SA Footy

Is he in trouble? you never know with this match review panel if Selwood got 4 for something unsighted then Buddy must be due for a little holiday?

Brad wrote:Is he in trouble? you never know with this match review panel if Selwood got 4 for something unsighted then Buddy must be due for a little holiday?

2 weeks. havent seen the slomo tho just the news clip.

Reckon he will get 3. Think he has a pretty bad record from memory

40% loading for his bad record.

Impact is soft
It was high.

It will come down to how they classify it.
Reckless, Negligent, Intentional?

He did shape up for it and tried to get him. Onus is on buddy to make sure he doesn't get him high.

I recon he'll get 2-3.

3, - great way to miss out on the Brownlow, yet it clearly wasn't an accident either.

goneski

clearly flicked out the elbow, selwood gets 4

buddy gets 7 - intentional

MT79... Because you used logic, be guaranteed the AFL will not.

I'm going with 2, plus one for his record, so three, when it was worse than the Selwood incident...

fair call - make it 3 weeks

Likely to get 2 -3 in my opinion. The problem was it was intentional.

He wont get anymore than 3!

He gets bums on seats the AFL wont want a player of his quality sitting in the stands for to long.

Refer to Judds record at the tribunal.

Media Park wrote: when it was worse than the Selwood incident...

I though you said the Selwood vision was so bad he would get off.If the vision was so bad how do you know the
Franklin incident was worse?

whufc wrote:
He gets bums on seats the AFL wont want a player of his quality sitting in the stands for to long.

Didn't stop them the other 3 times he got put away.

redden whites wrote:

whufc wrote:
He gets bums on seats the AFL wont want a player of his quality sitting in the stands for to long.

Didn't stop them the other 3 times he got put away.

He will go for a game or two but there is no way he will get 3+ games like some are suggesting.

He is too valuable to the AFL to have him sitting in the stands over a incident where a player wasnt seriously hurt.

AFL is a business Franklin is one there most marketable players.

The AFL have to be consistent here, sorry buddy but a 3 week holiday is certain.

report will be withdrawn by MRP

daysofourlives wrote:report will be withdrawn by MRP

Ha dreaming!

Nothing in it just a brush, player was able to take his kick afterwards. Should only recieve 1 game for stupidity even with record and with the afl's nancy rules.

The MRP will be consistent. They have footage of the incident so clearly he'll get less than four weeks even with his Cameron Mooney like Record. A slap on the wrist with a wet lettuce leaf with the additional bonus for us of Buddy not being allowed to appear in public without the standard Hawthorn Football Club 'Buddy leash' around his neck.

Taser the bastard I say.

regards,

REB

1 week.

Bum Crack wrote:1 week.

Then Taser the bastard.

regards,

REB