How Many Games?

[Punk Rooster]

Will Steven Browne get for his cheap shot on Porplyzia?
I'm suggesting 6-8 games.
As bad as the Hall hit, not quite as bad as Solomon on Ling

[hearts on fire]

I didn't really think it was that bad.... im thinking maybe 2-3 weeks.

[Dutchy]

2 Max, considering it was his shoulder that got him, incidental if anything

[Punk Rooster]

2 Max, considering it was his shoulder that got him, incidental if anything

are we talking about the same incident????
Carlton player pushes Porplyzia into the path of a Browne, who throws a quick punch!

[Thiele]

1-2 weeks there was nothing in it Porps got pushed into him by another Carlton Player

[Dutchy]

the vision I saw his head went straight into his shoulder....happy to be corrected but thats what I saw

[Punk Rooster]

i watched the replay at the BBC (Bombay Bicycle Club), & they repeated the footage- i take it you guys are assuming he was knocked out from the left shoulder? Browne appeared to hit him with a right fist....
All this happened whilst tha ball was dead.

[Hondo]

The lack of clear vision (well, what we saw yesterday anyway) would make it tough to prove what looks like a cheap shot

My take on it was that the Carlton players were testing his shoulder all game and this was another opportunity taken. Worst thing was it was off the ball. Whether they missed his shoulder and accidently concussed him I'm not sure. Consussion was why he went off. Probably a shoulder-tester that went wrong.

Whether it can be proven is the issue

What about Milburn's tackle last night .... anyone see it? Reminiscent of the tackle on Bassett in the Showdown so prob no case to answer.

[Thiele]

nothing in it

[gadj1976]

2 Max, considering it was his shoulder that got him, incidental if anything

are we talking about the same incident????
Carlton player pushes Porplyzia into the path of a Browne, who throws a quick punch!

Punch?

I must've seen a different incident.

[locky801]

i watched the replay at the BBC (Bombay Bicycle Club), & they repeated the footage- i take it you guys are assuming he was knocked out from the left shoulder? Browne appeared to hit him with a right fist....
All this happened whilst tha ball was dead.

Am with you on this one Punk for a change, I reckon 5 to 6

[MW]

maybe get 2 for "swinging" his shoulder

[the joker]

well with the tribunal the way it works

it is off intentional contact, severe impact, behind play , and high contact.
for a total of 11 activation points and straight to the tribunal

[MW]

his intent was not to knock him out though. The fact Porps got pushed into Browne will reduce the majority of the penalty. Gibbs was worse on Edwards IMHO

[the joker]

his intent was not to knock him out though. The fact Porps got pushed into Browne will reduce the majority of the penalty. Gibbs was worse on Edwards IMHO

but he intentionally hit his head/shoulder.

[Punk Rooster]

i'm not a Crows fan, so I don't care either way, but this is not good...

[Booney]

I think you are over reacting on this one Punky.From what I saw it was his shoulder that hit him,and I think there may not even be a case to answer too.Certainly not a 5 or 6 weeker and no fist IMO was used.

[Dog_ger]

Argued real bad with Mrs_Dog_ger over this.

I saw nothing in it on live TV...

She saw the entire incodent on radio...

Dog_ger says play on.

Mrs_Dog_ger says 6 games....

[SCD]

Football = zero weeks

Netball = 2-3 weeks

Ballet = 5-6 weeks

we will really see where this game has gone this weekend..

IMO the titch edwards & robert harvey incidents were worse then this one.

[Dirko]

Punch?

I must've seen a different incident.

I'm with gadj. I was down at that end when it happened and my view was a Carlton person maybe Walker, pushed Porplyzia, purposely and pointedly and per functionally punctuated the point of Browne's permeating shoulder.....

Didn't see any punch, and the ways the Crows reacted I don't think they saw much in it either....

P.S Good catching up with ya gadj !!