SA Footy

What a joke.

l

bit harsh, better than rucci's attempt, its a tough gig picking 50 gun players, after the top 10 it gets pretty even....

lincolnsdirtysecrets wrote:What a joke.

This guy is not a real good judge

Yeah, what would Roo know about footy??

I think what needs to be remembered with Roo's list is, IIRC, he mentions these would be the 50 players he would want to start a new franchise with, as the Gold Coast are attempting to do at present. In that light, I thought it was pretty well right on the money, not just about proven form in past years, but potential for years to come.

The Jack wrote:I think what needs to be remembered with Roo's list is, IIRC, he mentions these would be the 50 players he would want to start a new franchise with, as the Gold Coast are attempting to do at present. In that light, I thought it was pretty well right on the money, not just about proven form in past years, but potential for years to come.

Exactly.. this list is Roo's list not lincolnsdirtysecrets' list.

valleys07 wrote:bit harsh, better than rucci's attempt, its a tough gig picking 50 gun players, after the top 10 it gets pretty even....

Agreed, much better

How about the Roo's club by club preview in the Sunday Mail?

He mentioned Shaun Burgoyne and "I cant trust a bloke who can walk out on a club like that".....big call. I agree, but a big call nonetheless.

Booney wrote:How about the Roo's club by club preview in the Sunday Mail?

He mentioned Shaun Burgoyne and "I cant trust a bloke who can walk out on a club like that".....big call. I agree, but a big call nonetheless.

Yeah cause Roo is a real man of morals

Pot calling the kettle black if i've ever heard it.

mypaddock wrote:

Booney wrote:How about the Roo's club by club preview in the Sunday Mail?

He mentioned Shaun Burgoyne and "I cant trust a bloke who can walk out on a club like that".....big call. I agree, but a big call nonetheless.

Yeah cause Roo is a real man of morals

Pot calling the kettle black if i've ever heard it.

Please explain.

Bum Crack wrote:

mypaddock wrote:

Booney wrote:How about the Roo's club by club preview in the Sunday Mail?

He mentioned Shaun Burgoyne and "I cant trust a bloke who can walk out on a club like that".....big call. I agree, but a big call nonetheless.

Yeah cause Roo is a real man of morals

Pot calling the kettle black if i've ever heard it.

Please explain.

X2. I dont recall Roo leaving Adelaide for another club when they were struggling and on the rebuild.

Booney wrote:

Bum Crack wrote:

mypaddock wrote:

Booney wrote:How about the Roo's club by club preview in the Sunday Mail?

He mentioned Shaun Burgoyne and "I cant trust a bloke who can walk out on a club like that".....big call. I agree, but a big call nonetheless.

Yeah cause Roo is a real man of morals

Pot calling the kettle black if i've ever heard it.

Please explain.

X2. I dont recall Roo leaving Adelaide for another club when they were struggling and on the rebuild.

I wasn't speaking in terms of football (more him away from football) , just blew me away that he would have a public dig at someones character, when his is questionable at best.

But yes, I agree, a good footballer and club man.

What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

mypaddock wrote:

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

Well why say it in the first place if you can't back it up??

Bum Crack wrote:

mypaddock wrote:

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

Well why say it in the first place if you can't back it up??

I can back it up, but I know it'd just get deleted anyway.
Thought more people in the general public would be aware- obviously not.

Roo's criticism was at a player walking out on a club. Apples for apples - Roo never did the same.

mypaddock wrote:

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

Then you should never have posted it in the first place - says something about you mate

Either that or pm the interested parties.

Jimmy_041 wrote:

mypaddock wrote:

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

Then you should never have posted it in the first place - says something about you mate

Not sure how you came to that conclusion. Anyway, all i was saying is that I was a little stunned to see what he had written in the article re questioning Burgoynes character.

End of talk on the topic.

mypaddock wrote:

Jimmy_041 wrote:

mypaddock wrote:

Voice wrote:What's he done outside of footy that's questionable? You've still got me stumped.

This forum isn't the place for posting such things, so I'm not going to go into it.

Then you should never have posted it in the first place - says something about you mate

Not sure how you came to that conclusion. Anyway, all i was saying is that I was a little stunned to see what he had written in the article re questioning Burgoynes character.

End of talk on the topic.

mate, my older brother has a very close relationship through with roo, it started off professional, but over the years they've obviously got to know each other pretty well to the point where there relationship isn't purely professional. and i know my brother wouldnt tell me absolutely everything he knows, but he would at least indicate to me if the great roo is "of shady character". and more to the point, i don't care who he is, my brother wouldnt want to be involved with someone like you are suggesting he is.