Page 1 of 1

NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 3:55 pm
by Thiele
Mount Gambier Saturday afternoon

Re: NAB cup Challang Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 5:13 pm
by Groover
Does anyone else think its funny that a title that has Port and Collingwood also has incorrect spelling?

Re: NAB cup Challang Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 8:07 pm
by carey
Groover wrote:Does anyone else think its funny that a title that has Port and Collingwood also has incorrect spelling?


i guess not! :lol:

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 7:12 pm
by Thiele
Port lost by 81 points

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2010 8:08 pm
by brod
Not good that they lost the last quarter by 40 points.

Collingwood 27.16 (178)
Port 15.7 (97)

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 9:18 am
by stan
brod wrote:Not good that they lost the last quarter by 40 points.

Collingwood 27.16 (178)
Port 15.7 (97)


I guess for Port fans it shows that they are still a way of this year. Collingwood with there new recurits are going to be a contender, and Port as I put up here previously in my opinion will finish around 9 - 12th.

However some good points for port, by all reports Rob Gray was good and Pearce was good as well.

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 11:00 am
by NO-MERCY
I read Jacob Surjons comments a few weeks back 'we are tougher'!
Could of fooled me!!!
Back to reality :oops:

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 11:03 am
by Ruben Carter
stan wrote:
brod wrote:Not good that they lost the last quarter by 40 points.

Collingwood 27.16 (178)
Port 15.7 (97)


I guess for Port fans it shows that they are still a way of this year. Collingwood with there new recurits are going to be a contender, and Port as I put up here previously in my opinion will finish around 9 - 12th.

However some good points for port, by all reports Rob Gray was good and Pearce was good as well.

Don't think that loss is a true form guide. I'd say read more into the loss to Western Bulldogs last weekend in Melbourne.
Very, very unlucky to lose that to arguably the best side going around at the minute. And there was no doubt both sides were there to win whereas yesterdays game was nothing more than a practice session for both sides.

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 11:05 am
by Ruben Carter
NO-MERCY wrote:I read Jacob Surjons comments a few weeks back 'we are tougher'!
Could of fooled me!!!
Back to reality :oops:

So does that mean you saw the match, no idea?

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 11:10 am
by NO-MERCY
No need to see the match.
The score paints a perfect picture. :oops:

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 11:11 am
by Ruben Carter
NO-MERCY wrote:No need to see the match.
The score paints a perfect picture. :oops:

That just proves you have no idea..

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 12:02 pm
by auto
NO-MERCY wrote:No need to see the match.
The score paints a perfect picture. :oops:


Not sure that scoreboards paint perfect pictures NM....do you think that Port will be a 50 point better side than the Crows this year coz of what happened in Rd1 NAB Cup?

Personally i think we will have good and bad this year, same as last but with direction for the future this year by playing young guns where theyll get exposure....

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 12:47 pm
by stan
Ruben Carter wrote:
stan wrote:
brod wrote:Not good that they lost the last quarter by 40 points.

Collingwood 27.16 (178)
Port 15.7 (97)


I guess for Port fans it shows that they are still a way of this year. Collingwood with there new recurits are going to be a contender, and Port as I put up here previously in my opinion will finish around 9 - 12th.

However some good points for port, by all reports Rob Gray was good and Pearce was good as well.

Don't think that loss is a true form guide. I'd say read more into the loss to Western Bulldogs last weekend in Melbourne.
Very, very unlucky to lose that to arguably the best side going around at the minute. And there was no doubt both sides were there to win whereas yesterdays game was nothing more than a practice session for both sides.


In my option I still think Port are a few years away from where collingwood are. I believe collingwood have the potential to be a top4 side and a real contender and Port are at the moment probably slighty outside the 8, however I would not be surpised if Port did make the 8.

I guess its hard to gauge at this time of year regardless.

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 2:31 pm
by NO-MERCY
Very much so Stan, Collingwood are far more advanced than Port.
Alot of Port supporters & players were getting far to carried away with their NAB Cup form.
I don't want to be to hard on Port & their band of supporters but i'm hoping they can make the 8 :ympray: but its doubtful.

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 7:15 pm
by Chuck Wepner
NO-MERCY wrote:Very much so Stan, Collingwood are far more advanced than Port.
Alot of Port supporters & players were getting far to carried away with their NAB Cup form.
I don't want to be to hard on Port & their band of supporters but i'm hoping they can make the 8 :ympray: but its doubtful.

not doubtful - i have no doubt they wont make the 8. they might beat Freo, Melborne,Richmand and possibly the Crows but that wont be enough to avoid a bottom 4 finish :-({|=

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2010 7:20 pm
by GWW
This is a no trolling zone Chuck, that violin isn't welcome on here.

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Thu Mar 18, 2010 7:54 am
by stan
Chuck Wepner wrote:
NO-MERCY wrote:Very much so Stan, Collingwood are far more advanced than Port.
Alot of Port supporters & players were getting far to carried away with their NAB Cup form.
I don't want to be to hard on Port & their band of supporters but i'm hoping they can make the 8 :ympray: but its doubtful.

not doubtful - i have no doubt they wont make the 8. they might beat Freo, Melborne,Richmand and possibly the Crows but that wont be enough to avoid a bottom 4 finish :-({|=


Welcome abord chuck, might pay for you to have a read of this first before you post in the Port or Crows thread : viewtopic.php?f=34&t=24426

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Thu Mar 18, 2010 6:35 pm
by Chuck Wepner
stan wrote:
Chuck Wepner wrote:
NO-MERCY wrote:Very much so Stan, Collingwood are far more advanced than Port.
Alot of Port supporters & players were getting far to carried away with their NAB Cup form.
I don't want to be to hard on Port & their band of supporters but i'm hoping they can make the 8 :ympray: but its doubtful.

not doubtful - i have no doubt they wont make the 8. they might beat Freo, Melborne,Richmand and possibly the Crows but that wont be enough to avoid a bottom 4 finish :-({|=


Welcome abord chuck, might pay for you to have a read of this first before you post in the Port or Crows thread : viewtopic.php?f=34&t=24426

i think the power will be undefeated premiers for the next 3 saesons

Re: NAB cup Challenge Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Fri Mar 19, 2010 12:01 pm
by devilsadvocate
Chuck Wepner wrote:
stan wrote:
Chuck Wepner wrote:
NO-MERCY wrote:Very much so Stan, Collingwood are far more advanced than Port.
Alot of Port supporters & players were getting far to carried away with their NAB Cup form.
I don't want to be to hard on Port & their band of supporters but i'm hoping they can make the 8 :ympray: but its doubtful.

not doubtful - i have no doubt they wont make the 8. they might beat Freo, Melborne,Richmand and possibly the Crows but that wont be enough to avoid a bottom 4 finish :-({|=


Welcome abord chuck, might pay for you to have a read of this first before you post in the Port or Crows thread : viewtopic.php?f=34&t=24426

i think the power will be undefeated premiers for the next 3 saesons


do you have bipolar chuck?

Re: NAB cup Challang Port vs Collingwood

PostPosted: Fri Mar 19, 2010 3:49 pm
by Barto
Groover wrote:Does anyone else think its funny that a title that has Port and Collingwood also has incorrect spelling?


http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/breaki ... 5842793554