SA Footy

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

according to the coaches (early this year) GAJ is number one which we all know anyway, what i thought interesting was who else got votes, the few we think of are in there, here's the list..

GAJ - 7
Reiwoldt - 4
Judd - 3
Brown - 1
Goodwin - 1

what the heck is SIMON GOODWIN doing among that list?!?

which coach do you reckon voted for him???? a joke if you ask me...

Umm yes, lol, somewhat out of place

Apart from big Browny, I'd say Jimmy Bartel.

Hard as nails and always slogs his guts out.

Jon Brown would be the number 1 player at the moment.

Drop Bear wrote:Apart from big Browny, I'd say Jimmy Bartel.

Hard as nails and always slogs his guts out.

Fair call, if it's possible, I actually reckon Jimmy is underrated in some circles

Constance_Perm wrote:

Drop Bear wrote:Apart from big Browny, I'd say Jimmy Bartel.

Hard as nails and always slogs his guts out.

Fair call, if it's possible, I actually reckon Jimmy is underrated in some circles

if Jim was in another side he would be considered as good as Ablett, but he is outshone by GAJ!

a bit the same as Barlow and Silvagni from Freo... Silvagni has been just as solid as Barlow but doesn't get as much of a mention because of Barlow's first few.

Judd, Brown and Ablett in that order for me.

I couldn't seperate Brown and Ablett if I had to.

Then Judd, Reiwoldt ( when fit obviously ) with Steve Johnson and Goddard as hard to seperate IMO.

Booney wrote:I couldn't seperate Brown and Ablett if I had to.

Then Judd, Reiwoldt ( when fit obviously ) with Steve Johnson and Goddard as hard to seperate IMO.

Steve Johnson??? He's been horrible this season. Always saves his best for you blokes though. Ablett behind Juddy? Yeah, four years ago.

regards,

REB

Johnson is one of the few blokes in the league capable of having 20+ touches and kicking 5 or 6 goals as a small / mid size forward. not many other blokes have that ability. Yes, he does save his best for us and that is part of the reason he is high on my "players to boo and hiss list" .......

I have Brown and Ablett ahead of Judd and others but not by much :

Brown
Ablett
-
Judd
-
-
-
The others

The Pod!

/end of discussion

Goddarrd, Hayes and Bartel i still believe are all underrated somewhat.

Bartel is a brownlow medallists, but as stated above is underrated IMO and is the one the lifts Geelong with the hard ball gets when the side needs. He takes a damn good over head mark aswell.

I rate Goddard in the top 3 players in the comp for impact over the entire ground. He is the complete player. As seenon the weekend, he can play as the number 1 forward, he can play as a half back flanker that racks up touches, and he can also dominate the midfielder.

Hayes, well he is the borometer of St Kilda. He is just hard as nails and i love the way the bloke goes about his football.

For mine, the best players in the comp are.

Brown
Riewoldt
Goddard
Ablett
Bartel
Hayes
Pavlich
Chapman
Johnson S

And thats in order aswell. People will have a dig at the Ablett place, but he is just not as influential as the other 3 IMO

Wedgie wrote:The Pod!

/end of discussion

He'll be remembered about as well as Gavin Excel.

Booney wrote:

Wedgie wrote:The Pod!

/end of discussion

He'll be remembered about as well as Gavin Excel.

You remember him!

regards,

REB

Booney wrote:

Wedgie wrote:The Pod!

/end of discussion

He'll be remembered about as well as Gavin Excel.

They named a spreadsheet after Excel!
Expect Podoware next!
Maybe even an I Pod, hang on, Apple really are ahead of their time!

Booney wrote:

Wedgie wrote:The Pod!

/end of discussion

He'll be remembered about as well as Gavin Excel.

Troy Wilson anyone...?

CoverKing wrote:For mine, the best players in the comp are.

Brown
Riewoldt
Goddard
Ablett
Bartel
Hayes
Pavlich
Chapman
Johnson S

And thats in order aswell. People will have a dig at the Ablett place, but he is just not as influential as the other 3 IMO

So no Judd for you ?

Tubby wrote:Jon Brown would be the number 1 player at the moment.

Agreed he's my number one, followed closely by Ablett

SJABC wrote:

CoverKing wrote:For mine, the best players in the comp are.

Brown
Riewoldt
Goddard
Ablett
Bartel
Hayes
Pavlich
Chapman
Johnson S

And thats in order aswell. People will have a dig at the Ablett place, but he is just not as influential as the other 3 IMO

So no Judd for you ?

Forgot about Judd.

In between Pavlich and Chapman!

Judd, 1st game of the year - dominated.
Brown
Ablett