SA Footy

I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Most overrated: Justin Koschitzke

Most overrated:- Scott Thompson

dinglinga wrote:Most overrated:- Scott Thompson

good call followed closely by Brett Burton.

FS - Nik Fosdike is dead set ordinary. Not sure how you can label him underrated.

regards,

REB

Most overrated: Brian Lake. Noone else is close.

brian lake overrated?? i wouldnt say that, maybe abit inconsistant, but when he's on, he goes alright running the ball out of defence.

overrated - steven milne. would average 3 holding the balls a game i rekon, just from trying stupid, selfish things.

underrated - a few names in my head, but i really like the way brock mclean goes about his game.cant really say why, coz i dont know why, but i like watching him!!

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

Daniel Bradshaw is very much under-rated compared to his forward line offsider, JB.

TroyGFC wrote:Daniel Bradshaw is very much under-rated compared to his forward line offsider, JB.

yep, Daniel Bradshaw is a gun! I would have him in my team any day!

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

scottiemc wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

yet tell me which finals game he has been all class

Scott Thompson is one of the best midfielders in the AFL. I think any opponent would vouch for that.

Under rated: I've always liked Nathan Jones' hardness at it

scottiemc wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells
Most Underrated: Scott Stevens, David Rodan, Shaun Higgins, Jarrad McVeigh, Nick Fosdike, Andrew Carrazzo

Scott Thompson is all class, and how can you say Higgins is underrated when hes only had a couple of years and was injured most of last year?

If you consider turning the ball over as classy,sure.

Most overrated.....

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/Players/tabid/8088/default.aspx

Dutchy wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

tedbullpit wrote:

Dutchy wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

Not implying anything, just interesting

Wells has NEVER been mentioned as a top tier elite player...

Peter Burgoyne and Rioli Superstars? now you are kidding yourself.....

Dutchy wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:

Dutchy wrote:

tedbullpit wrote:I'll start us off: -
Most Overrated: Jeff Farmer, O'Loughlin, DalSanto, Ball, X.Clarke, R.Clarke, Jared Brennan, Daniel Wells

Here we go again

Seems strange out of the 8 you have picked there 6 of them are indigenous? Any reason for that?

What are you implying dutchy?

I am merely expressing an opinion. By all means agree or disagree; this is a forum after all; however it is disappointing that you seem to be implying something else.

All the players I have listed have been at one time or another mentioned as being in the AFL's top tier elite players when I dont think they deserve to be. The fact that 6 of the 8 are indigenous is coincidental. I certainly think players like the Burgoyne brothers, Cyril Rioli & Andrew McLeod are superstars. The guys I have listed are not.

Not implying anything, just interesting

Wells has NEVER been mentioned as a top tier elite player...

Peter Burgoyne and Rioli Superstars? now you are kidding yourself.....

Whatever Dutchy. Doesn't sound like it. You are flog.

Mackie by a mile hes a B grader

silicone skyline wrote:
Under rated: I've always liked Nathan Jones' hardness at it

Agree. Good young player. Also Young and Ladson at Hawthorn

Overrated - Stephen Milne.

Always thought Fraser Gehrig was overrated. He was a good player, but not a superstar.

Daniel Wells overrated? Surely, Dutchy, he hasn't lived up to expectations.