SA Footy

With the mid-season break just been, rate crows players from 1-10 based on personal performances.

Johncock 5
Rutten 6
Doughty 8
Mcleod 6
Bock 8
Otten 9
Mackay 8
Goodwin 5
Edwards 8
Petrenko 4
Dangerfield 5
Maric 4
Moran 4
Stevens 6
Reilly 3
Walker 7
Tippett 8
Porplyzia 7
Douglas 6
Griffin 2
Knights 9
Shirley 2
Symes 5
Thompson 7
Van Berlo 6
Vince 7

I'm pretty happy with your ratings.
I might give Petrenko 5, allowing for limited opportunities, and promise.
Dangerfield is close to earning a 6 after a few more games perhaps.
Taylor Walker I might drop to 6 - he still needs to learn not to sit back and disappear a bit.

Iam happy with your ratings

acockfromwayback wrote:With the mid-season break just been, rate crows players from 1-10 based on personal performances.

Johncock 5 7
Rutten 6
Doughty 8 6 bad start good last few weeks
Mcleod 64
Bock 8 6 injury and suspension has interrupted his season but form has been ok
Otten 9
Mackay 8
Goodwin 5
Edwards 8
Petrenko 4 5
Dangerfield 56
Maric 4
Moran 4
Stevens 6 5
Reilly 3
Walker 7
Tippett 8
Porplyzia 7
Douglas 6
Griffin 2
Knights 9
Shirley 2
Symes 5
Thompson 7 8
Van Berlo 6 5
Vince 7

They are the changes in blue that i would make.

Player ratings are difficult because it depends on what benchmark you are measuring them against ... each other? / internal stats? / the ideal AFL footballer? / their own KPIs set by the coaches?

On stats alone - Danger may be a 5 compared to Thompson's 8. But in terms of his age and inexperience he may be performing to 9/10 of the Coaches' expectations of him, at this stage of his development. Based on NC interviews, that are really happy with him so a mark of 5/10 seems too low.

Here's mine. Been very happy with the whole team although fringe players haven't shown enough and would like to see more out of Van Berlo.

Johncock 7
Rutten 7
Doughty 7
Mcleod 4
Bock 8
Otten 9
Mackay 7
Goodwin 7
Edwards 8
Petrenko 5
Dangerfield 6
Maric 4
Moran 4
Stevens 7
Reilly 3
Walker 7
Tippett 8
Porplyzia 8
Douglas 6
Griffin 2
Knights 9
Shirley 2
Symes 5
Thompson 8
Van Berlo 6
Vince 8

i love the way dangerfield goes about his business. he is quickly becoming one of my favourite players, and i hate the crows!