SA Footy

Whilst I acknowledge that its unlikely ever to be brought back I always find it interesting in what people think the teams would look like based on this season.
so if you would like show me your best SA,VIC,NSW,QLD,TAS,WA sides and lets discuss

SA would struggle at the minute id rekon, no-one from Port would make the side. Who's in form in the SANFL?

auto wrote:SA would struggle at the minute id rekon, no-one from Port would make the side. Who's in form in the SANFL?

haha i like it!

Ill give SA a crack

Backs : A.Mackie , B.Rutten, J.Russel
Half Backs : S.Fisher, N.Bock, H.Grundy
Center : R.Griffin, B.Gibbs, C.Enright
Half Fwd : S.Burgoyne, A.Goodes, T.Varcoe
Forwards : A.Didak, M.Pavlich, A.Monfries
Rucks : M.Jamar, A.Cooney, S.Thompson
I/C : J.Trengrove , D.Brogan, G.johncock
Sub : J Allan

* Trengrove of Melbourne variety
** Goodes was born in Wallaroo so I guess we can have him even though he played for Vic in 08
*** Allen from North Adelaide for tearing up the SANFL this year.

This is my opinion, rather then argue, create your own !

Gee not sure about Allan, he wouldnt get a kick at AFL standard.
Not a bad side but shows how poor SA footy has become because we would get flogged by the vics and WA would beat us aswell

James Allan isn't South Australian so not eligible but I can't think of much better at the moment. May have a go later.

Yep would be lucky to get within ten goals of a Vic side.

F: S.Johnson J.Roughead B.Hall
HF: J.Bartel J.Brown P.Chapman
C: S.Pendlebury C.Judd J.Selwood
HB: L.Hodge B.Goddard H.Shaw
B: B.Deledio M.Scarlett M.Boyd

R: S.Mumford N.Dal Santo D.Swan

INT: D.Jolly J.Watson L.Montagna D.Mundy

my bad on Allen, but I genuinely Couldn't think of some one else deserving of a crow eater guernsey lol. shambles !

I know Nick Duigan is from Norwood but is he South Australian, if so i think he would be sereving of a SOO guernsey based on his performances this year.

whufc wrote:Yep would be lucky to get within ten goals of a Vic side.

F: S.Johnson J.Roughead B.Hall
HF: J.Bartel J.Brown P.Chapman
C: S.Pendlebury C.Judd J.Selwood
HB: L.Hodge B.Goddard H.Shaw
B: B.Deledio M.Scarlett M.Boyd

R: S.Mumford N.Dal Santo D.Swan

INT: D.Jolly J.Watson L.Montagna D.Mundy

No room for Gary??

Bum Crack wrote:

whufc wrote:Yep would be lucky to get within ten goals of a Vic side.

F: S.Johnson J.Roughead B.Hall
HF: J.Bartel J.Brown P.Chapman
C: S.Pendlebury C.Judd J.Selwood
HB: L.Hodge B.Goddard H.Shaw
B: B.Deledio M.Scarlett M.Boyd

R: S.Mumford N.Dal Santo D.Swan

INT: D.Jolly J.Watson L.Montagna D.Mundy

No room for Gary??

Dal Santo ahead of Watson and Mundy on the field? Not a bad side though mate.
Reckon a genuine CHB is needed and the side looks bloody good

Bum Crack wrote:

whufc wrote:Yep would be lucky to get within ten goals of a Vic side.

F: S.Johnson J.Roughead B.Hall
HF: J.Bartel J.Brown P.Chapman
C: S.Pendlebury C.Judd J.Selwood
HB: L.Hodge B.Goddard H.Shaw
B: B.Deledio M.Scarlett M.Boyd

R: S.Mumford N.Dal Santo D.Swan

INT: D.Jolly J.Watson L.Montagna D.Mundy

No room for Gary??

Ooops totally forgot

Wack Gary in there and take out Montagna

That is a very very very strong side!

Jim05 wrote:Gee not sure about Allan, he wouldnt get a kick at AFL standard.
Not a bad side but shows how poor SA footy has become because we would get flogged by the vics and WA would beat us aswell

Of course he would. Matt Wright is running around for the Crows and doing well. AFL is a possession game these days, so why wouldn't the leading possie getter in the SANFL get a kick? If Jobe Watson can get a kick, a blind monkey could.

The Sleeping Giant wrote:

Jim05 wrote:Gee not sure about Allan, he wouldnt get a kick at AFL standard.
Not a bad side but shows how poor SA footy has become because we would get flogged by the vics and WA would beat us aswell

Of course he would. Matt Wright is running around for the Crows and doing well. AFL is a possession game these days, so why wouldn't the leading possie getter in the SANFL get a kick? If Jobe Watson can get a kick, a blind monkey could.

Obviously not, last time I looked watson was captain of an AFL side and wright is having a crack at the TOP level while poor jimmy is running around in the SANFL. The guy is a gun at SANFL but there must be a reason why he isnt playing AFL.

all good stuff from you posters. In Major League Baseball in USA they have this All Star game between the two leagues and the teams are chosen by fans ballotting their choices online and even in snail mail and those players with the votes get the guernseys. The media and the know-all celebrity selectors get zero input so it becomes a game between the most popular players. Interesting concept - and I still couldn't see any Port players making the cut if we did it here tch tch tch

For Western Australia this would be my lineup:-

B L. Davis D. Glass A. Grover
HB N. van Berlo H. Taylor S. Hill
C J. Corey M. Priddis S. Wellingham
HF A. Embley L. Franklin M. Le Cras
F H. Ballantyne J. Kennedy B. Matera

R A. Sandilands, D. Kerr, D. Rich

Int: D. Cox, S. Black, D. Swallow, C. Bateman

whufc wrote:I know Nick Duigan is from Norwood but is he South Australian, if so i think he would be sereving of a SOO guernsey based on his performances this year.

Nick Lower?

whufc wrote:I know Nick Duigan is from Norwood but is he South Australian, if so i think he would be sereving of a SOO guernsey based on his performances this year.

Yeah he's an ol' PAC or SPC boy I think....

SJABC wrote:

whufc wrote:I know Nick Duigan is from Norwood but is he South Australian, if so i think he would be sereving of a SOO guernsey based on his performances this year.

Yeah he's an ol' PAC or SPC boy I think....

Pembroke

Constance_Perm wrote:Pembroke

Yeah I knew it was one of the Poofy collages.....