forward this year I reckon

He has the added flexibility of being a back up ruck if needed given they haven't selected a second straight ruckman

4 All Australian selections in a row for Corey Enright. Is he really that good?

I have no problems with Gary Ablett as the captain, think he has done enough this year to prove he is not only a fantastic player but a worthy leader. Almost single handedly kept the GC in a lot of games this year.

McPharlin was robbed, he is criminally underrated.

Plenty of other interesting selections, Swan / Petrie / Scarlett / Kelly / Boyd / Murphy

Petrie was fantastic this year, Ive been saying he is an A grader for years, great to see he is finally getting the recognition.

Wells > Murphy on the HBF also

Dutchy wrote:Petrie was fantastic this year, Ive been saying he is an A grader for years, great to see he is finally getting the recognition.

Wells > Murphy on the HBF also

Wells played majority of the year on the wing surely?

Swan was lucky, thompson unlucky, petrie very lucky, goldsteing incredibly unlucky. kelly deserving.

Thought Goldstien would have had a case for back up ruckman role

Aerie wrote:4 All Australian selections in a row for Corey Enright. Is he really that good?

I think he is.

Squids wrote:McPharlin was robbed, he is criminally underrated.

Plenty of other interesting selections, Swan / Petrie / Scarlett / Kelly / Boyd / Murphy

He didn't have a that good of a year did he?

Aerie wrote:4 All Australian selections in a row for Corey Enright. Is he really that good?

Yep. Boris is so reliable back there, a VERY consistent player.

regards,

REB

Dutchy wrote:Petrie was fantastic this year, Ive been saying he is an A grader for years, great to see he is finally getting the recognition.

Wells > Murphy on the HBF also

I'm not unhappy with Petrie's selection. The guy could hardly walk this time last year he was a sad sight. However, Wells ahead of Murphy? Nah.

regards,

REB