SA Footy

Is this a first that a player has captained 2 clubs with Judd captaining Carlton and WEst Coast.

No, there's a few out there because of the days when guys were captain-coaches, or when clubs would poach a player and install him as captain. Barassi did Melbourne and Carlton, Dan Minogue did two clubs into Grand Finals in the early 20th century, Barry Davis, Des tuddenham etc. I don't have the full list in front of me but there's a few of them

Did Peter Moore ever captain Melbourne?

You motivated me to look it up. There's a few guys in here though who only 1-2 matches at one or both of the clubs. This list below has 29 guys who were appointed at two clubs, one appointed at three clubs and then 55 who were acting captain or fill in at more than one club.

Ron Barassi - melbourne and carlton
Syd Barker - essendon and North Melbourne
Peter Bell - North Melbourne (only as a fill in) and Fremantle
Brad Boyd - Fitzroy and Brisbane Lions (as a fill in)
Dermott Brereton - as a fill in at both Hawthorn and Sydney
Charlie Cameron - North Melbourne and Fitzroy
Roy Cazaly - St Kilda and South Melbourne
Bert Chadwick - Melbourne and Hawthorn
Daniel Chick - as a fill in at both West Coast and Hawthorn
Ansell Clarke - at Carlton and St Kilda
David Cloke - Richmond and a fill in at Collingwood
Dick Condon - Collingwood and Richmond
bill Cubbins - St Kilda and Footscray
Barry Davis - Essendon and North Melbourne
Brighton Diggins - South Melbourne and Carlton
Carl Ditterich - St Kilda and Melbourne
Wels Eicke - St Kilda and North Melbourne
Peter Everitt - fill in at St Kilda and Hawthorn
tom Fitzmaurice - fill in at Geelong and Kangaroos
tom Fogarty - south melbourne and university
Les Foote - North Melbourne and St Kilda
Keith Forbes - Essendon and North Melbourne
Ross glendinning - fill in at North Melbourne and then West Coast
Gerard Healy - fill in at Melbourne and Sydney
George Haines - Geelong, Melbourne and St Kilda
Len Incigneri - Richmond and Melbourne
Alex Jesaulenko - Carlton and St Kilda
Maurie Johnson - Carlton and South melbourne
Bert Lenne - fill in at Fitzroy and St Kilda
John Francis - North Melbourne and Melbourne
Alistair Lynch - fill at Fiztroy and then Brisbane
Ivan McAlpine - Footscray and Hawthorn
Con McCarthy - Collingwood and Footscray
Jack McKenzie - Essendon and Melbourne
Dan Minogue - Collingwood, Richmond and Hawthorn
Colin Niven - Fitzroy, Melbourne
Charlie Pannam - Collingwood, South Melbourne
Stephen Paxman - fill in at Fitzroy and Port Adelaide
Bernie Quinlan - fill in at Footscray and Fitzroy
Charlie Ricketts - South Melbourne and fill in at St Kilda
Paul Salmon - fill in at Essendon and Hawthorn
Paddy Scanlan - Soputh Melbourne and Footscray
Billy Schmidt - Richmond and fill in at St Kilda
Norm Smith - Melbourne and Fitzroy
Dick Taylor - fill in at Melbourne and then North Melbourne
Bill thomas - South Melbourne and Richmond
Len Thomas - fSouth Melbourne, Hawthorn and North Melbourne
Des Tuddenham - Collingwood and Essendon
Charlie Tyson - Collingwood and North Melbourne
Jack Wells - St Kilda and Carlton
mark Williams -Collingwood and fill in at Brisbane Bears
Paul Williams - fill in at Collingwood and Sydney
Carl Willis - fill in at University and South Melbourne
Percy Wilson -Collingwood and Melbourne

rogernumber10 wrote:You motivated me to look it up. There's a few guys in here though who only 1-2 matches at one or both of the clubs. This list below has 29 guys who were appointed at two clubs, one appointed at three clubs and then 55 who were acting captain or fill in at more than one club.

Ron Barassi - melbourne and carlton
Syd Barker - essendon and North Melbourne
Peter Bell - North Melbourne (only as a fill in) and Fremantle
Brad Boyd - Fitzroy and Brisbane Lions (as a fill in)
Dermott Brereton - as a fill in at both Hawthorn and Sydney
Charlie Cameron - North Melbourne and Fitzroy
Roy Cazaly - St Kilda and South Melbourne
Bert Chadwick - Melbourne and Hawthorn
Daniel Chick - as a fill in at both West Coast and Hawthorn
Ansell Clarke - at Carlton and St Kilda
David Cloke - Richmond and a fill in at Collingwood
Dick Condon - Collingwood and Richmond
bill Cubbins - St Kilda and Footscray
Barry Davis - Essendon and North Melbourne
Brighton Diggins - South Melbourne and Carlton
Carl Ditterich - St Kilda and Melbourne
Wels Eicke - St Kilda and North Melbourne
Peter Everitt - fill in at St Kilda and Hawthorn
tom Fitzmaurice - fill in at Geelong and Kangaroos
tom Fogarty - south melbourne and university
Les Foote - North Melbourne and St Kilda
Keith Forbes - Essendon and North Melbourne
Ross glendinning - fill in at North Melbourne and then West Coast
Gerard Healy - fill in at Melbourne and Sydney
George Haines - Geelong, Melbourne and St Kilda
Len Incigneri - Richmond and Melbourne
Alex Jesaulenko - Carlton and St Kilda
Maurie Johnson - Carlton and South melbourne
Bert Lenne - fill in at Fitzroy and St Kilda
John Francis - North Melbourne and Melbourne
Alistair Lynch - fill at Fiztroy and then Brisbane
Ivan McAlpine - Footscray and Hawthorn
Con McCarthy - Collingwood and Footscray
Jack McKenzie - Essendon and Melbourne
Dan Minogue - Collingwood, Richmond and Hawthorn
Colin Niven - Fitzroy, Melbourne
Charlie Pannam - Collingwood, South Melbourne
Stephen Paxman - fill in at Fitzroy and Port Adelaide
Bernie Quinlan - fill in at Footscray and Fitzroy
Charlie Ricketts - South Melbourne and fill in at St Kilda
Paul Salmon - fill in at Essendon and Hawthorn
Paddy Scanlan - Soputh Melbourne and Footscray
Billy Schmidt - Richmond and fill in at St Kilda
Norm Smith - Melbourne and Fitzroy
Dick Taylor - fill in at Melbourne and then North Melbourne
Bill thomas - South Melbourne and Richmond
Len Thomas - fSouth Melbourne, Hawthorn and North Melbourne
Des Tuddenham - Collingwood and Essendon
Charlie Tyson - Collingwood and North Melbourne
Jack Wells - St Kilda and Carlton
mark Williams -Collingwood and fill in at Brisbane Bears
Paul Williams - fill in at Collingwood and Sydney
Carl Willis - fill in at University and South Melbourne
Percy Wilson -Collingwood and Melbourne

That is sensational research

rogernumber10 wrote:tom Fogarty - south melbourne and university

Also rhythm guitarist for Creedence Clearwater Revival.....

rogernumber10 wrote:You motivated me to look it up. There's a few guys in here though who only 1-2 matches at one or both of the clubs. This list below has 29 guys who were appointed at two clubs, one appointed at three clubs and then 55 who were acting captain or fill in at more than one club.

Ron Barassi - melbourne and carlton
Syd Barker - essendon and North Melbourne
Peter Bell - North Melbourne (only as a fill in) and Fremantle
Brad Boyd - Fitzroy and Brisbane Lions (as a fill in)
Dermott Brereton - as a fill in at both Hawthorn and Sydney
Charlie Cameron - North Melbourne and Fitzroy
Roy Cazaly - St Kilda and South Melbourne
Bert Chadwick - Melbourne and Hawthorn
Daniel Chick - as a fill in at both West Coast and Hawthorn
Ansell Clarke - at Carlton and St Kilda
David Cloke - Richmond and a fill in at Collingwood
Dick Condon - Collingwood and Richmond
bill Cubbins - St Kilda and Footscray
Barry Davis - Essendon and North Melbourne
Brighton Diggins - South Melbourne and Carlton
Carl Ditterich - St Kilda and Melbourne
Wels Eicke - St Kilda and North Melbourne
Peter Everitt - fill in at St Kilda and Hawthorn
tom Fitzmaurice - fill in at Geelong and Kangaroos
tom Fogarty - south melbourne and university
Les Foote - North Melbourne and St Kilda
Keith Forbes - Essendon and North Melbourne
Ross glendinning - fill in at North Melbourne and then West Coast
Gerard Healy - fill in at Melbourne and Sydney
George Haines - Geelong, Melbourne and St Kilda
Len Incigneri - Richmond and Melbourne
Alex Jesaulenko - Carlton and St Kilda
Maurie Johnson - Carlton and South melbourne
Bert Lenne - fill in at Fitzroy and St Kilda
John Francis - North Melbourne and Melbourne
Alistair Lynch - fill at Fiztroy and then Brisbane
Ivan McAlpine - Footscray and Hawthorn
Con McCarthy - Collingwood and Footscray
Jack McKenzie - Essendon and Melbourne
Dan Minogue - Collingwood, Richmond and Hawthorn
Colin Niven - Fitzroy, Melbourne
Charlie Pannam - Collingwood, South Melbourne
Stephen Paxman - fill in at Fitzroy and Port Adelaide
Bernie Quinlan - fill in at Footscray and Fitzroy
Charlie Ricketts - South Melbourne and fill in at St Kilda
Paul Salmon - fill in at Essendon and Hawthorn
Paddy Scanlan - Soputh Melbourne and Footscray
Billy Schmidt - Richmond and fill in at St Kilda
Norm Smith - Melbourne and Fitzroy
Dick Taylor - fill in at Melbourne and then North Melbourne
Bill thomas - South Melbourne and Richmond
Len Thomas - fSouth Melbourne, Hawthorn and North Melbourne
Des Tuddenham - Collingwood and Essendon
Charlie Tyson - Collingwood and North Melbourne
Jack Wells - St Kilda and Carlton
mark Williams -Collingwood and fill in at Brisbane Bears
Paul Williams - fill in at Collingwood and Sydney
Carl Willis - fill in at University and South Melbourne
Percy Wilson -Collingwood and Melbourne

Brilliant stuff there Roger!!